Blog
The owned-but-not-insured exclusion: UM/UIM gaps at home
Standard policies can deny uninsured motorist claims when you are hurt in a vehicle you own that is not on the policy. How it works and how to close it.
Often not, if your own policy follows the standard form. The standard Personal Auto Policy takes uninsured motorist (UM) coverage away from an insured who is hurt while in, or struck as a pedestrian by, a motor vehicle that the insured owns but did not insure for UM on that policy. A second car you own, a motorcycle you keep in the garage, or a vehicle that is "available for your regular use" can all fall into the gap, depending on the wording of your policy and your state's law. The exclusion exists because the insurer priced the policy for the cars it knew about.
Below is what the standard wording says, what two courts did with it, how state law changes the result, and the cheapest ways to close the gap before you need it.
What the standard wording says
The Insurance Services Office (ISO) Personal Auto Policy is the template many personal auto policies are based on. This article quotes the 1994 edition (PP 00 01 06 94) as filed by Concord General Mutual with the Maine Bureau of Insurance, because it is publicly posted. Later editions and company-specific forms differ in detail, so read your own policy. Four places in that form create the "owned but not insured" problem, per the ISO PP 00 01 06 94 as filed with Maine (checked November 2026).
| Part | What it says (paraphrased) |
|---|---|
| Uninsured motorists, Exclusions A.1 | No UM coverage for bodily injury sustained by an insured while occupying, or when struck by, any motor vehicle owned by that insured that is not insured for this coverage under this policy |
| Uninsured motorists, Exclusions A.2 | No UM coverage for a family member hurt in or struck by a vehicle you own that is insured for UM on a primary basis under another policy |
| Medical payments, Exclusions 5 and 6 | No medical payments coverage for injury while occupying or struck by a vehicle (other than your covered auto) that is owned by you or furnished or available for your regular use; the same for a family member's owned or regularly available vehicle, though that exclusion does not apply to you |
| Liability, Exclusions B.2 | No liability coverage for a vehicle other than your covered auto that is owned by you or furnished or available for your regular use |
The form also defines the vehicle that counts as uninsured. A vehicle "owned by or furnished or available for the regular use of you or any 'family member'" is not an "uninsured motor vehicle" under the UM part. That is the mirror image: if a relative's uninsured car hits you, the policy does not treat that car as an uninsured motor vehicle either.
Two more definitions matter. "Family member" means a person related to you by blood, marriage or adoption who is a resident of your household. And a private passenger auto leased to a person under a written agreement for a continuous period of at least 6 months is deemed owned by that person. A long-term lease can therefore make a car "owned" for these purposes.
Why the insurer wrote it this way
The reasoning was explained in a Minnesota Supreme Court decision, Wintz v. Colonial Insurance Co., 542 N.W.2d 625 (1996), which upheld the exclusion. The court said that voiding it would allow a policyholder to insure only one vehicle and gain coverage on any and all other uninsured vehicles, converting first-party benefits into third-party liability benefits, per the opinion as published by the Caselaw Access Project (checked November 2026). In plain words: an insurer that charged you for one car's UM is not expected to give you UM for every other car you or your relatives own.
That is the insurer's logic. Your logic as a policyholder is that UM coverage is supposed to protect you, not a vehicle. Courts have split on how far to take that idea, which is why your state matters.
Case study: the motorcycle in Minnesota
In Wintz, a stepson moved out of state and left his uninsured motorcycle, its keys and the title with his father, giving the father unconditional permission to use it. The father drove it occasionally. His wife, Linda, was a passenger on the motorcycle when it collided with a tractor-trailer, and she claimed UM benefits under her husband's car policy. The policy excluded vehicles "owned by or furnished or available for the regular use of you, or a relative." The trial court enforced the exclusion; the court of appeals reversed on a rule that coverage follows the person; and the Minnesota Supreme Court reversed again, holding that she could not recover. The court said that whether the father used the motorcycle once or a dozen times, it was available to him for regular use, per the Wintz opinion.
The case also records the legislative history. Before 1984, the court had said UM coverage was for persons and not vehicles, disallowing such exclusions; in 1985 the Minnesota legislature amended Minn. Stat. 65B.49, subdivision 3a, to let insurers exclude vehicles owned by the policyholder but not insured by the policyholder. Today the statute says the UM and UIM coverages required by the subdivision "do not apply to bodily injury of the insured while occupying a motor vehicle owned by the insured, unless the occupied vehicle is an insured motor vehicle," and separately do not apply to bodily injury of the insured while occupying a motorcycle owned by the insured, per Minn. Stat. 65B.49 (Minnesota Revisor of Statutes, checked November 2026).
