Blog

How price changes as you raise limits and deductibles: worked numbers

Filed North Carolina factors show how premium moves with liability limits and deductibles, with worked examples and a list of quote variants to request.

Premium does not move in a straight line when you change limits or deductibles. Liability gets cheaper per dollar of protection as limits rise, while deductible discounts flatten out quickly: in North Carolina's filed manual, moving a collision deductible from $100 to $1,000 changes the collision premium by only 13%. The numbers below come from that manual, which is one of the few personal auto rate manuals the public can open in full, so you can see the actual shape of the curves rather than a rule of thumb.

One caution before the tables. These are North Carolina's factors, filed by the North Carolina Rate Bureau, and a company in another state files its own. The shape of each curve is typical of how rating factors work, but the exact percentages are not a national price list. Treat the examples as a way to read your own quotes, and use your state's regulator or the state car insurance requirements lookup tool to see what your state requires before you pick any limit.

Where the numbers come from

Two North Carolina Rate Bureau documents carry most of what follows. The first is the Bureau's 2024 private passenger auto rate filing, which prints the increased limits tables for bodily injury, property damage and medical payments. A note in the filing says the factors on its page B-3 resulted from the settlement of the Bureau's February 1, 2023 filing and became effective December 1, 2023.

The second is the Bureau's Circular A-25-3, which announces the rates and rules effective October 1, 2025. It says the Bureau and the Commissioner of Insurance settled a June 6, 2025 consent order for an overall +5.0% rate level change, and it lists revised deductible relativities (Rule 14) among the changes. I checked both documents in November 2026. Any later filing could change the factors, and nothing here is a quote.

Two terms need defining. A relativity or factor is a multiplier applied to a base premium. An increased limits factor (ILF) is the multiplier for a liability limit above the basic one. A CAS study note by actuary Joseph Palmer, Increased Limits Ratemaking for Liability Insurance, explains why the industry uses them: there is usually not enough claim data at high loss sizes to calculate a rate separately for every limit, so the analysis is split in two parts and the factors are applied to a lower-limit rate. That is why the high-limit prices you see are smoothed, filed numbers and not a separate price for each limit. The blog piece on why doubling liability limits does not double the premium covers the logic in more depth.

The liability curve: bodily injury

North Carolina's bodily injury table uses 30/60 (a $30,000 per-person and $60,000 per-accident limit) as the base, with a factor of 1.00. The filing lists these factors for the higher limits:

Limit (per person / per accident) Filed factor
30/60 1.00
50/100 1.23
100/100 1.39
100/200 1.49
100/300 1.50
300/300 1.78
250/500 1.83
500/1,000 2.07
1,000/1,000 2.20
1,000/2,000 2.28

Source: North Carolina Rate Bureau 2024 filing, page B-3, factors effective December 1, 2023.

A worked example with defined numbers

Suppose, hypothetically, that the bodily injury premium at 30/60 for a driver is $420 a year. Multiplying by the filed factors gives:

Limit Factor Annual bodily injury premium Cost per $1,000 of per-person limit
30/60 1.00 $420.00 $14.00
50/100 1.23 $516.60 $10.33
100/300 1.50 $630.00 $6.30
250/500 1.83 $768.60 $3.07
500/1,000 2.07 $869.40 $1.74

Going from 30/60 to 100/300 more than triples the per-person limit and quintuples the per-accident limit, yet the premium rises 50%, or $210 in this example. Going on to 250/500 adds only $138.60 more and buys another 2.5 times the per-person protection. The step from 100/300 to 250/500 is the cheapest protection in the table per dollar. That is the "diminishing returns" in reverse: for liability, the first dollars of limit are the expensive ones.

The pattern has a practical meaning. A driver who carries the state minimum is paying the highest price per dollar of protection. A shopper who prices 100/300 and finds it costs a third more than 30/60, not three times more, has seen the ILF at work. The companion piece the price of liability limits: how much each step up really costs walks through the same idea with other limits, and how much liability coverage do you need? helps decide how much protection is enough.

The limits of this curve

Three caveats apply. First, the table applies only to the base 30/60 bodily injury rate, so a hypothetical $420 premium already contains the driver's class, territory and other factors, which are multiplied before or after the limit factor depending on the manual. Second, the factors above are one state's. A 100/300 factor of 1.50 in North Carolina does not tell you what 100/300 costs in Michigan or Florida. Third, the table says nothing about whether you need the limit. Whether a $100,000 per-person limit is adequate depends on what your assets and likely claim costs are, which is a different question from price.

The liability curve: property damage and medical payments

Property damage liability is much flatter. The same filing lists a $25,000 base, with factors of 1.008 at $35,000, 1.016 at $50,000, 1.048 at $100,000, 1.095 at $250,000, 1.115 at $300,000, 1.182 at $500,000, 1.247 at $750,000 and 1.326 at $1,000,000.

