Blog
Car insurance affordability for low-income households: the evidence
How researchers measure the car insurance burden on lower-income households, what the data shows about ZIP, credit and age, and which programs exist.
Lower-income households pay the same kind of premium as everyone else, but the same dollar amount takes a larger bite out of a smaller income, and several studies find that some of these households are also quoted more for the same driving record. No single number settles how big the burden is: the answer depends on whether researchers divide by median income, compare quotes, or count who is uninsured. Two states, California and New Jersey, run programs aimed at low-income drivers, and a handful of everyday steps can lower the bill in any state.
This article walks through the measures researchers use, what the Federal Insurance Office and the Insurance Research Council each found, what the evidence says about ZIP code, credit and age, how the two state programs work, and what a driver can check in practice. It relies on pages opened for this article in November 2026. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) blocked automated downloads of its database report, so no NAIC premium figure is quoted here.
How researchers measure the burden
"Affordable" has no legal definition. Three yardsticks are in common use, and they answer different questions.
Premium divided by median household income. The Insurance Research Council (IRC), an insurance-industry research group, calculates an affordability index as the ratio of average auto insurance expenditures to median household income, using Census income data and NAIC expenditure data. The IRC's brief says the goal is not to set a threshold at which insurance becomes affordable, because any threshold would be subjective; the index is a tool for comparing years and states (IRC, Personal Auto Insurance Affordability: Countrywide Trends and State Comparisons, checked November 2026). Its brief also says that analysis looks at the overall population and does not address underserved populations, which would require more granular data.
Premium for minimum coverage divided by ZIP-code income. The Treasury Department's Federal Insurance Office (FIO) built its own index. In its January 2017 study, FIO defined affordability as the ratio of the average annual written liability premium in the voluntary market to the median household income in a ZIP code, and it treated a ratio above two percent as presumptively unaffordable. It chose two percent because, in its words, the average U.S. household spends approximately two percent of annual income on personal auto insurance (FIO, Study on the Affordability of Personal Automobile Insurance, January 2017). Our companion piece on The Federal Insurance Office's study of auto insurance affordability covers the method in more depth.
Quotes for identical drivers in different places. The Consumer Federation of America (CFA), a consumer advocacy group, took a third approach in a 2015 report: it collected quotes from the five largest insurers for the same hypothetical good driver in different ZIP codes and compared the averages (CFA press release, November 18, 2015).
Each measure has a blind spot. The ratio to median income says nothing about a household that earns half the median. The FIO ratio uses minimum-limits liability premiums, yet FIO itself notes that many consumers buy more than the minimum, and that the lower a family's median income, the more likely it is to buy at the minimum. The CFA method shows price differences between places for the same driver but cannot say whether insurers' loss costs explain them.
What the federal study found
FIO identified 9,172 ZIP codes in which "affected persons," meaning low- and moderate-income or majority-minority populations, made up half or more of residents, about 28 percent of all ZIP codes. In 845 of them the index exceeded two percent, and those ZIP codes held over 18.6 million people (FIO 2017 study).
Two cautions from the study itself deserve attention.
- FIO says the index allows comparison of ZIP codes within the same state but should not be used to compare states, and that it is not meant to guide budgeting for any individual.
- The study uses 2017-era data. Premiums have changed a great deal since. The IRC brief opened for this article says average expenditure per vehicle was $1,127 in 2022, up 6.1 percent from 2021, and that personal auto losses rose 14 percent annualized between 2020 and 2024 while premiums rose 9 percent annualized (IRC, checked November 2026). When losses outrun premiums, insurers ask for increases, so a 2017 snapshot likely understates today's burden. That inference is ours; neither source states it.
The study's state examples show how much geography matters. In California, FIO found Affordability Index values in the AP ZIP codes ranging from 0.12 percent to 3.00 percent, with a median of 0.66 percent. In Florida the range was 0.42 percent to 5.15 percent, with a median of 1.69 percent. FIO's study says California prohibits considering ZIP codes in setting auto rates, while the California regulation cited below groups garaging locations into bands of ZIP codes or census tracts, so the exact rule is worth confirming with the Department. Either way, a state's rules, not just incomes, shape the pattern.
ZIP code, credit and age: what each does
Rating factors differ by state, and a lower-income household can be affected by each of them in a different way.
ZIP code
In most states, insurers group addresses into rating territories and charge different base rates for each. FIO lists location of residence among the standard pricing factors and ties it to the probability of accidents, which is often higher in more densely populated areas, and to the likelihood of natural-hazard damage. CFA's 2015 findings are the best-known challenge to this practice. It reported average quotes of $1,060 in predominantly African American ZIP codes against $622 in predominantly white ZIP codes for similarly situated good drivers, a 70 percent gap. In the densest urban centers the gap was 60 percent ($1,797 versus $1,126), and in rural ZIP codes it was 24 percent ($669 versus $542) (CFA, 2015).
CFA was explicit that it was not rushing to judgment about why the pattern exists. The report does not show that insurers intend to discriminate, and insurers dispute such conclusions in other forums; for a longer treatment see ZIP-code pricing and racial disparities: what investigations found. For a household, the practical point is that the territory you garage the car in is a large lever, and the rule about it varies, as Why your ZIP code changes your car insurance price explains.