So in Minnesota, the second exclusion is not just a policy term. It is built into the statute for owned motorcycles.
Case study: when the wording is not exact
Wording matters, and courts read exclusions narrowly. In Mistretta v. Auto Club Insurance Association, an unpublished Michigan Court of Appeals decision from March 4, 2004, the insurer insured the plaintiff's family vehicles but not the car in which she was riding, which was furnished to her mother by an employer and titled in the name of a trust. The policy's "other owned vehicle" exclusion applied to vehicles "owned by a member of her household." The insurer argued the mother was an owner under the statutory definition of owner, which includes a person who has use of a vehicle for more than thirty days. The court said the term "owned" was not defined in the policy, that the commonly used meaning is the titled and registered owner, and that exclusions are strictly construed against the insurer, so the plaintiff was entitled to benefits, per the Mistretta opinion (Michigan Court of Appeals, unpublished, checked November 2026).
The lesson from the two cases together: the exclusion is enforceable in many places, but how it applies depends on what the words say, how the state defines ownership and whether the vehicle was "available for regular use". An unpublished opinion is not binding precedent, and neither case is a prediction about your state. A licensed attorney or the state insurance department is the place for specifics.
Scenario A: the motorcycle
Suppose a hypothetical driver, Dana, insures two cars on one policy with 50/100 UM limits. Dana also owns a motorcycle, insured under a separate policy that carries no UM and a low liability limit. A driver with no insurance hits Dana on the motorcycle and Dana has $90,000 in medical bills and lost wages.
- Dana's car policy. Under the ISO wording above, UM does not apply to Dana's injury while occupying a motor vehicle she owns that is not insured for UM on that policy. Liability coverage excludes vehicles with fewer than four wheels, and the medical payments part excludes injury while occupying a motorized vehicle having fewer than four wheels, per the ISO form. The car policy was never meant to cover the bike.
- Dana's motorcycle policy. UM on the motorcycle policy is the only place to look. If she declined it, she has a gap.
- Health insurance and other sources. Health coverage may pay medical bills; see MedPay or health insurance: who pays first after a crash.
The gap is cheapest to fix before the accident. For how motorcycles and cars interact in claims, see car-motorcycle collisions: fault, injuries and claims; for bundling a motorcycle policy with a car policy, see Bundling a motorcycle, RV or boat policy with your car insurance.
Scenario B: a car stored at a relative's home
Another hypothetical: Marcus owns two cars. He insures the daily driver but keeps a second car, titled in his name, at his mother's house two states away while he works abroad. He does not insure it, figuring it is not being driven. His mother, who lives alone, drives it to the store each week, and Marcus's brother, who does not live with either, uses it on holidays.
Now ask four questions, which are the same ones an adjuster would ask:
- Who owns it? Marcus, by title. If he is injured in it, the "owned by that insured and not insured for UM" language applies to his daily-driver policy.
- Is his mother a "family member" under his policy? Only if she is a resident of his household. She is not; so the "regular use of a family member" language is probably not triggered by her use. The result might differ if she lived with him.
- Is it "available for the regular use" of anyone on the policy? Marcus is abroad, so a court might say it is available to his mother but not to him. The Wintz court treated a motorcycle left with a father as available for the father's regular use, per the Wintz opinion.
- What does the state require of an owned, unused vehicle? Many states require liability insurance on a registered vehicle even when it is garaged; see insuring a car you are not driving.
The point is not that Marcus is certainly uncovered. It is that he has bought an argument he does not need. Keeping the car on a cheap storage-only or reduced policy, or insuring it for UM, turns a litigation question into a settled one.
How state law changes the picture
States vary in at least four ways, and I cannot give a complete state-by-state table:
- Statutes. Minnesota's statute explicitly allows the owned-vehicle and owned-motorcycle exclusions, per Minn. Stat. 65B.49. Other states may require UM to follow the person, limit the exclusion, or permit it only where the other vehicle was insured elsewhere.
- Court decisions. Wintz shows a court moving from "coverage follows the person" to enforcing the exclusion after a statutory change. Other states' courts may still apply the older rule.
- Definitions of ownership. Mistretta turned on whether "owned" meant the titled owner or a person with use over thirty days.
