Blog

Time-limited policy limits demands and bad faith setups

How a deadline to pay your liability limit can lead to a judgment above your coverage, what California, Georgia and Florida require, and what to do if insured.

A time-limited policy limits demand is a claimant's offer to settle for the at-fault driver's full liability limit if the insurer accepts by a deadline. If the insurer lets the deadline pass on a claim that is clearly worth more than the limit, and a later verdict exceeds the limit, the insurer can be held liable for the excess in many states. If the insurer accepts, the case ends within the policy. That asymmetry is why these letters are sometimes described as "setups," and why several states have written rules for them.

This article explains how a demand works, how the duty to settle is tested, what California, Georgia and Florida require in 2026, and what you should do if you are the insured driver. The wording of each rule is cited to its source and checked in November 2026. The details differ by state, and a licensed attorney is the person who can apply them to your case.

What a time-limited demand is

Imagine you carry $50,000 in bodily injury liability per person and cause a crash that seriously injures another driver. Before filing suit, the injured person's lawyer sends your insurer a letter: pay $50,000 within 30 days, in exchange for a release of you, or the offer is withdrawn. That is a time-limited demand.

California's statute defines the term precisely in Code of Civil Procedure section 999: an offer made before a complaint is filed, by or for a claimant to a tortfeasor who has liability insurance, to settle within the insurer's limit of liability insurance, "which by its terms must be accepted within a specified period of time." The statute also defines "extracontractual damages" as any amount of damage that exceeds the total available limit of liability insurance. Those two phrases frame the issue: a deadline on one side, exposure above the limit on the other.

Why do claimants do this? A limits demand gives the insurer a clear choice. Paying the limit costs the insurer nothing beyond what the policy promises. Refusing risks a verdict above the limit, and the law in many states says the insurer, not the insured, should carry that risk when settlement within limits was reasonable. A demand is often legitimate and sometimes the best outcome for everyone. The concern is when it is built to be impossible to meet, for example by sending it with little documentation and a short fuse.

The insurer's duty to settle

Under most states' law, an insurer that controls the defense of a liability claim owes its insured a duty to give the insured's interests at least equal consideration when deciding whether to settle. The test is applied after the fact, with the benefit of hindsight about what the insurer knew.

The classic California statement comes from Crisci v. Security Insurance Co., 66 Cal.2d 425 (1967): the test is "whether a prudent insurer without policy limits would have accepted the settlement offer." In Crisci, the landlord's policy limit was $10,000. The injured tenant's lawyer reduced her demand to $10,000, but the insurer was willing to pay only $3,000 for the physical injuries. A jury later awarded $100,000 to the tenant and $1,000 to her husband, the insurer paid its $10,000, and the court awarded the insured landlord $91,000 plus $25,000 for mental suffering against the insurer.

Texas applies a similar duty through the Stowers doctrine. In *American Physicians Insurance Exchange v. Garcia*, 876 S.W.2d 842 (Tex. 1994), the Supreme Court of Texas held that the duty is not triggered unless three prerequisites are met: the claim is within the scope of coverage, the demand is within the policy limits, and the terms are such that an ordinarily prudent insurer would accept it, considering the likelihood and degree of the insured's exposure to an excess judgment. A demand above the limits does not trigger the duty, even if it is reasonable.

Florida has a statute alongside its common law. Fla. Stat. 624.155(1)(b)1. makes it a basis for a civil action when an insurer does not attempt in good faith to settle claims when, under all the circumstances, it could and should have done so, "had it acted fairly and honestly toward its insured and with due regard for her or his interests." The same section adds that mere negligence alone is insufficient to constitute bad faith. For the general concept, see insurance bad faith explained and the glossary entry bad faith.