Credit
Many insurers use a credit-based insurance score, a number built from credit-report data, as a rating factor where state law permits it. Some states bar or limit the practice; our guide to credit-based insurance scores and car insurance and the car insurance with poor credit: ways to lower the bill article cover which. California's rating regulation, 10 CCR 2632.5, lists the factors insurers may use: three mandatory ones (driving safety record, annual mileage and years of driving experience) and a list of optional ones including type of vehicle, multi-vehicle households, academic standing, driver training, marital status, persistency and multi-policy discounts (10 CCR 2632.5, Cornell Legal Information Institute, checked November 2026). The regulation also lists a relative-claims-frequency factor based on where the car is garaged, grouped into bands of ZIP codes or census tracts, which shows that location still counts there even though FIO's study says California prohibits using ZIP code directly; read the regulation or ask the Department for the current rule. In a state that permits credit scoring, a lower-income driver whose credit file is thin or damaged may pay more; the sources opened here do not quantify that gap nationally, so no percentage is claimed.
Age and experience
Young and inexperienced drivers pay more nearly everywhere, and a program that explicitly adds surcharges shows the size in one place. California's low-cost program adds a 30 percent surcharge for unmarried drivers 19 to 24, a 40 percent surcharge for drivers with under three years of verifiable driving history, and a 100 percent surcharge for drivers 16 to 18 (California Department of Insurance, 2025 Low Cost Auto report). Those figures apply only to that program's filed rates, not to the voluntary market. For lower-income families the age effect compounds: a household with a teen driver pays the surcharge on top of an already tight budget.
Who goes without coverage
The pressure shows up in the uninsured rate. The IRC's 2025 study, published by the Insurance Information Institute, estimated that 15.4 percent of motorists were uninsured in 2023, up from 12.4 percent in 2017, with 2023 rates ranging from 5.7 percent in Maine to 28.2 percent in Mississippi (Insurance Information Institute, Facts and statistics: uninsured motorists, checked November 2026). The IRC measures this indirectly, through the ratio of uninsured-motorist claims to bodily injury claims, so it is an estimate. It does not break the rate out by household income, so it cannot say how much of the uninsured share is low income. FIO's study notes that lower-income drivers are more likely to be uninsured, which it says could indicate a correlation with affordability. See who goes uninsured and why: cost, lapses and enforcement gaps for the mechanisms.
State programs: California and New Jersey
Only a few states run a program built around income. Both examples below are described by the state regulators and should be checked against the current program page before you apply.
California Low Cost Auto
According to the California Department of Insurance's 2025 report to the Legislature, the California Low Cost Auto Insurance (CLCA) program began in 2000 as a Los Angeles and San Francisco pilot, expanded to all 58 counties after April 2006, and was made permanent by AB 917 in 2023. Since launch it has covered 260,748 drivers. In 2024 it assigned 34,171 new applications, and 46,175 policies were active at year-end, up 54 percent from 2023. CAARP data in the report show 73 percent of 2024 applicants were uninsured when they applied.
Eligibility, effective 2024, requires a valid California driver's license (including an AB 60 license), a vehicle valued at $25,000 or less, age 16 or older, a good driving record (or a new driver), and household income at or below set limits: $37,650 for one person, $51,100 for two, $64,550 for three, $78,000 for four and $91,450 for five. The report lists several kinds of proof of income, including enrollment in CalFresh, Medi-Cal, SSI or tax and payroll documents, and says that since 2020 applicants may submit a Certification of Income Eligibility form when proof is not available.
The policy is liability only. The report lists basic limits of $10,000 per person and $20,000 per accident for bodily injury and $30,000 for property damage, with optional add-ons ($37 to $107 a year per the report) for medical payments and uninsured-motorist bodily injury. It does not include collision or comprehensive. Premiums are set by county and filed with the Insurance Commissioner. The report's table, effective March 1, 2024, shows county liability premiums that range at least from $198 to $401 per vehicle a year (the table's Amador and Alameda rows), before surcharges. California raised its general minimum liability limits to 30/60/15 on January 1, 2025, so confirm on the program page whether the plan's limits have changed since the report.
An insurer must be assigned within 45 days after the application, according to the report. A producer who gets a minimum-limits inquiry is required to tell the applicant about CLCA under Insurance Code Section 11629.745, which is why asking an agent about it is a legitimate first move.
New Jersey Special Automobile Insurance Policy
New Jersey's Department of Banking and Insurance says its Special Automobile Insurance Policy (SAIP) is an initiative to make limited coverage available to drivers eligible for federal Medicaid with hospitalization. It costs $365 a year ($360 if paid up front, according to its FAQ), covers emergency treatment after an accident and serious brain and spinal cord injury treatment up to $250,000, and pays a $10,000 death benefit. It does not cover liability to other people, damage to your own car, or outpatient care that Medicaid already covers (NJ DOBI, Special Automobile Insurance Policy, checked November 2026). The tradeoff is stark: the policy is cheap because it is limited, and if you cause a crash the policy will not pay the other party. The article on New Jersey's Special Automobile Insurance Policy: what it covers explains the consequences.
