Blog

Bad faith or just a disagreement: what counts as insurer misconduct

A slow or low claim is not automatically bad faith. How courts and regulators separate honest disputes from misconduct, and what to keep and do next.

A slow claim, a low offer or a denial you dislike is a disagreement until it fails a legal test. Bad faith is conduct without a reasonable basis, such as ignoring evidence, stalling with no explanation, or refusing a fair settlement for no good reason. Many disputes are honest differences about what a car was worth or what a policy covers, and those are resolved by negotiation, appraisal or a regulator complaint, not a lawsuit.

This article separates the two, explains how the rules differ between your own insurer and the other driver's insurer, and lists the evidence worth keeping. The law varies by state, so the examples below come from California, Florida and Washington. Use state car insurance requirements lookup or your state insurance department to find your own rules, and talk to a licensed attorney before acting on a specific dispute.

Two kinds of bad faith claim

Lawyers use "bad faith" for several different legal theories, and which one applies depends on who is complaining.

A first-party claim is a claim you make under your own policy: collision, comprehensive, medical payments, uninsured motorist. Your insurer owes you a contractual duty to pay what the policy promises. When it breaches that duty without a reasonable basis, some states allow a separate lawsuit for bad faith on top of the claim for the unpaid benefits. See first-party vs third-party claims for how the two claim types differ.

A third-party claim is a claim made against someone insured by the company. The classic bad faith case here is an insurer that refuses a reasonable settlement offer within the policy limits and then loses at trial for more than the limit. The California Supreme Court described this in Comunale v. Traders & General Insurance Co., 50 Cal. 2d 654 (1958): an insurer that refused to settle within limits, only because it wrongly denied coverage, was liable for the whole judgment against its insured. The court grounded the duty in the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing that it found in every contract (Comunale opinion on Case.law, checked November 2026).

In Gruenberg v. Aetna Insurance Co., 9 Cal. 3d 566 (1973), the same court reaffirmed that the duty to deal fairly with the insured, when breached, "sounds in both contract and tort" (Gruenberg opinion on Case.law, checked November 2026). The practical meaning is that damages can go beyond the unpaid benefit. That is one California example. Other states set their own limits, and some allow far less.

If you were the one sued after a crash and the other side offered to settle within your limits, read refused settlements and excess judgments: the insurer's duty to settle. The rest of this article focuses on the more common situation: you are dealing with a claim and suspect your own insurer, or the other driver's insurer, is acting unfairly.

Three layers of rules

Insurer conduct is policed by three overlapping sets of rules, and a complaint can fit one without fitting the others.

  1. Unfair claims settlement practices laws and regulations. Most states have adopted some version of the NAIC model act and model regulation. They define what a regulator can punish. In most states they are enforced by the insurance department, not by individual policyholders suing.
  2. Statutes that create a private lawsuit. A minority of states, including Florida and Washington, have statutes that let a policyholder sue for specific kinds of misconduct.
  3. Common-law bad faith. Court decisions in many states recognize a claim based on the duty of good faith in the insurance contract, as in the California cases above.

What the NAIC model says

The NAIC Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act (Model 900) lists acts such as knowingly misrepresenting policy provisions, failing to acknowledge communications promptly, and not attempting in good faith to settle claims where liability is reasonably clear. Section 3 says these are improper only when committed "flagrantly and in conscious disregard" of the law, or "with such frequency to indicate a general business practice." Section 1 adds that nothing in the act should be read to create a private cause of action, and a drafting note says a state that wants one should use a different scheme (NAIC Model 900, checked November 2026).

That structure explains why one slow claim is usually a regulatory matter rather than a lawsuit. The model is aimed at patterns. A state that adopts it can still discipline an insurer based on complaints, but your own damages come from your policy and, where it exists, a separate statute or court doctrine.

What a regulation can require

The companion NAIC Model Regulation 902 turns the general standards into deadlines and rules. Among them: the insurer must tell a first-party claimant whether the claim is accepted or denied within 21 days after receiving properly executed proofs of loss, and a denial based on a policy provision must cite that provision and be in writing. If more time is needed, it must say so within 21 days, and again every 45 days (NAIC Model 902, checked November 2026). States adopt their own numbers. California, for example, requires acceptance or denial within 40 calendar days of proof of claim and a written explanation every 30 days while the claim stays open (10 CCR 2695.7, checked November 2026).

The point for you is simple. A missed deadline in your state's regulation is documented evidence of a problem. It is not, by itself, proof of bad faith.

Examples that tend to qualify and ones that tend not to

No two cases are alike, and the outcome depends on state law and the file. These are patterns that regulators and courts treat differently.

