Blog

Excessive, inadequate, unfairly discriminatory: the rate test

The three-word legal standard regulators apply to car insurance rates, how states define each prong, how profit is judged, and how to cite it in a complaint.

Most states ask the same three questions of every car insurance rate: is it too high (excessive), too low to pay the costs it must cover (inadequate), or does it treat similar drivers differently for reasons unrelated to risk (unfairly discriminatory)? A rate that fails any one of the three can be disapproved or, in some states, ordered refunded. The wording of the standard is close from state to state, but the definitions, the burden of proof and the role of competition are not, so the statute in your own state is the one that counts.

This article reads the standard in four places this article opened: California (through its Supreme Court's opinions), Florida, Texas and Massachusetts. It then walks through how a regulator measures profit, what kinds of rating factors fail, how courts review a rate decision, and how a driver can cite the standard in a complaint. The model laws written by the NAIC are the common ancestor of many state statutes, but the NAIC's site refused our automated requests, so we did not read them and make no claim about their wording.

Where the three words come from

The standard lives in each state's insurance code, in the section that governs how rates are made and reviewed.

  • California. Insurance Code section 1861.05(a), quoted in the Supreme Court's opinion in 20th Century Insurance Co. v. Garamendi, says no rate shall be approved or remain in effect that is "excessive, inadequate, unfairly discriminatory or otherwise in violation of" the law. In judging this, "no consideration shall be given to the degree of competition," and the commissioner must consider whether the rate mathematically reflects the insurer's investment income.
  • Florida. Statute 627.062 says rates for the classes of insurance it covers "may not be excessive, inadequate, or unfairly discriminatory," and that insurers must set rates allowing a reasonable rate of return.
  • Texas. Insurance Code 2251.051 defines each of the three terms for the chapter, and Insurance Code 2251.052 says a rate may not be excessive, inadequate, unreasonable or unfairly discriminatory for the risks to which it applies. Section 2251.001 states the chapter's purposes as protecting the public by prohibiting those three kinds of rates, promoting price competition and prohibiting price-fixing.
  • Massachusetts. General Laws chapter 175E, section 4 opens: rates "shall not be excessive or inadequate, as herein defined, nor shall they be unfairly discriminatory."

The same three words, then, but four different statutes. The rest of this article shows where they diverge.

The excessive prong

"Excessive" means the price is too high relative to what the coverage costs the insurer plus a fair margin.

State How the statute describes an excessive rate
Florida Likely to produce a profit from Florida business that is unreasonably high in relation to the risk involved in the class of business, or expenses that are unreasonably high in relation to services rendered. Also excessive if a stock insurer's rate structure replenishes surplus from premiums when the replenishment is attributable to investment losses.
Texas Likely to produce a long-term profit that is unreasonably high in relation to the insurance coverage provided.
Massachusetts Unreasonably high for the insurance provided. Evidence that a reasonable degree of competition exists in the area is "material, but not conclusive" evidence that the rate is not excessive.
California The statute bars excessive rates without a general definition in the opinions we read. For the rollback year, Calfarm says a rate is excessive if it is above 80 percent of the 1987 rate and more than minimally nonconfiscatory.

Notice the word "unreasonably." No statute says an insurer may not profit. Each says the profit may not be unreasonably high. What counts as reasonable is the real fight, and it is covered below.

The inadequate prong

"Inadequate" is the mirror image, and it protects insurers and, indirectly, policyholders, because a company priced below its costs may fail or leave the market.

  • Florida deems a rate inadequate if it is clearly insufficient, together with the investment income attributable to it, to sustain projected losses and expenses in the class of business.
  • Texas says a rate is inadequate if it is insufficient to sustain projected losses and expenses, if it endangers the solvency of an insurer using it, or if it has the effect of substantially lessening competition or creating a monopoly.
  • Massachusetts holds a rate inadequate only if it is unreasonably low and either endangers the insurer's solvency or would destroy competition or create a monopoly.
  • California's court opinions tie the prong to the Constitution: a confiscatory rate "is necessarily an inadequate rate." That is why a rate cap must leave a pressure valve, a point developed in the article on rate caps, rollbacks and freezes: how states limit increases.

Regulators rarely disapprove a rate for being too low in a soft market, but the prong matters when a legislature or commissioner tries to hold prices down.

The unfairly discriminatory prong

This prong is the one drivers feel most, because it is about who pays more than whom. A key point: insurance prices differently by design. The statutes do not ban differences. They ban differences that are not tied to expected cost, or that rest on a forbidden characteristic.

