Blog
Choosing a car with insurance in mind: a pre-purchase checklist
Get insurance quotes on the exact car before you sign. A checklist covering trim, safety equipment, theft, repair costs, IIHS and HLDI data, and timing.
Check the insurance cost before you buy by getting quotes on the exact car you are considering, with the same coverage you will carry, before you sign the sales contract. Two cars with the same sticker price can carry very different premiums, and the gap comes from claim history for that model, repair costs, theft, safety equipment and your own driver profile. A quote takes a short while to get, and it can change which trim or model you choose.
This checklist explains what drives the difference, what the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) and its Highway Loss Data Institute (HLDI) publish that you can check yourself, and what two insurers say about safety and anti-theft discounts. It is written as of November 2026. Premiums are personal and state-specific, so every number here is either from a named source or an invented example labelled as such.
Why the same price tag can mean different premiums
An insurer sets your price from rating factors about you, your location and the vehicle (rating factors). For the vehicle, three kinds of cost matter.
- Collision and comprehensive losses. What the insurer pays to fix or replace this model after crashes, theft and other damage. See collision coverage and comprehensive coverage.
- Liability and injury claims. How often drivers of the model cause damage to others or are hurt, which the vehicle's design and its typical drivers influence.
- Repair and replacement cost. Parts, labor, calibration of safety sensors and the chance the car is totaled (total loss).
You cannot see the insurer's calculation, but you can see published loss data for hundreds of models, and you can ask for quotes. The two together tell you more than the price tag.
Step 1: Use the HLDI loss data as a first screen
HLDI publishes insurance loss results by make and model each year. IIHS says its database holds records from companies representing more than 85 percent of the U.S. private passenger auto insurance market, and that consumers shopping for a safe vehicle "should focus on models with fewer, less severe claims than the average — especially under injury coverages" (IIHS: auto insurance, checked November 2026).
The make-and-model tables are described on the HLDI page (IIHS and HLDI: insurance losses by make and model, checked November 2026). What it says that matters for a buyer:
- Results exist for several coverages, including collision, property damage liability, comprehensive and injury coverages, and models are grouped by size and class so a pickup is compared with other pickups.
- For collision, property damage liability and comprehensive, results reflect both how often claims happen and the average payment per claim. Injury results reflect claim frequency only.
- Results are adjusted for factors other than the vehicle, including operator age, calendar year, density, gender, marital status, model year, risk (standard or nonstandard) and state. Collision and comprehensive are also adjusted for deductible.
- The data generally predict the experience of current versions of the same model, but when a manufacturer substantially redesigns a vehicle the earlier results may not apply.
How to use it: look up your shortlist, compare each model with its class average, and note which coverage is driving the number. A model that is worse than average on collision may be expensive to fix; a model worse than average on comprehensive may be stolen or hit by hail more often. The tables show how a model's losses compare, not what your premium will be. For more, see IIHS and HLDI insurance loss data: what it shows about cars.
Step 2: Check the safety ratings, then the equipment on the exact trim
IIHS says its Top Safety Pick and Top Safety Pick+ awards identify the best vehicle choices for safety within size categories in a given year. For the plus award, the criteria it lists include good ratings in the small overlap front, moderate overlap front and side tests, acceptable or good headlights, good pedestrian front crash prevention and acceptable or good vehicle-to-vehicle front crash prevention, with standard availability noted for some of those items (IIHS: Top Safety Pick winners, checked November 2026).
The phrase "standard availability" matters. A model can win an award only when certain equipment is available on a trim, and the page also notes limits such as an award applying only to vehicles built after a given month. The practical consequence is that the safety equipment on the lot car is not guaranteed to be what the award describes.
Do this on the specific car:
- Find the exact trim and build date in the window sticker or VIN-based listing.
- Compare it with the award's stated criteria, including build-date notes.
- Note which driver-assistance features are standard, optional, or missing.
- Ask the insurer which of those features it recognizes (below).
Step 3: Learn what the insurer says about discounts tied to the car
Insurers describe vehicle-related discounts, but amounts and eligibility vary. Two examples, checked November 2026:
- State Farm says additional savings are available "depending on the safety features of your car's make and model, including driver assist technology." It lists a passive restraint discount for factory-installed air bags or other passive restraints, up to 40 percent on medical-related coverage, and an anti-theft discount for a vehicle with an alarm or other approved anti-theft device (State Farm: auto insurance discounts).
- Nationwide lists an anti-theft discount that applies if the vehicle is equipped with certain anti-theft devices, noting that proof of an installed device may be required (Nationwide: auto insurance discounts).
These pages do not say what your percentage will be, which features count, or which model years qualify. See safety feature and anti-theft discounts and anti-theft device discount. The most efficient move is to ask each insurer during the quote which vehicle discounts are already applied and which need proof.
Step 4: Check theft exposure for the model and your area
The National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB) reported that 659,880 vehicles were reported stolen nationwide in 2025, which Insurance Journal's coverage describes as the largest decrease in thefts in 40 years. NICB's list put the Hyundai Elantra first, with 21,732 thefts, followed by the Honda Accord with 17,797, and said California, Texas and Illinois had the most thefts by state (Insurance Journal: Vehicle Thefts Declined Nearly 25% Last Year: NICB, March 19, 2026; trade press reporting the NICB release, whose own report I did not open).
