Blog

Deer, elk and rural roads: how wildlife collisions show up in rates

Animal strikes are paid under comprehensive, so they surface in rates through area claim frequency and your deductible. State data, seasons, and how to choose.

A wildlife collision reaches your car-insurance price in two places. The comprehensive premium for your area is built partly from how often animal strikes happen there, and the comprehensive deductible you choose decides how much of each strike you pay. Your own claim may or may not change your future price, depending on the state and the insurer, and a few states restrict it.

The mechanics of filing a deer claim are covered in hitting a deer or other animal: comprehensive or collision?. This article is about the pricing side: where the claims cluster, when, how big they are, and how to set a deductible if you drive rural roads. Figures are as of November 2026, and rules vary by state; use the state car insurance requirements lookup or your state insurance department for specifics.

Where an animal strike lands in the policy

Hitting an animal is normally a comprehensive loss, not a collision loss. The Texas Department of Insurance's auto insurance guide lists "hitting an animal (if you have comprehensive coverage)" among the things most policies cover, alongside fire, hail, theft, flood and flying gravel (checked November 2026). The Highway Loss Data Institute, the insurance-funded research arm of the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, says the same in its deer-season analysis: repairs from crashes involving deer and other animals are covered by comprehensive (checked November 2026).

Two consequences matter for price:

  • Animal claims sit in the comprehensive pool. The comprehensive premium you pay is shared out from the losses of all comprehensive claims in a rating territory: theft, glass, hail, flood and animals together. If animal strikes are frequent in your ZIP code, they push your territory's comprehensive rate up.
  • If you drop comprehensive, you drop the protection. About 80 percent of insured drivers buy comprehensive, according to Triple-I's analysis of 2023 NAIC data on its auto insurance facts page (checked November 2026). On an older car, some drivers decide the premium is not worth it. In deer country that is a choice about an event that is not rare. See the full coverage calculator.

For how rates vary between city and country generally, see urban, suburban and rural: how car insurance prices differ by place and Why your ZIP code changes your car insurance price.

What the state numbers say

Insurers publish few state-level animal-claim figures, and the two sources below use different measures, so do not compare their numbers directly.

State Farm's 2025-26 claim likelihood

State Farm's newsroom release of September 15, 2026 estimates more than 1.6 million animal-vehicle collision claims across the United States between July 1, 2025 and June 30, 2026, and says State Farm paid $1.9 billion in claim costs in the study period (checked November 2026). It puts the national likelihood of an animal collision at 1 in 145, improved from 1 in 139 the year before. By state:

State Likelihood of an animal collision, State Farm 2025-26
West Virginia 1 in 46
Montana 1 in 54
Wisconsin 1 in 62
Pennsylvania 1 in 64
Michigan 1 in 68
United States 1 in 145

State Farm says West Virginia has held the top spot for more than a decade, and that Pennsylvania had the highest number of estimated industry claims, about 141,000. The figures are State Farm's estimates from its own claims, not a regulator's count, and State Farm says the data now covers wild and domestic animals, with deer by far the most commonly struck. Its claims include rodents that chew wiring.

HLDI's frequency measure

The HLDI analysis covered 2006 to 2018. It measured claims per 1,000 insured vehicle years, where one insured vehicle year is one vehicle insured for one year. It found:

State August claims per 1,000 vehicle years November claims per 1,000 vehicle years
West Virginia 15.1 47.8
Iowa 8.1 31.8
Pennsylvania 6.4 29.3
Kentucky 7.4 28.1
Michigan 7.7 23.4

(Source: HLDI via IIHS, checked November 2026.) West Virginia's November rate was more than three times the national average for the month. Butler County, Pennsylvania, had the highest county rate in November at 53.2. HLDI noted a limit on its own data: of the 41 companies that report comprehensive coverage, only 25 gave information about animal strikes.