Tradeoffs behind the numbers
- Minimum limits versus protection. FIO notes that the affordability index is built on minimum-limits premiums, and that lower-income families more often buy the minimum. Minimum limits cut the bill but leave the household exposed to a judgment above the limit. See minimum coverage.
- Liability only versus a financed car. CLCA's policy lacks collision and comprehensive. A lender will usually require them on a financed vehicle, so the program fits owners of paid-off, modest-value cars, which the $25,000 value cap reflects.
- A cheap policy versus an assigned plan. Income-based programs are separate from the general residual market; for that last resort, see assigned risk plans: what the residual market costs and who uses it.
- Rate regulation versus availability. States that restrict ZIP code or credit change who bears the cost; the sources opened here do not show whether that lowers or raises the average low-income household's total bill.
What a low-income driver can verify
A worked example with numbers we define. Suppose a household earns $36,000 a year and pays $1,440 a year for one car. That is four percent of income, double FIO's two percent yardstick. These are hypothetical figures for illustration only. A quote that dropped the premium to $1,080 would take the ratio to three percent. The household cannot control the ratio's denominator, but each item below can move the numerator.
- Ask whether a state program exists. Search your state insurance department's site for "low cost auto" and confirm income limits on the program page. Only some states have one; state low-cost auto insurance programs lists what we have documented.
- Re-quote at the same limits with several insurers. Prices for the same driver vary widely between companies; compare identically configured quotes (see building a fair comparison of car insurance quotes: a worksheet).
- Check the facts on the current policy. Garaging address, annual mileage, vehicle use and driver list should be right; errors cost money. Auditing your policy's facts: VIN, garaging, mileage and use has a checklist.
- Ask which discounts apply to your situation, such as low mileage, a defensive driving course or paperless billing, and ask the insurer to confirm each in writing. Do not assume a discount exists; see state insurance department discount pages and shopping guides.
- Raise the deductible only if you can pay it. A higher deductible lowers the collision and comprehensive premium but moves risk to you; if a $1,000 deductible would force you into a payday loan, it is not a saving.
- Drop physical damage coverage on an old, paid-off car only after comparing the annual premium for it against the car's market value. The decision rule is in our cutting car insurance on a fixed income: seven changes by dollars article.
- Ask about payment options. Paying in full can avoid installment fees; ask the insurer what fee applies per payment.
- Do not let coverage lapse. A gap can raise the next quote and can bring penalties; use state car insurance requirements lookup to see your state's rule.
Common questions
Is there a federal program that pays for car insurance?
None of the sources opened for this article describes one. The programs found are state-run: California's CLCA and New Jersey's SAIP. The FIO study describes federal monitoring of affordability, not a subsidy.
Does a low-income program mean I get a worse insurer?
CLCA policies are issued by insurers holding California certificates of authority, according to the report, so they are licensed companies. The limits are lower, though, and physical damage is excluded.
Can I be charged more for my ZIP code?
In most states, location is a rating factor. FIO's study says California prohibits considering ZIP codes, but California's regulation also bands garaging locations by ZIP code or census tract, so check your own state's rule with its regulator.
Does being poor raise my premium directly?
Rating factors do not usually include income. They include things correlated with income, such as credit-based scores (where allowed), location and age. The sources here do not show an insurer rating on income itself.
Key takeaways
- Burden depends on the yardstick: FIO flags a premium above two percent of ZIP-code median income, while the IRC's index tracks average premium to median income without a threshold.
- The data is older than today's prices: FIO's study dates to 2017, and the IRC says losses grew faster than premiums from 2020 to 2024.
- Only a few states run income-based programs. California's CLCA is liability only with income limits and a $25,000 vehicle cap; New Jersey's SAIP is medical-only and costs $365 a year.
- Minimum limits cut the premium but leave you exposed above the limit.
- The reliable action is to verify: ask about state programs, compare identical quotes, and audit the facts on your policy.
Sources
- FIO: Study on the Affordability of Personal Automobile Insurance (January 2017), affordability index, two percent threshold, AP ZIP code counts and state examples, checked November 2026
- IRC: Personal Auto Insurance Affordability, Countrywide Trends and State Comparisons, the IRC index, 2022 expenditure and loss growth, checked November 2026
- Consumer Federation of America: Major auto insurers charge good drivers 70% more in African American ZIP codes (2015), quote comparison by ZIP code, checked November 2026
- California Department of Insurance: 2025 Low Cost Auto Report to the Legislature, CLCA eligibility, limits, premiums, surcharges and 2024 activity, checked November 2026
- New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance: Special Automobile Insurance Policy, SAIP eligibility, price and coverage, checked November 2026
- Insurance Information Institute: Facts and statistics, uninsured motorists, IRC uninsured-motorist estimates for 2017 to 2023, checked November 2026
- Cornell LII: 10 CCR 2632.5 (California rating factors), mandatory and optional rating factors in California, checked November 2026