Use that as a risk indicator, not a verdict. A model that tops a national list may be rarely stolen where you live, and a model off the list may be targeted in your neighborhood. To see how the statistics are produced and where they mislead, read How car theft statistics are counted: FBI, NICB and insurer data. For devices that deter theft and how thieves beat them, read anti-theft devices compared: immobilizers, trackers and locks. Ask each insurer how it treats the specific model's theft history and whether a factory immobilizer or tracking device changes the quote.
Step 5: Think about repair cost, not just crash performance
A car can score well in crash tests and still be costly to repair. Sensors in bumpers, windshields and mirrors may need calibration after a repair, and parts prices differ by make. The HLDI table's average loss per claim for collision is the closest public signal for repair cost, because it combines how often claims occur and what they cost. See advanced driver-assistance systems for the term.
Compare quotes for two comparable cars: if one has an average loss per claim worse than its class and the other better, the premium gap is partly explained. If both are similar, the gap likely comes from other factors, such as the trim or your location.
Step 6: Get quotes by the exact car
Before you buy, ask for quotes with:
- the exact year, make, model and trim (or the VIN if the insurer accepts it for a pre-purchase quote);
- the same limits, deductibles and add-ons on every quote (deductible);
- the same drivers and garaging address;
- a start date that matches the day you will take delivery.
Use the car insurance quote comparison worksheet so you compare like with like. If the seller is a dealer, you will need proof of insurance when you take the car. The steps for that day are in insuring a new car: what to do before you drive off the lot. If a lender or lessor is involved, it may require specific coverages and deductibles, so confirm before you quote.
Worked example (hypothetical numbers)
Suppose a buyer is choosing between two compact crossovers, Car A and Car B, at the same $30,000 price. The numbers below are invented to show the process.
| Item | Car A | Car B |
|---|---|---|
| Six-month quote, same coverage | $980 | $1,240 |
| HLDI collision result vs class | Better than average | Worse than average |
| HLDI comprehensive result vs class | Average | Worse than average |
| Safety equipment on lot trim | Includes front-crash prevention | Optional on this trim |
| Anti-theft device | Factory immobilizer | Factory immobilizer |
The six-month gap is $260, so a year's gap would be $520, and over a three-year ownership about $1,560 if the quotes stayed flat (they will not). The buyer asks Car B's dealer whether the next trim up includes front-crash prevention as standard and gets a revised quote of $1,150 for that trim. Then the buyer compares the trim's extra purchase price against the $90 six-month saving. The choice is clearer with numbers than from the sticker.
Pre-purchase checklist
- [ ] Shortlisted models looked up in the HLDI loss tables, with class comparison noted.
- [ ] Safety ratings and the Top Safety Pick criteria checked against the actual trim and build date.
- [ ] Driver-assistance features listed as standard, optional or missing.
- [ ] Theft exposure checked for the model and your state, and the insurer asked about it.
- [ ] Repair-cost signals reviewed, including sensor calibration for the trim.
- [ ] Quotes obtained on the exact car with identical coverage from at least three insurers.
- [ ] Each insurer asked which vehicle discounts are applied and which need proof.
- [ ] Start date set to the delivery date, with proof of insurance ready for the dealer.
- [ ] Lender or lessor insurance requirements confirmed.
Common mistakes
- Quoting the wrong trim. A base trim may lack the equipment that earns a discount or an award.
- Comparing different deductibles. A lower premium with a higher deductible is not cheaper in the way you think.
- Assuming a safety award means a lower price. The IIHS awards are about crash and prevention performance. A discount is the insurer's separate decision.
- Waiting until delivery. If the quote is higher than expected, you have no leverage once the paperwork is signed.
- Forgetting a teen driver. If a teen will drive the car, see choosing a first car for a teen using safety and insurance data.
Common questions
Can I get an insurance quote before buying a car?
Ask each insurer. I did not find a published rule on the insurer pages I opened, so confirm whether it will quote a car you do not yet own, whether it wants the model and trim or the VIN, and when the quote expires.
Do IIHS awards lower insurance premiums?
IIHS says its awards identify the best vehicle choices for safety. Insurers set their own prices, and State Farm's page says discounts depend on the safety features of the make and model. Ask the insurer which features count.
Does the theft list mean my car will cost more to insure?
Not by itself. NICB's list shows which models were reported stolen most often in 2025, but insurers price using their own data and your location. Ask how the model is rated.
How reliable are HLDI results for a newly redesigned car?
HLDI says the results generally predict the experience of current versions of a model, but substantial redesigns may make an earlier model's results less relevant.
Key takeaways
- Get quotes on the exact car, with identical coverage, before you sign.
- Use the HLDI loss tables for a first screen and compare each model with its class.
- Check that the trim you are buying actually has the safety equipment the awards and discounts describe.
- Treat theft lists as risk signals and ask the insurer how it rates the model.
- Set the policy start date for delivery day and confirm lender requirements.
Sources
- IIHS: auto insurance, database coverage and the advice to focus on models with fewer, less severe claims, checked November 2026
- IIHS and HLDI: insurance losses by make and model, what the loss results measure and their adjustments, checked November 2026
- IIHS: Top Safety Pick winners, award criteria and build-date notes, checked November 2026
- State Farm: auto insurance discounts, vehicle safety, passive restraint and anti-theft discounts, checked November 2026
- Nationwide: auto insurance discounts, anti-theft discount and proof of device, checked November 2026
- Insurance Journal: Vehicle Thefts Declined Nearly 25% Last Year: NICB, 2025 theft totals and most-stolen models (trade press reporting NICB), checked November 2026