Blog
Chargeable vs non-chargeable claims: what insurers count
A chargeable claim is one your insurer's rating plan lets it count. How fault, claim type and dollar thresholds decide, with state examples and what to ask.
A chargeable claim is one that your insurer's filed rating plan allows it to count against you when it sets your price, usually because you were at fault and the loss met a dollar or injury threshold. A non-chargeable claim is one the plan excludes, which commonly includes many comprehensive losses such as glass, theft, weather and animal strikes, and accidents another driver caused. The line is drawn by your state's rules and your company's plan, not by a universal standard, so the same claim can be chargeable with one insurer and not with another.
That distinction matters because filing a claim and being surcharged are different events. A claim can be paid, recorded and still never touch your premium. The reverse also happens: a small at-fault claim you could have paid yourself can add a surcharge that costs more than it recovered.
The vocabulary insurers use
Three terms get mixed together, and separating them clears up most confusion.
- Claim. A request that your insurer cover a loss. It exists whether or not anything is paid.
- Chargeable claim. A claim the insurer counts when it applies a surcharge, removes a claim-free discount or assigns points under a rating plan. "Chargeable" is a rating term, not a legal finding.
- Non-chargeable claim. A claim the plan does not count for those purposes. It may still be recorded in your claims history.
State Farm's own explainer on claims and rates (checked November 2026) uses the same split. State Farm says a claim may be considered chargeable when the driver is determined to be at fault and the loss meets the insurer's and the state's criteria, which can include the type of loss and the amount paid. It adds that some losses, often including certain comprehensive claims such as theft, vandalism, weather damage, glass damage or animal impact, may be treated as non-chargeable depending on the insurer and state, and that even a non-chargeable loss can still affect savings, eligibility or underwriting.
That last clause is the practical warning. "Not chargeable" does not mean "invisible."
Fault is the first question
For collision and liability claims, the first thing a rating plan asks is who caused the loss. Several states write that into law.
- Virginia. Code of Virginia 38.2-1905 says an insurer may not increase a premium or charge safe-driver-plan points because of an accident unless it was caused wholly or partly by the named insured, a resident of the household or another customary operator. A driver who is charged can appeal to the Commissioner in writing within 60 days of the notice, according to the same section.
- Arizona. Arizona Revised Statutes 20-263 bars an insurer from raising the premium because of an accident not caused or significantly contributed to by the insured, and requires a notice of the reason when a premium rises for accident involvement.
- California. 10 CCR 2632.13 says an insurer may not call a driver "principally at fault" unless the driver's actions were at least 51 percent of the legal cause, and unless the accident involved bodily injury or death or more than $1,000 in property damage. It lists presumptions that the driver is not at fault, including a lawfully parked vehicle, a rear-ended vehicle where the driver was not convicted of a moving violation, a hit-and-run where the accident was reported in a reasonable time, and contact with animals, birds or falling objects.
Not every state has a rule like these. Progressive's accident page (checked November 2026) says that accidents that are not your fault may still increase your rate in certain states, though usually by less than an at-fault accident. Our article on can a not-at-fault accident raise your premium? goes through that question state by state; here the point is narrower. Fault is a threshold question, and in several states it is a legal one.
Dollar thresholds and injury triggers
Many plans, and some state rules, add a size test. Three examples show how differently states set it.
New York. The Department of Financial Services' consumer FAQ says surcharges apply to liability, collision and no-fault coverages and are allowed only for at-fault accidents involving bodily injury or property losses over $2,000, or for certain chargeable convictions. It also says the total paid on a claim does not change the surcharge: a driver surcharged for an accident pays the same whether the damage was $3,000 or $50,000. Two or more accidents or minor convictions within roughly three years can also be surcharged even if neither would be alone.
North Carolina. The Safe Driver Incentive Plan published by the Department of Insurance assigns points by severity. An at-fault accident with total property damage of $2,300 or less is one point, between $2,300 and $3,850 is two points, and $3,850 or more or a certain level of bodily injury is three points. The plan also lists conditions under which no points apply to a property-damage-only accident of $2,300 or less: no moving-violation conviction connected to the accident, and no convictions or at-fault accidents among licensed household operators during the experience period. An insurer may require six consecutive months of coverage with it before that exemption applies. The experience period for these accidents is the three years before the application or renewal.