Situation Usually a disagreement More likely misconduct
Total loss offer is lower than expected Insurer used comparable cars you think are wrong, but it itemized them and will review your evidence Insurer will not consider the listings, service records or option packages you submit, or will not explain its adjustments
Slow response Short delay while a supplement or police report arrives, with notice of the reason Weeks of silence, no required status letters, repeated requests for the same documents
Denial A written denial citing a policy exclusion that plausibly applies A denial that misstates the policy, cites no provision, or contradicts the policy language
Repair estimate Insurer pays less than the shop quote and discloses why Insurer refuses to look at the shop's estimate, or will not consider damage found during repair
Settlement in a liability claim Insurer offers less than your demand after a real evaluation Insurer refuses to settle within limits for a reason unrelated to the merits
Medical or PIP benefits Benefits stop after a documented independent exam Benefits stop with no medical basis and no written explanation

Look at the California regulation's own list for what a reasonable offer review looks like. It says an offer is "unreasonably low" if the insurer did not consider the evidence submitted by the claimant to support the claim's value, did not consider legal authority or evidence reasonably available to it, or did not consider the advice of its adjuster, among other factors (10 CCR 2695.7(g), checked November 2026). That is why the evidence you submit matters twice: it supports the value and it creates a record of what the insurer was told.

Washington's regulation includes a list that reads like a checklist of misconduct. It includes refusing to pay claims without a reasonable investigation, failing to affirm or deny coverage within a reasonable time after proof of loss, and compelling a first-party claimant to start litigation, arbitration or appraisal by offering substantially less than the amounts ultimately recovered (WAC 284-30-330, checked November 2026).

A hypothetical example, with numbers we define. Suppose an insurer offers $9,800 for your totaled sedan. You send three dealer listings that average $11,600 with the same trim and similar mileage. The insurer replies that its valuation stands, with no discussion of your listings. That is a disagreement over value, and the insurer may be right. It starts looking like a problem if the insurer will not say why your listings are not comparable, since the California rules require adjustments to be itemized and documented. Asking for the explanation in writing is the first step either way.

What the statutes in three states allow

California

The California regulations quoted above are enforced by the California Department of Insurance. For private suits, the Gruenberg decision shows that a first-party tort claim for breach of the duty of good faith is recognized in the state, but this article does not summarize its later history or limits. Whether a particular claim qualifies, and what damages are available, is a question for a California attorney.

Florida

Florida's statute, section 624.155, lets a person sue an insurer who is damaged when the insurer fails to attempt in good faith to settle claims when, under all the circumstances, it could and should have done so, "had it acted fairly and honestly toward its insured and with due regard for her or his interests." Before suing, the claimant must give the Department of Financial Services and the insurer 60 days' written notice on the department's form. No action lies if the insurer pays the damages or corrects the circumstances within 60 days after receiving the notice (Florida Statutes 624.155, checked November 2026).

The same statute adds limits that apply to every Florida bad faith action: mere negligence alone is insufficient, and claimants have their own duty to act in good faith in furnishing information, making demands and setting deadlines. A claim on a liability policy cannot succeed if the insurer tenders the lesser of the policy limit or the amount demanded within 90 days after receiving actual notice of a claim accompanied by sufficient evidence to support its amount.

Washington

Washington's Insurance Fair Conduct Act, RCW 48.30.015, lets a first-party claimant who is "unreasonably denied" a claim for coverage or benefits sue for actual damages plus attorneys' fees and litigation costs, and the court may increase the award up to three times the actual damages. Twenty days before filing, the claimant must give written notice of the basis for the action to the insurer and the insurance commissioner. If the insurer does not resolve the basis within those 20 days, the claimant can sue without more notice (RCW 48.30.015, checked November 2026).

Three states, three different structures: a regulation backed by case law, a notice-and-cure statute, and a statute with enhanced damages. This is why a rule you read about online may not apply where you live.

Remedies: what you can actually get

A regulator complaint can lead to a corrected payment, a written explanation or discipline against the insurer. A lawsuit can lead to more, but only where state law allows. Where a statute or court decision recognizes bad faith, remedies may include the unpaid benefit, interest, attorney's fees, other damages caused by the delay, and in some states multiplied or punitive damages. The Washington statute above shows one version with fees and an increase up to three times actual damages. Florida's statute is one that sets the notice and cure rules.

In many states there is no private bad faith action for a routine claim at all, and the policy remedy is a breach of contract suit for the amount owed plus interest. A consultation with a licensed attorney in your state will tell you which rules apply to your facts. The general guide insurance bad faith explained covers the basic concepts, and when to hire a lawyer after a car accident covers when a lawyer is worth the cost.

Evidence to keep from day one

Almost every bad faith theory depends on the paper trail. Build it from the first call.