  • Cost relationship. Florida deems a rating plan unfairly discriminatory if its discounts, credits or surcharges among risks do not bear a reasonable relationship to the expected loss and expense experience among the various risks. Texas uses nearly the same language: a rate is unfairly discriminatory if it does not bear a reasonable relationship to the expected loss and expense experience among risks.
  • Forbidden characteristics. Texas adds that a rate is unfairly discriminatory if it is based wholly or partly on the race, creed, color, ethnicity or national origin of the policyholder or an insured. Massachusetts goes further for motor vehicle insurance: its statute says rates shall not be based on credit information, including a credit-based insurance score; risks shall not be grouped by sex or marital status; and risks shall not be grouped by age except to produce a 25 percent lower rate for insureds aged 65 or older who otherwise qualify for the lowest rate classification.
  • Specific regulations. California's department lists on its rate filings page a 2019 regulation prohibiting gender discrimination in personal auto rates and, as of November 2026, a page headed "Removal of Marital Status in Automobile Rating Factor." The page links guides on removing each factor; it does not state the legal basis, so read the regulation itself before relying on it.
  • Discounts that are too generous. Florida also treats a rate as inadequate for a risk or group if the discounts or credits allowed exceed a reasonable reflection of expense savings and reasonably expected loss experience. A discount can create the problem in either direction.

Practical consequence: a factor such as age, ZIP code or credit-based score is not illegal because it makes some drivers pay more. It is lawful where the statute permits it and the insurer supports it with cost data, and unlawful where the state bans it or the data does not support it. The article on price optimization: why regulators barred charging what you'll pay shows a factor that failed because it tracked something other than cost.

How reasonable profit is measured

Three tools show up repeatedly.

1. A filed profit provision, judged against statute. Florida's list of factors the regulator must consider includes past and prospective loss experience, past and prospective expenses, the degree of competition, investment income reasonably expected from the premiums and reserves, trend factors, the cost of reinsurance, and "a reasonable margin for underwriting profit and contingencies." The regulator must apply "generally accepted and reasonable actuarial techniques." California's formula leaves competition out and requires the investment-income calculation. The difference is not academic: a market with many sellers is evidence of a fair price in Massachusetts and Florida, and irrelevant in California.

2. A look-back profit test. Florida's excess profits statute, 627.066, compares each private passenger auto insurer group's underwriting gain over three calendar-accident years with the profit it anticipated, defined from the profit and contingencies factors in its own rate filings, plus 5 percent of earned premiums. A gain above that line is excessive and must be refunded unless the insurer shows the refund would render a group member impaired or insolvent. A simplified hypothetical, with numbers defined here for illustration: if an insurer group's three-year earned premium is $300 million and its filed profit provision was 3 percent, the line is 8 percent, or $24 million. An underwriting gain of $27 million would be $3 million above the line. The statute's own definition has more steps, but this is the shape of the test.

3. Disallowed expenses. Texas's definitions section, 2251.002, lists "disallowed expenses" for personal lines that cannot be built into a rate: administrative expenses (other than acquisition, loss control and safety engineering) above 110 percent of the industry median; lobbying; advertising except advertising directly related to the insurer's services or products or designed and directed at loss prevention; and others in the statute, including fines and penalties and damages in bad-faith or fraud actions. Rates may not include them. The rate test thus works on the expense side as well as profit.

For how a filing documents these inputs, see loss ratios and rate filings: how insurers justify an increase, and for the filing itself see the filing lookup routine.

Who has to prove what

The burden of proof is where states differ most.

  • In California's prior approval system, the court opinions quote the statute as saying an applicant bears the burden of proving the requested rate change is justified, and the insurer must file a complete rate application before changing a rate.
  • In file-and-use systems the regulator carries more of the work after the fact. Florida's statute says the regulator may review a rate at any time, and if it finds on a preliminary basis that a rate may be excessive, inadequate or unfairly discriminatory, must start proceedings to disapprove it; the insurer then has 60 days to file the information that, in its belief, proves the rate reasonable, adequate and fair.
  • Texas says that the commissioner may disapprove a rate already in effect only after a hearing with at least 20 days' written notice, with the order issued within 15 days after the hearing closes, and that further use may not be barred earlier than the 45th day after the hearing closes (2251.104).

See also prior approval vs file-and-use: do regulated states pay more or less? and rate hearings and intervenors: how the public challenges an increase.