Premium averages for the same states

The NAIC's 2022/2023 Auto Insurance Database Report, Table 3C, gives average comprehensive premiums by state (checked November 2026):

State 2023 average comprehensive premium 2022
Wyoming $452.24 $394.90
Montana $365.45 $333.78
Iowa $310.69 $264.12
West Virginia $302.12 $251.79
Pennsylvania $240.89 $198.65
Wisconsin $238.68 $191.87
Michigan $236.90 $191.56
California $150.04 $104.31

The report's national average for 2023 was $238.24, per this site's verified-facts notes. Be careful with this table: the average covers every comprehensive claim, including hail, which dominates Wyoming, theft and glass. High animal-strike states do tend to sit at or above the national average, but the NAIC report does not break out how much of the premium animal strikes cause, so no figure here is an "animal share." The hail, floods and hurricanes: how weather shows up in car premiums article covers the weather share of the same pool.

When strikes happen, and why November is expensive

HLDI found that animal-strike claims run more than twice the yearly average in November and are lowest in August. Claims rise rapidly in October, peak in November, and drop in December and January, matching the deer mating and hunting seasons. The average cost of a November claim over 2006 to 2018 was $3,560, against $2,801 in February, the least severe month.

A shopper can use that calendar in three ways:

  1. Check your deductible before October, not after a claim.
  2. Shift driving where possible at dusk and dawn. State Farm's release advises extra alertness from dusk to dawn, high beams where appropriate, and braking rather than swerving.
  3. If you add comprehensive in autumn, ask when it takes effect. Confirm the start date in writing before you drive on a deer corridor.

Big animals: elk, cattle and the severity problem

The data above is mostly about deer. State Farm's release lists the other animals in its claims as rodents, dogs, raccoons, cattle, coyotes, cats, turkeys, hogs and bears. Elk, moose and cattle are heavier than deer, and cars are damaged more by a heavier animal, but none of the sources I opened gives a claim-severity figure for elk or moose, so I do not state one. What the sources do show is the cost trend for animal strikes as a group: HLDI says the average claim cost rose from $2,424 in 2006 to $3,875 in 2018, mostly because of higher-priced cars and components. About nine in ten animal-strike crashes are front-impact, according to HLDI, which is why bumpers, radiators, headlamps and the sensors mounted in them drive the repair bill. For why those parts cost what they do, see ADAS calibration.

Colorado's transportation department runs a wildlife program that considers common species such as deer and elk when planning highways (checked November 2026). Crossings and fencing are a long-run influence on the claims data, which is why insurers watch them, though the page does not give claim figures.

Injuries and deaths

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety's fatality facts say deaths in crashes where the first harmful event was a collision with an animal rose from 89 in 1975 to 210 in 2024 (checked November 2026). Of the 2024 deaths, 63 percent were in crashes where the most harmful event was the animal collision itself, and 12 percent were rollovers. Texas had the most such deaths over the past ten years, a total that reflects the number of drivers, the animal population and the share of rural roads. In a review of 147 fatal animal crashes in nine states in 2000 to 2002, 77 percent of the animals struck were deer.

This is why the advice to brake, not swerve, matters more than the claim. Injuries are not paid by comprehensive; they fall under medical payments, personal injury protection or health insurance.

Does an animal claim raise your rate?

Practices differ. Some states limit what an insurer may do after a comprehensive claim of this kind. In Texas, the TDI guide says an insurer cannot nonrenew a policy because of claims for weather damage or for damage from hitting an animal, and that it cannot nonrenew for accidents that cannot reasonably be blamed on you unless you have more than one such claim in 12 months (checked November 2026). That is nonrenewal. The same page does not address whether the premium rises, so the question to ask your insurer is separate.

In other states, check the state department or your policy. As a general matter an animal strike has no at-fault driver, so it is not an at-fault accident, and many insurers treat it as a non-chargeable comprehensive loss; but that is a company practice, not a rule, and I did not find a source that states it for all insurers. Ask directly:

  • "If I file a comprehensive claim for hitting a deer, is it recorded as at-fault or chargeable?"
  • "Does a comprehensive claim affect my renewal price or my eligibility for a claim-free discount?"
  • "How many comprehensive claims in three years does this company treat as grounds for a higher deductible or nonrenewal?"

Compare the answers across insurers; they differ. The Should I file a claim? calculator helps decide whether a small claim is worth filing at all.