Pennsylvania. The state's motor vehicle code, 75 Pa.C.S. 1799.3 (as reproduced on Onecle, last modified 2016), bars surcharges where the aggregate cost to the insurer over the preceding three years is below a stated dollar amount above the deductible, bars a surcharge when the insurer recovers at least 60 percent of the paid claim from the responsible party, and bars a surcharge for paying a first-party medical claim. The statute directs the Insurance Department to adjust the dollar cap for inflation at least every three years, so the figure in the 2016 text should not be treated as current. Check the Pennsylvania Insurance Department for today's number.
Notice what these have in common: the size and fault tests are written to keep trivial or blameless claims from driving premiums. Notice also what they do not do. They do not stop an insurer from recording the claim, and in several states they leave room for the insurer to consider claim frequency, a point the next section covers.
Claim types: a sorting table
The table below summarizes how the sources above treat common claim types. It describes tendencies and structure, not a promise about any policy.
| Claim type | Usually chargeable? | What the sources say |
|---|---|---|
| At-fault collision above the state or plan threshold | Yes | New York, North Carolina and California all define surchargeable accidents by fault plus a size or injury test |
| Collision where another driver is clearly at fault | Often no | Virginia and Arizona bar the increase by statute; other states vary, per Progressive |
| Glass (comprehensive) | Often no, but recorded | State Farm lists glass damage among losses often treated as non-chargeable |
| Theft, vandalism, weather, animal strike | Often no | Same State Farm explanation; California presumes no fault for animal strikes and falling objects |
| Repeated comprehensive claims | Can matter | State Farm says multiple losses in a short period can affect savings, eligibility or renewal pricing |
| First-party medical (PIP, medical payments) | Often no | Pennsylvania's statute bars a surcharge for paying a first-party medical claim |
| Claim recovered from the at-fault party | Can be removed | Pennsylvania bars a surcharge where at least 60 percent is recovered |
Comprehensive, glass, towing and roadside
Comprehensive losses are the biggest source of "will this count?" questions. Two structural points help.
First, in plans like New York's, surcharges attach to liability, collision and no-fault coverages. That is the Department of Financial Services' description, and it leaves comprehensive outside that surcharge system. Other states and company plans may treat it differently, which is why the answer in writing matters.
Second, even where comprehensive is not surcharged, frequency can count. The North Carolina Department of Insurance's auto insurance FAQ says a company can nonrenew collision and comprehensive coverage if you do not meet its underwriting criteria, with proper notice, and that many companies use claim frequency, including fault-free claims, as one criterion. Our guide to comprehensive coverage explained covers what the coverage includes.
Glass has a state-law wrinkle. Florida, for example, provides in section 627.7288 that deductible provisions in comprehensive policies do not apply to windshield damage. A zero-deductible glass claim is cheap to file, and State Farm's page says any glass loss may still be recorded as claims activity depending on the insurer. So a free windshield repair and a clean renewal are not the same promise.
Towing and roadside service is the least documented category. We did not find a regulator or insurer page that states a general rule, and State Farm's page does not list it. Insurers differ in whether roadside use is tracked at all, so ask your insurer directly rather than assuming.
What a plan does with a chargeable claim
When a claim is chargeable, the consequences usually come in three layers.
- A surcharge or points. A percentage added to your premium for a set number of policy years. North Carolina publishes its percentages: the plan lists 40 percent for one point, 55 percent for two and 70 percent for three.
- Loss of a discount. A claims-free or accident-free discount can disappear even when no surcharge applies. State Farm's page gives an illustration of a claims-free saving of about $150 a year against a $500 deductible and notes the rules for keeping such savings vary.
- Underwriting review. An accumulation of claims can lead to a nonrenewal or a move to another rating tier.
How long this lasts is covered in how long accidents and tickets affect your rates and in our article on how multiple tickets and accidents stack on a rating plan. The state-by-state size of the increase is in how much one at-fault accident raises your rate in different states.
A worked example with defined numbers
These numbers are hypothetical. Suppose your policy costs $1,700 a year, and your insurer's plan adds a 30 percent surcharge for three years after a chargeable claim. That is $510 a year, or $1,530 over three years.
- Case A, small at-fault dent. The repair is $1,100 and your collision deductible is $500. The claim pays $600. If it is chargeable, you are $930 worse off over three years ($1,530 minus $600). If the plan's threshold excludes it, you gain $600.
- Case B, cracked windshield. The glass costs $450 and your comprehensive deductible is $250. The claim pays $200. If the plan treats glass as non-chargeable, the cost of filing is the $200 benefit minus any lost claims-free discount, which could be positive or negative depending on the discount.