How courts review a rate decision

A rate decision usually ends in an administrative order, which an insurer can appeal. What the court does with that order depends on the state's law and on the kind of decision.

California offers one documented example. In the rollback case 20th Century v. Garamendi, the Supreme Court said that in reviewing the commissioner's rollback order a court is required to weigh the evidence under its independent judgment, sustain the order if it has adequate evidentiary support and strike it down if it does not, while scrutinizing the commissioner's implementing regulations for arbitrariness. Calfarm added that any rate set by the commissioner is subject to judicial review and that the initiative's standard for rates must not permit confiscation. That standard of review belongs to one kind of order in one state, so do not generalize it. Texas's statute separately describes judicial review of an order disapproving a rate and restricts an insurer from filing and using a higher rate while review is pending unless it follows the approval process (2251.151).

We did not open other appellate decisions on this standard for this article, so we cite only the two California opinions as court authority.

How a consumer can use the standard

Individual drivers seldom win a ruling that a filed rate is excessive. The standard is more useful as a way to ask a precise question than as a cause of action. Three examples:

  • "Is this factor in your filed rating plan?" A surcharge or discount you were charged should appear in the insurer's filed rules. If it does not, the question belongs in front of the department.
  • "Is this factor allowed here?" If your state bans a factor (Massachusetts bans credit-based scores for private passenger auto, for example) and your renewal appears to use it, ask.
  • "Does the change match the filing?" Compare your increase with the filing's average and ask why you are above it.

The department is not an arbitrator of your price. The article on what your state insurance department cannot do for you sets out limits, and the guide on how to file a complaint against a car insurance company covers the general process. California's consumer help page offers an electronic complaint form for non-health lines such as auto, and the Texas Department of Insurance's complaint help page says it assists with complaints against companies, agents and adjusters.

How to cite the standard in a complaint

  1. Find the right statute. Search your state code for the section governing private passenger auto rates, and note its number. Use your insurance department's website or your state legislature's code.
  2. Name the prong. Say whether you think the issue is the amount (excessive), a particular factor (unfairly discriminatory) or an insurer's solvency (inadequate). Most consumer complaints are about the second.
  3. Give facts, not conclusions. Policy number, renewal date, old and new premium, the factor or surcharge at issue, and the SERFF tracking number if you found the filing.
  4. Ask a question the department can answer. "Please confirm whether this surcharge appears in the insurer's approved rules" gets further than "this is unfair."
  5. Attach the paperwork. Declarations pages for both terms, the renewal notice and the page of the filing you rely on.
  6. Keep the dates. Write down when you contacted the insurer and what it said.

A sample paragraph, with brackets for your own details:

My policy [number] renewed on [date]. My premium changed from [amount] to [amount]. The notice lists [factor or surcharge]. I found filing [SERFF tracking number], which shows an average change of [percent] effective [date]. Please confirm whether [factor] is part of the insurer's filed and approved rating plan in [state], and whether it is consistent with [section number of the state's rating statute].

This is general information, not legal advice. For a legal dispute, a licensed attorney or your state insurance department is the place for specifics.

Common questions

Does "excessive" mean an insurer cannot make a profit?

No. Each statute opened for this article says only that profit must not be unreasonably high, and Florida's statute expressly lists a reasonable margin for underwriting profit and contingencies as a factor.

Where the state permits the factor and the insurer supports it with cost data, yes. A state can ban a factor outright; Massachusetts bans credit scores, sex and marital status for motor vehicle rating, and limits age use.

Why does competition count in some states and not others?

Statutes decide. California's standard says competition is not considered. Florida lists the degree of competition as a factor, and Massachusetts treats evidence of competition as material but not conclusive.

Can I use the standard to challenge my own premium in court?

The sources opened here do not show a private lawsuit route against a filed rate. The department is the usual forum. Ask an attorney about your state.

Key takeaways

  • The three-word test is shared in outline and different in detail: read your state's definitions of each prong.
  • Reasonable profit is judged from filed profit provisions, investment income, look-back tests like Florida's and expense rules like Texas's disallowed list.
  • Competition is irrelevant in California, a listed factor in Florida and material but not conclusive in Massachusetts.
  • A cap that ignores the inadequate prong will fail in court; California's opinions explain why.
  • In a complaint, name the statute and prong, give dated facts and ask the department a question it can answer.

Sources

Terms used in this guide

Related states

Related guides

Related tools

Latest on this topic