Blog
Online quote defaults: pre-selected extras and recommended coverage
Why two online quotes for the same car can differ by their pre-filled coverages, and how to see, strip or keep each default so the prices compare fairly.
An online quote form often arrives with some boxes already ticked: a liability limit, a deductible and perhaps a few extras. Those defaults are someone's starting guess, not a legal requirement and not a verdict on what you need. A quote built on defaults can differ from the next one by coverage as much as by company, so the price on the screen is only useful once you know what it buys.
This article separates the three things a form can call a default, shows where to find what is selected, explains how to remove extras without dropping protection you need, and gives a method for comparing quotes that were built differently. No insurer's live quote engine is reproduced here, because what a form pre-selects changes by state, vehicle, date and sales channel. The article relies on the guidance regulators and insurers publish, dated November 2026, and tells you how to check the form in front of you.
Three different things called "defaults"
When a form shows a coverage you did not choose, it falls into one of three groups.
- Required. Your state says every policy must include it. Liability limits at the state minimum are the usual example, and some states also require personal injury protection or uninsured motorist coverage. You cannot remove these, though in some states you can reject one in writing.
- Pre-filled by the insurer. The company's system picks a starting limit, deductible or optional coverage and shows it as selected. You can usually change it.
- Recommended by a tool. A calculator or an agent suggests coverage from your answers about assets, loans and use. It is advice, and the tool may say so.
The Illinois Department of Insurance describes the first group in its auto shopping guide. It lists the liability limits Illinois law requires, with bodily injury at a minimum of $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident and property damage at a minimum of $20,000 per accident, and it states that the state minimums may not be enough to protect you from lawsuits, so buyers should consider higher limits (Illinois Department of Insurance: Auto Insurance Shopping Guide, checked November 2026). Required and recommended are different words for a reason: the law sets a floor, and nothing about a floor says it fits you. state minimum vs full coverage: which do you need? explains the gap in detail.
Where the defaults tend to sit
A form can pre-fill any coverage, but the places where defaults matter most are limits, deductibles and extras.
Limits
Liability limits, shown as three numbers such as 25/50/25, set the most the insurer will pay for injuries and property damage you cause (liability limits). If the form starts at the state minimum, the quote is as cheap as it can be and as thin as it can be. If it starts higher, the quote may look expensive next to a minimum-limit quote even though it protects more. Uninsured motorist limits are a separate line with their own limit, so check that one too.
Deductibles
The deductible is what you pay on a collision or comprehensive claim before the insurer pays (deductible). Progressive's coverage calculator makes the trade-off explicit: its question on deductibles says a higher deductible can bring a lower rate in exchange for more out of pocket if you have a claim, and that a lower deductible raises the premium (Progressive: Car Insurance Coverages, checked November 2026). A form that pre-selects $500 and one that pre-selects $1,000 are not quoting the same product, and the cheaper price is partly the higher deductible.
Extras
Extras are the optional coverages that add small amounts to the price: rental reimbursement, roadside assistance, medical payments and, in some quotes, gap coverage or other add-ons. Progressive's calculator asks whether you have easy access to another car if yours is totaled, and describes rental reimbursement as optional coverage that pays for a rental while your car is being repaired after damage from a covered accident. Its question on whether you owe more on your loan or lease than the car is worth, which it ties to gap insurance, works the same way: each extra is attached to a circumstance, and the extra only has value if the circumstance is yours (Progressive: Car Insurance Coverages, checked November 2026). See rental reimbursement coverage, roadside assistance coverage vs auto club membership, gap insurance explained and Medical payments coverage (MedPay) explained for how each works.