Choosing a deductible when you drive rural roads

A comprehensive deductible is the amount you pay before the insurer pays. A higher deductible lowers the comprehensive premium and raises your out-of-pocket cost per strike. The right level depends on the chance of a claim and your savings. The general approach is in choosing a comprehensive deductible on a high-theft or hail-prone car.

A hypothetical worked example

These numbers are invented for illustration, not any insurer's prices. A driver in a rural county has two comprehensive options:

$250 deductible $1,000 deductible
Annual comprehensive premium $310 $230
Saving per year n/a $80
Cost of a strike with $3,560 damage $250 $1,000
Extra cost if a strike happens n/a $750

(The $3,560 is HLDI's average November claim over 2006-2018, used here only as a repair-size placeholder.) The $1,000 deductible saves $80 a year but costs $750 more each time a strike happens. The break-even is a strike once every nine years or so (750 / 80). State Farm's 2025-26 likelihood of 1 in 46 in West Virginia works out, on these invented numbers, to an expected extra cost of about $16 a year ($750 / 46), and the national 1 in 145 to about $5, both well below the $80 saving. Those likelihoods are State Farm's own claim rates, not your personal odds, and in a bad year a driver on a deer corridor could have two strikes. The expected-value math also ignores whether you could cover $1,000 in cash. If a $1,000 bill would cause trouble, the $250 option is the safer choice. Use the deductible break-even calculator with your own quotes.

A small-claim rule of thumb follows: damage below the deductible is not worth claiming, and the claim may stay in your record. A $600 repair under a $500 deductible produces a $100 payment. Paying it yourself may be better. The should you file a claim or pay out of pocket? guide explains why.

What to confirm on your policy

Open the declarations page and check:

  1. Comprehensive is listed with a deductible. Collision alone does not pay for a strike.
  2. The deductible amount and whether it is per vehicle.
  3. Glass coverage. A deer through the windshield may be a glass claim with its own deductible; see full glass coverage.
  4. Rental reimbursement, as a repair after a strike can take weeks.
  5. Whether a lender requires comprehensive. If you owe money on the car, the lender usually does.
  6. Aftermarket parts and equipment such as light bars or bull bars, which may be limited unless listed.

Documenting the event

A claim is easier to settle when the record is clear.

  1. Move to safety, turn on hazard lights, and do not approach an injured animal.
  2. Call the police if the animal blocks the road, someone is hurt or the damage is large, and ask whether your state requires a report.
  3. Photograph the car, the animal if safe, the road, skid marks, and any fur or blood on the vehicle.
  4. Note the time, location and direction of travel, and get witness names.
  5. Check for leaks, tire damage and broken lights before driving, as State Farm advises.
  6. Report the claim promptly and ask the adjuster in writing whether it is coded comprehensive or collision.
  7. Keep repair estimates, towing and rental receipts.

Common questions

Is a deer strike a collision claim?

Usually not. Insurers generally pay it under comprehensive. If you swerve and hit another object, the loss is normally treated as collision. See the longer explanation in hitting a deer or other animal: comprehensive or collision?.

Which states have the most animal strikes?

By State Farm's 2025-26 estimate, West Virginia (1 in 46), Montana, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania and Michigan. HLDI's 2006-2018 analysis had West Virginia, Iowa, Pennsylvania, Kentucky and Michigan for November frequency.

Will my rates go up after I hit a deer?

It depends on the state and insurer. Texas limits nonrenewal for animal claims, per TDI. Ask your insurer whether the claim is chargeable.

Should I raise my comprehensive deductible?

If you can pay it comfortably and your premium saving is meaningful, it can make sense. Run your own quotes through the deductible break-even calculator.

Key takeaways

  • Animal strikes are paid under comprehensive, and they feed your area's comprehensive rate along with theft, glass and weather.
  • State Farm's 2025-26 data puts West Virginia, Montana, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania and Michigan highest; HLDI shows claims peaking in November.
  • Average strike cost rose from $2,424 in 2006 to $3,875 in 2018, per HLDI, so check your deductible before autumn.
  • Whether a claim affects price is a state and insurer question; ask, and compare quotes.
  • Brake rather than swerve; injuries cost more than any repair.

Sources

Terms used in this guide

Related insurers

Related states

Related guides

Related tools

Latest on this topic