With a hypothetical $180 property damage premium at $25,000, that works out as:

Property damage limit Factor Annual premium Added cost over $25,000
$25,000 1.000 $180.00 $0
$50,000 1.016 $182.88 $2.88
$100,000 1.048 $188.64 $8.64
$300,000 1.115 $200.70 $20.70

Quadrupling the limit from $25,000 to $100,000 costs about $8.64 a year in this example. The likely reason is the one behind all increased limits factors: the factor is the ratio of expected cost at the higher limit to expected cost at the basic limit, and when few claims reach the upper layers, that ratio stays close to 1. That is my reading of how the factors work, not a statement from the filing. Where one expensive vehicle is the claim, the higher limit protects you, and the price shows it is one of the cheapest upgrades available. (Property damage limits also interact with what you drive: a $25,000 limit does not cover much if you hit a new truck.)

Medical payments coverage behaves differently. The filing's table is based on a $500 limit and lists factors of 1.45 at $750, 1.83 at $1,000, 2.98 at $2,000, 3.73 at $3,000 and 4.62 at $5,000. Here the premium climbs quickly with the limit, because the base limit is small and the extra layers are likely to be used. A reader comparing an $1,000 medical payments option with a $5,000 option should expect the price to be about two and a half times as high on these factors (4.62 divided by 1.83 is about 2.5). So "where is an extra dollar cheapest" has no single answer: it is cheapest in high bodily injury and property damage limits, and not cheap in small first-party medical limits.

The deductible curve: collision

For collision coverage, North Carolina's manual prices deductibles as a percentage of the $100-deductible premium. The October 1, 2025 circular lists these charges for the deductibles whose premiums are not printed:

Collision deductible Charge as a percent of the $100-deductible premium
$50 101%
$100 100% (base)
$200 98%
$250 97%
$500 93%
$1,000 87%

The circular also removed the $25 collision deductible. In the old rule the $500 deductible was priced at 91% and the $1,000 deductible at 81%; the settlement moved them to 93% and 87%, a flatter curve than before.

Worked example: what each step saves

Suppose a hypothetical collision premium at the $100 deductible is $640 a year. The filed percentages give:

Deductible Annual collision premium Saved versus $100
$100 $640.00 $0
$200 $627.20 $12.80
$250 $620.80 $19.20
$500 $595.20 $44.80
$1,000 $556.80 $83.20

Now compare steps. Moving from $500 to $1,000 saves $38.40 a year ($595.20 minus $556.80). It also adds $500 to what you pay after a claim. If you have a collision claim only once every 13 years, the saving breaks even ($500 divided by $38.40 is 13.0). If you have a claim sooner, the lower deductible would have paid back. Moving from $250 to $500 saves $25.60 for $250 of added exposure, a break-even of just under 10 years (9.8). The first step from $100 to $200 breaks even at 7.8 years.

Two features of the curve are worth noting. The discounts get smaller as a share of the added risk: each extra dollar of deductible buys a smaller discount than the last. And the savings in dollars are modest in absolute terms. In this example, the whole $900 jump from $100 to $1,000 saves $83.20 a year, or 13%. Anyone told to "raise the deductible to save big" on collision should compare against this shape. The piece raising your deductible: the break-even and the emergency fund test covers the cash-reserve side of the decision, and the deductible break-even calculator runs the break-even with your own quote figures.

The deductible curve: comprehensive

Comprehensive coverage in the same manual is priced as a percentage of the full coverage comprehensive premium:

Comprehensive deductible Charge as a percent of the full coverage premium
$50 97%
$100 95%
$250 88%
$500 77%
$1,000 65%

(The percentages above are the revised values; the old values were 96%, 93%, 84%, 70% and 58%.) The manual's labeling is "full coverage comprehensive premium," which I read as the premium before any deductible discount. I could not confirm that reading from a separate definition, so treat the base as the manual's own.

Take a hypothetical $200 comprehensive premium at that base. A $250 deductible costs $176, a $500 deductible $154 and a $1,000 deductible $130. The step from $500 to $1,000 saves $24 a year, and it adds $500 to a claim, which is a 20.8-year break-even ($500 divided by $24). The step from $250 to $500 saves $22 for $250 of exposure, 11.4 years. Comprehensive curves are steeper in percentage terms than collision (a 35% reduction at $1,000 against 13% for collision), but the premium base is smaller, so the dollars saved are small.

That helps explain a common experience: a high comprehensive deductible makes sense on a car in a low-theft, low-hail area, and less sense where glass breakage, hail or theft are real. For the high-risk version of the question, see choosing a comprehensive deductible on a high-theft or hail-prone car.