How the deadline creates exposure

The sequence that leads to an excess judgment usually runs like this:

  1. A serious injury occurs, and the claim value plausibly exceeds the policy limit.
  2. The claimant sends a limits demand with a deadline.
  3. The insurer does not accept in time. Reasons vary: it disputes fault, wants more medical records, or cannot get a signed release in time.
  4. The case is tried or settled for more than the limit.
  5. The insured faces the excess, or the claimant takes an assignment of the insured's rights and sues the insurer for it.

A case like Crisci shows the pattern, but with a twist: in many states the insured can recover the excess from the insurer only if the refusal was unreasonable. A refusal that was reasonable at the time, because liability was truly disputed or the damages unsupported, generally does not create excess liability. That is why the terms of the demand matter so much.

What states now require of demands

Because disputes over deadlines are common, three large states regulate how a demand must be written, so that an insurer is not penalized for missing a trap.

California (since January 1, 2023)

Section 999.1 says a time-limited demand must be in writing, be labeled as a time-limited demand or reference the section, and contain these material terms:

  • a deadline not fewer than 30 days from transmission if sent by email, fax or certified mail, or not fewer than 33 days if sent by mail;
  • a clear and unequivocal offer to settle all claims within policy limits, including satisfaction of all liens;
  • an offer of a complete release of the insurer's insureds from all present and future liability for the occurrence;
  • the date and location of the loss, the claim number if known, and a description of all known injuries; and
  • reasonable proof, which may include medical records or bills, sufficient to support the claim.

Two further provisions matter. Under section 999.3, asking for clarification, additional information or an extension is not, by itself, a counteroffer or rejection, and an insurer that does not accept must tell the claimant in writing its decision and the basis for it before the demand expires. Under section 999.4, a demand that does not substantially comply is not considered a reasonable offer to settle within limits for purposes of a lawsuit alleging extracontractual damages. That protection does not apply to a claimant without a lawyer. The chapter applies to auto, homeowner and commercial premises liability claims for demands sent on or after January 1, 2023.

Georgia (amended effective July 1, 2024)

Georgia's O.C.G.A. 9-11-67.1, as reproduced on that site, treats an offer to settle a motor vehicle injury claim as an offer to enter a bilateral contract. For offers prepared with an attorney, it lists the only material terms, including an acceptance date not less than 30 days from receipt of an offer sent by certified mail or statutory overnight delivery, the payment amount, the parties and claims released, a payment delivery date not less than 40 days from receipt, and, unless waived, a requirement that the recipient give a sworn statement on whether all applicable liability insurance has been disclosed. The offer must include medical or other records sufficient to evaluate the claim. Any term outside the listed ones is treated as immaterial, and recipients can seek clarification in writing without making a counteroffer.

Florida (90-day safe harbor)

Florida takes a different route. Fla. Stat. 624.155(4) provides that a bad faith action involving a liability claim "shall not lie" if the insurer tenders the lesser of the policy limits or the amount demanded within 90 days after receiving actual notice of a claim accompanied by sufficient evidence to support its amount. The statute also puts a duty of good faith on the insured, the claimant and their representatives in furnishing information, making demands, and setting deadlines, and lets the jury consider that when reducing damages.

State Minimum response time Documentation Effect of a non-compliant demand
California 30 days (33 if mailed) Injury description and reasonable proof Not a reasonable offer within limits for extracontractual claims; not applicable if claimant unrepresented
Georgia 30 days from receipt; payment not before 40 days Medical or other records sufficient to evaluate Extra terms are immaterial; recipients may seek clarification
Florida 90-day tender safe harbor Claim with sufficient evidence of amount Timely tender bars a bad faith action
Texas No statute described here; common-law test Demand within limits and reasonable Stowers duty not triggered without all three elements

Other states have their own approach or none, and the tests change. To see yours, ask your state insurance department or an attorney; state car insurance requirements lookup covers minimum limits but not demand rules.

What happens when the deadline passes

If the insurer neither accepts nor responds in time, the offer lapses and the claimant is free to sue for more. The lapse does not by itself create excess liability. What matters in a later bad faith claim is the full record: what the insurer knew, whether the demand was clear, whether a prudent insurer without limits would have accepted, and what the insurer told you.