- Case C, hit by an uninsured driver and you have collision. Whether the claim is chargeable depends on state law and the plan. In Virginia or Arizona the statutes above restrict an increase for an accident you did not cause.
The Should I file a claim? calculator lets you swap in your own numbers, and claims just above your deductible: the true cost of filing covers the narrow band where filing barely pays.
How to get the answer in writing
Because chargeability depends on the plan, the only reliable answer comes from your insurer or your state.
- Describe the loss and ask about classification. Use a script such as: "If I file this as a comprehensive claim, will you classify it as chargeable or non-chargeable under your rating plan?"
- Ask about the discount. "Will this claim remove my claims-free or accident-free discount, even if there is no surcharge?"
- Ask for the rule. "Which page of your filed rating rules or underwriting guidelines covers this?" Plans are filed with the state, and your department of insurance can often tell you how to read them. Our article on How a claim reaches your CLUE report and your renewal price shows what is recorded when you call.
- Ask for the reason if the price rises. If your price goes up after a claim, many states require a notice. Arizona and Virginia say so in the statutes cited above, and California's regulation requires a written notice of an at-fault determination with a right to reconsideration within 30 days.
- Save the reply. An email or a letter is better than a phone note.
We did not open any insurer's filed rating rules for this article, so we cannot tell you how a particular company's plan treats a particular claim. Use your department of insurance and state car insurance requirements lookup to find your state's rules.
Checking what is recorded
Chargeability is about price. The recording is separate. The Connecticut Insurance Department's CLUE FAQ says the database holds up to seven years of claims history and that insurers use it almost exclusively to rate new policies. The CFPB's entry for LexisNexis C.L.U.E. says one free report per 12 months is available on request. Pull yours before shopping so you know what a new insurer will see; our Your CLUE report and motor vehicle record explained guide shows how to read it.
Common questions
Does a claim that is not chargeable still show up on my CLUE report?
It can. Chargeability is a rating concept. The report records losses you asked your insurer to cover, according to Connecticut's FAQ, so a glass or theft claim may appear even if it never raises your price.
Can an insurer raise my rate for a claim that was not my fault?
In some states it cannot, under statutes like Virginia's and Arizona's. In others the plan may count it, though often by less, per Progressive's page. Ask your insurer and check your state's rules.
Does the amount paid change the surcharge?
Sometimes. New York says the total paid does not change the surcharge once it applies, while North Carolina and Pennsylvania use dollar bands or caps to decide whether and how much to charge.
What if my insurer calls a claim at fault and I disagree?
California requires a written notice and a 30-day window to request reconsideration by someone other than the original decision maker. Virginia allows a written appeal to the Commissioner within 60 days. Other states have their own processes; the department of insurance is the place to ask.
Key takeaways
- "Chargeable" means your insurer's rating plan counts the claim, usually when you were at fault and the loss passed a dollar or injury test.
- Glass, theft, weather and animal claims are often non-chargeable, but they can still be recorded and can affect discounts or frequency reviews.
- State rules differ sharply: Virginia and Arizona restrict increases for accidents you did not cause, while New York and North Carolina publish surcharge thresholds.
- Get the classification and the effect on your discounts in writing before you file a small claim.
Sources
- State Farm: Will my insurance increase after a claim?, insurer's own description of chargeable and non-chargeable claims, checked November 2026
- Progressive: How much does insurance go up after an accident?, not-at-fault accidents in some states, checked November 2026
- Code of Virginia 38.2-1905, no increase unless the insured caused the accident, 60-day appeal, checked November 2026
- Arizona Revised Statutes 20-263, no increase for accidents not caused by the insured, checked November 2026
- Cornell LII: 10 CCR 2632.13, California principally-at-fault rules, checked November 2026
- NY DFS: Can my insurance company raise my premium due to an accident or traffic ticket?, surcharge triggers and thresholds, checked November 2026
- NC DOI: Safe Driver Incentive Plan, points, percentages, experience period, checked November 2026
- NC DOI: FAQs about auto insurance, claim frequency and nonrenewal, checked November 2026
- Onecle: 75 Pa.C.S. 1799.3, Pennsylvania surcharge limits (text last modified 2016), checked November 2026
- Florida Senate: Statute 627.7288, glass deductible rule, checked November 2026
- Connecticut Insurance Department: CLUE FAQs, what CLUE holds and who uses it, checked November 2026
- CFPB: LexisNexis C.L.U.E. and Telematics OnDemand, seven-year reporting and free annual report, checked November 2026