What the NAIC averages add

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners publishes nationwide averages by coverage. Its 2022/2023 Auto Insurance Database Report shows that the 2023 countrywide average premium was $736.65 for liability, $463.71 for collision and $238.24 for comprehensive, with a combined average of $1,438.60 for a vehicle that carries all three (the report's figures; the NAIC cautions that averages reflect what consumers choose to buy as well as price). Between 2019 and 2023 the report shows the average comprehensive premium rising 38.21%, collision 21.42% and liability 12.74%.

Those averages put the deductible examples in context. If a typical collision premium is about $464 and a $1,000 deductible trims it by roughly 13% on North Carolina's relativities, the saving is on the order of $60 a year, not hundreds. For liability, the average of $736.65 is the amount the ILF curve scales. When you look at your own bill, the liability line is usually where limit changes show up, so a quote that lets you toggle limits shows the curve fastest.

How vehicle age changes the picture

The percentage relativities in North Carolina's manual are printed as a single table, so the same percentage applies to a new car and an old one within the manual. What changes is the dollar base. A hypothetical 12-year-old car might have a collision premium of $180 instead of $640. A $1,000 deductible at 87% would save $23.40 a year, so adding $900 of exposure would take about 38 years to pay back. That is a hypothetical result from the same percentages, not a filed price.

It is also a reason to price collision on an older car at several deductibles and compare the dollar savings, because many insurers file their own relativities and some vary them by vehicle value or age. For an older car, the question is often whether to carry collision at all rather than how high to set the deductible. The coverage-versus-value comparison belongs in how to choose a deductible: $500 vs $1,000 and beyond, and the where to spend premium dollars: limits first, deductibles second article argues for the order in which to spend a fixed budget.

How to request quote variants

Comparing prices only works if every insurer prices the same options. The California Department of Insurance's auto insurance guide tells shoppers to compare costs and coverage carefully, and the Nevada Division of Insurance's consumer guide to auto insurance rates (2024 edition) shows what a consistent comparison looks like: it prices the same driver profiles at two liability options (25/50/20 and 100/300/50) with a $250 comprehensive and $500 collision deductible. You can copy that design.

Ask each company or agent for the same set of variants:

Variant Liability Collision deductible Comprehensive deductible What it tells you
A (baseline) Your current limits Your current Your current The reference price
B Next limit up (for example 100/300/100) Current Current The marginal price of liability
C Two steps up (for example 250/500/100) Current Current Whether high limits are cheap per dollar
D Baseline Double the current Current The collision deductible saving
E Baseline Current Double the current The comprehensive saving
F Baseline Highest the insurer offers Highest offered The ceiling of deductible savings
G Baseline No collision (older cars only) Current What collision costs as a share of the bill

Record the total and each coverage line. The car insurance quote comparison worksheet has room for that. Then calculate the marginal price of each change: the difference between a variant and the baseline, not the total. A $90 increase to buy 100/300 is a different decision from a $90 increase for a deductible cut.

Mistakes that distort the comparison

  • Comparing totals when the limits differ. A cheap quote at 25/50/25 is not cheaper than a 100/300/100 quote from another company.
  • Treating a deductible discount as free. Each step transfers risk to you. Set it against a cash reserve you could actually use.
  • Ignoring the difference between per-person and per-accident limits. In the table above 100/100 has a lower factor than 100/300 even though both have a $100,000 per-person limit.
  • Assuming one example generalizes. Insurers file different base rates and different factors, and territory and class can change the dollars even when the percentages are the same.
  • Not asking what is rated per vehicle. A multi-car policy may have different deductibles per car.

Common questions

Does doubling my liability limits double the premium?

No. In North Carolina's filed table, going from 30/60 to 250/500 multiplies bodily injury premium by 1.83, even though limits rise more than eightfold per accident. The exact factor varies by state and insurer.

Is a $1,000 deductible always worth it?

Not always. On North Carolina's collision relativities it saves about 13% against a $100 deductible, which may be only tens of dollars a year on an older car. It helps when you have cash set aside and the premium base is large.

Which coverage gives the most protection per premium dollar?

On the filed factors, higher property damage and bodily injury limits give the most added protection for the least added premium. Small medical payments limits climb steeply, with a $5,000 limit at 4.62 times the $500 base.

Can I trust one example to predict my price?

No. Use it to understand the shape and then ask for your own variants, since territory, class, vehicle and company all change the base.

Key takeaways

  • Liability price per dollar of limit falls as limits rise: in North Carolina's filing, 100/300 costs 1.50 times 30/60 and 250/500 costs 1.83 times.
  • Deductible discounts flatten out: on the October 2025 manual, a $1,000 collision deductible is priced at 87% of a $100 deductible.
  • Compute break-even by dividing the added deductible by the annual saving, and compare it with your cash reserve.
  • Ask every insurer for the same set of limit and deductible variants and compare the marginal price of each change.
  • These are one state's filed factors from November 2026; confirm yours with your state regulator or the company.

Sources

Terms used in this guide

Related states

Related guides

Related tools

Latest on this topic