- No-fault systems. In some no-fault states, injury benefits come from personal injury protection rather than UM, and priority rules apply instead; Michigan's statute, for example, makes the injured person's own policy the starting point under MCL 500.3114(1), per Michigan Legislature: MCL 500.3114 (checked November 2026). See Personal injury protection (PIP) explained.
Use state car insurance requirements lookup to see what your state requires, and ask the department of insurance whether it has restricted this exclusion.
Why the gap is more than theoretical
UM coverage exists because many drivers carry no insurance. The Insurance Research Council estimated that 15.4 percent of motorists, or more than one in seven drivers, were uninsured in 2023, according to Triple-I: Facts and statistics, uninsured motorists (citing a 2025 Insurance Research Council study; checked November 2026). The IRC measures that with a ratio of claims by people injured by uninsured drivers to claims by people injured by insured drivers, so it is an estimate, and the state rates range widely. The point for this article: you can be hit by an uninsured driver in any vehicle you own, so the question is which policy answers.
Ways to close the gap
- Insure every vehicle you own, even a seldom-used one. Ask for a quote with comprehensive-only or reduced coverage, and make sure UM stays on. The cost depends on your state, insurer and the vehicle, and I cannot give a typical figure.
- Add UM to the motorcycle's own policy. If the motorcycle policy is separate, confirm the UM limit and whether you rejected it in writing.
- Tell the insurer within the grace window when you buy a car. The 1994 ISO form's newly-acquired-vehicle provision applies if you ask the insurer to insure the vehicle within 30 days after you become the owner, per the ISO form. Policies differ, so check yours.
- Match the household. List everyone who lives with you and every vehicle they own. A relative's car can be "available for regular use" even if it is not on your policy.
- Read the exclusion list in your own policy. Look for words such as "owned by," "furnished or available for the regular use," "household," and "motorized vehicle having fewer than four wheels."
- Consider an umbrella. Umbrella policies may include UM options; see umbrella insurance: liability protection above your auto policy. Check the exact terms.
Checks to run today
- Does every car, truck, motorcycle, RV or trailer you own appear on a declarations page somewhere?
- For each, what UM and UIM limits does it carry, and was UM ever rejected in writing?
- Does any relative in your household own a vehicle that is not on your policy?
- Is any vehicle you own kept somewhere else and used by someone else?
- Is there a long-term lease that counts as ownership under your policy's wording?
Common questions
If my second car is on a different policy, am I covered in it under my first policy?
Under the standard wording, a vehicle you own that is insured for UM on another policy is the subject of a separate exclusion for family members, and the UM benefit for you in an owned vehicle depends on it being insured for UM on this policy, per the ISO form. Look to the policy that insures that vehicle.
Does this exclusion apply if I am a passenger in a friend's car?
The exclusion targets vehicles you own or have regular use of, so a friend's car is usually a different question. See Who UM coverage protects: passengers, pedestrians and cyclists.
Can the insurer enforce it even though I paid for UM?
In many states, yes, if the wording is clear and state law permits it, as Wintz and Minnesota's statute show. In others, courts read it narrowly, as Mistretta shows.
Key takeaways
- The standard form removes UM for an insured hurt in a vehicle the insured owns that is not insured for UM on that policy.
- Motorcycles are a common gap: standard car forms exclude vehicles with fewer than four wheels from liability and medical payments.
- Courts and statutes differ by state; read your policy and ask your department of insurance.
- The cheapest fix is to insure every vehicle you own, with UM, before an accident.
Sources
- ISO Personal Auto Policy PP 00 01 06 94, filed with Maine Bureau of Insurance: UM, medical payments and liability wording, definitions; checked November 2026.
- Wintz v. Colonial Insurance Co., 542 N.W.2d 625 (Minn. 1996), Caselaw Access Project: the motorcycle case and the reasoning for the exclusion; checked November 2026.
- Minnesota Revisor of Statutes: Minn. Stat. 65B.49: owned-vehicle and owned-motorcycle exclusions from UM/UIM; checked November 2026.
- Mistretta v. Auto Club Insurance Association, Michigan Court of Appeals, March 4, 2004 (unpublished): how an undefined "owned" was read against the insurer; checked November 2026.
- Michigan Legislature: MCL 500.3114: PIP priority starts with the injured person's own policy; checked November 2026.
- Triple-I: Facts and statistics, uninsured motorists: 15.4 percent uninsured in 2023, IRC 2025 study; checked November 2026.