  1. A claim log. Date, time, name and what was said in every call. Send a short email after each call confirming what you understood.
  2. Every document the insurer sent. Estimates, valuation reports, denial letters, reservation of rights letters and status letters, with envelopes or email headers showing dates.
  3. Everything you sent. Listings, receipts, service records, photos, repair estimates, medical records, with proof of delivery.
  4. The policy. The full policy and declarations page in effect on the loss date, not a summary.
  5. Loss records. Police report, photos taken at the scene, towing and storage invoices, rental receipts.
  6. Out-of-pocket costs caused by delay. Rental charges, rideshare costs, storage fees, late fees on a loan.

California's regulation requires an insurer that denies a first-party claim in writing to give "all bases" for the denial and the factual and legal basis for each reason, and the written notice must tell the claimant that the California Department of Insurance can review the matter (10 CCR 2695.7(b), checked November 2026). Compare any denial you receive with your own state's version of that rule.

Regulator complaint or lawsuit

Regulator complaint Lawsuit
Cost Free Attorney fees, filing fees, experts; some statutes shift fees to a winning claimant
Speed Insurer must respond; timeline depends on the department Months to years
Result Insurer explanation, corrected payment or discipline; the department does not award damages to you in most states Possible damages where state law allows
Evidence needed Your documents and the insurer's response Formal discovery, depositions, expert testimony
Best for Missed deadlines, unexplained denials, offers that ignore your evidence Large losses, a clear pattern, or a failure to settle within limits
Time limits Check your state's rules Statutes of limitations apply, and the policy may have its own suit deadline

The two are not exclusive. Many people file a complaint with the state insurance department first because it costs nothing and puts the insurer on written notice. how to file a complaint against a car insurance company walks through the steps, and after you file a department of insurance complaint: what to expect explains what the process looks like afterward. California's department publishes a complaint page with an online form for auto claims (California Department of Insurance: Getting Help, checked November 2026). Florida's Division of Consumer Services tells consumers to contact the insurance company first, keep detailed records of all communications, write a formal letter if needed, and then ask the division for help if the problem remains (Florida Department of Financial Services: Get Insurance Help, checked November 2026).

Before you assume you have a lawsuit, check the clock. Both the statute of limitations and any policy suit-limitation clause can run out while you negotiate. See statute of limitations and statutes of limitations for car accident claims.

A step-by-step approach to a disputed claim

  1. Ask for the reason in writing. For a denial or a low offer, request the specific policy provision or valuation data relied on.
  2. Answer with evidence. Send documents that address the insurer's stated reason, and say what you want: a revised payment, a re-inspection, a supplement.
  3. Set a reasonable deadline. Ask for a response by a specific date and cite any state deadline that applies to you. See writing a claim dispute letter to your insurer: structure and evidence for an outline.
  4. Escalate inside the company. Ask for a supervisor or the insurer's internal appeal process. how to appeal a denied car insurance claim covers this.
  5. Use the contract's tools. For a value dispute, the appraisal clause may be available. See the appraisal clause: settling a dispute over value.
  6. File a regulator complaint. Attach the file you built.
  7. Consult an attorney if the amount is large, there is an injury, you face a suit, or the insurer refused a settlement within limits.

Common questions

Is a low offer bad faith?

Not by itself. A low offer becomes a problem when it is made without a reasonable basis, for example by ignoring the evidence you submitted or by failing to explain adjustments. The California regulation treats consideration of the claimant's evidence as a factor in deciding whether an offer is unreasonably low.

Can I sue my insurer in every state?

No. The NAIC model act says it does not create a private cause of action, and states differ on whether a policyholder can sue under a statute or under court decisions. Florida and Washington have statutes with specific notice rules, while other states rely on case law. Ask a licensed attorney in your state.

Does a late response prove bad faith?

No, but it can support a regulator complaint if it violates a deadline in your state's rules. Check the time limits in your state's claims regulation and keep dated proof that you made the request.

Should I record phone calls?

Recording rules differ by state, and some require every party's consent. Safer ways to build a record are follow-up emails and a written call log.

Key takeaways

  • Bad faith needs more than a slow or low claim: a lack of reasonable basis, a pattern, or a refusal to consider evidence.
  • Rules differ sharply by state: California relies on regulations and case law, Florida requires a 60-day notice and cure process, and Washington allows enhanced damages after a 20-day notice.
  • The strongest record is dated and in writing: what you asked, what you sent, what the insurer said.
  • A regulator complaint is free and often the right first escalation; a lawsuit is a slower tool for larger or clearer problems.
  • Check deadlines early, because statutes of limitations and policy suit clauses keep running.

Sources

Terms used in this guide

Related states

Related guides

Related tools

Latest on this topic