Three things can still help an insurer that missed a deadline: a request for clarification made in time, a written explanation of its decision, and, in states with a safe harbor, a tender within the window. California's section 999.3 requires the written explanation, and it makes that notice relevant in a later lawsuit alleging extracontractual damages.

Your rights and role as the insured

You are not a bystander. In practice, you can ask the insurer, in writing, to protect your interests, and you can hire your own lawyer at your own expense to speak for you on the excess exposure.

  1. Read the letter the day it arrives and ask what the deadline is, in writing.
  2. Tell the insurer in writing that you want the claim settled within limits if the injuries clearly exceed them. A paper trail helps in any later dispute.
  3. Respond fast to the insurer's requests for facts, statements and documents. If the insurer cannot document the claim because you did not respond, you weaken your position.
  4. Ask whether other insurance applies, including an umbrella policy or a second household policy, and notify those carriers promptly.
  5. Consider personal counsel. The insurer's lawyer represents the defense; a lawyer you hire advises you about your own money. See excess letters and time-limit demands: what to do as the insured for a deeper walk-through of the insured's first days.
  6. Do not sign anything the claimant sends you directly without a lawyer's review.
  7. Do not move or hide assets. That can create separate legal problems.

A limits review before it matters

You cannot choose the demand, but you can choose how large a gap would be left. A simple review:

  • List your assets and income that a judgment could reach: savings, home equity, future wages.
  • Compare that to your liability limit. A $25,000 per-person limit is exposed by a single hospital stay. The how much liability coverage do you need? guide and the How much car insurance do I need? show how to set a number.
  • Price the next step up. Ask for quotes at higher limits, for example 100/300/100 versus your current limits, and compare the premium difference with the added protection. The cost of each step varies by insurer and state, so get quotes rather than assuming.
  • Price an umbrella. An umbrella policy sits above your auto limit and can be cheaper per dollar of protection; see umbrella insurance: liability protection above your auto policy. Check whether it requires a minimum underlying auto limit.
  • Compare how policies read. Look at the declarations page for the limit structure (liability limits decoder) and ask about defense costs and how the insurer handles demands.

The point for shoppers: the best time to discover that your limit is too low is before you are in a situation where a demand letter arrives. Higher limits make a demand less likely to exceed your coverage.

For the related stages, see refused settlements and excess judgments: the insurer's duty to settle and excess judgments: when a verdict is larger than your policy limit.

Common questions

Is a time-limited demand always a trap?

No. Many are good-faith offers to settle for the limit, and accepting protects everyone. The concern arises when a demand is vague, lacks proof, or sets a deadline that cannot reasonably be met.

Does my insurer need my permission to settle?

The policy in Crisci authorized the insurer to make any settlement it deemed expedient, and many liability policies are written that way; check yours. That is why the duty to settle exists. Ask your insurer in writing to settle within limits if you want it to.

Can I pay the difference myself to settle?

Sometimes a claimant will accept the limit plus a contribution from the insured. Whether that is wise, and what the release must say, is a question for a lawyer.

What if I am the claimant?

A demand that follows the state's requirements and includes documentation is stronger evidence of a reasonable offer than a short letter with a short fuse.

Key takeaways

  • A time-limited demand offers to settle for the limit by a deadline; a missed deadline can lead to an excess judgment only if refusal was unreasonable.
  • Courts ask whether a prudent insurer without policy limits would have accepted, as in Crisci and, with extra prerequisites, Texas's Stowers doctrine.
  • California, Georgia and Florida regulate demands, with minimum response times and documentation or tender safe harbors.
  • As the insured, respond promptly, put your wishes in writing, and consider personal counsel.
  • Review your limits and umbrella coverage by getting quotes before a claim, not after.

Sources

Terms used in this guide

Related states

Related guides

Related tools

Latest on this topic