What "recommended" can and cannot mean
Progressive's calculator shows how a recommendation is built. It asks about your state, whether you own a home or hold assets above $50,000, whether you own or finance the car, what the car is worth, whether you owe more than it is worth, whether you could pay for repairs or a replacement yourself, your deductible preference, your access to another car and your use of rideshare. Each question carries a "Why we ask" note. For example, the page says lenders often require higher liability limits and comprehensive and collision coverage on leased or financed vehicles, that assets, including home equity, should be counted when choosing liability limits, and that physical damage coverages are recommended if you depend on your car for transportation and cannot afford to replace it (Progressive: Car Insurance Coverages, checked November 2026).
The same page also limits what its tool does. It says the calculator is informational, a starting point for choosing coverages, limits and deductibles. It adds that the tool does not generate a quote, is not intended to recommend specific coverages, and that you are responsible for selecting the coverages, limits and deductibles that best protect you and your property. It also says the tool does not present every coverage option or limit available in each state, and suggests excess or umbrella insurance if you want higher liability limits than the insurer offers.
That is a useful template for reading any recommendation. A "recommended" setting is the result of a short questionnaire, not an underwriting review of your finances. It tends to be reasonable as a starting point, and it can be wrong for you in either direction: too little protection when your assets are larger than the form assumes, or too much when you could cover a repair yourself. The shape of a recommendation depends on the questions asked, so answer them truthfully and then read the result critically.
A worked example with numbers we define
These figures are hypothetical, chosen to show how defaults distort a comparison. They are not any insurer's prices.
A driver with a financed 2020 sedan collects two six-month quotes from two websites on the same afternoon.
| Item | Quote A (pre-filled) | Quote B (pre-filled) |
|---|---|---|
| Liability limits | 50/100/50 | 25/50/25 |
| Uninsured motorist | Matches liability | State minimum |
| Collision deductible | $500 | $1,000 |
| Comprehensive deductible | $500 | $1,000 |
| Rental reimbursement | Included | Not selected |
| Roadside assistance | Included | Not selected |
| Medical payments | $1,000 | Not selected |
| Six-month price | $780 | $610 |
Quote B looks $170 cheaper, about 22% less. But the two quotes differ on seven lines. Suppose the driver then asks Company B to re-run its quote at 50/100/50, matching uninsured motorist limits, $500 deductibles and the three extras, and the new price is $770. The $170 gap has become $10. In this made-up case, almost all of the apparent saving came from the defaults.
The reverse is just as possible. Had Quote A's extras been unneeded, such as roadside assistance that a credit card or auto club membership already provides, removing them might have made Company A the lower price. The lesson is the method: change one line at a time on both forms until every row matches, then compare the totals. The car insurance quote comparison worksheet has a layout for it.
How to see what is selected
- Do not stop at the price. Before you click to buy, look for a coverage summary, "review your quote" or "coverage details" screen. Take a screenshot or print it.
- Read every line, not just the headline. The headline usually shows the total. The lines show each coverage, its limit or deductible and its own price.
- Look for a toggle or a "customize" link. Many forms show a package and hide the individual coverages behind it.
- Compare the summary to the declarations page of your current policy. The declarations page lists your coverages, limits and deductibles, and the how to read your car insurance declarations page guide shows how to read one.
- Ask for the coverage list in writing if a phone agent quotes you. Idaho's Department of Insurance advises asking to have the information emailed for your records when a company representative calls with a rate (Idaho Department of Insurance: online shopping tips, September 2011, checked November 2026).
- Check what the price assumes. Idaho's guidance notes that not all websites give an immediate quote and that a representative may call to confirm your information first. why your final price differs from the online quote covers why a final price can differ.
Removing extras without removing protection
Removing a pre-selected extra is a reasonable way to lower a quote, but the careful way is to ask what each one does and whether another source covers it. Use this as a starting checklist, and confirm each point against your own policy and loan documents.
| Default or extra | Check before removing |
|---|---|
| Collision and comprehensive | A lender or lessor usually requires them. Progressive's calculator says lenders often require them on financed and leased cars. Removing them can breach the loan contract. |
| Higher liability limits | Compare against your assets and income. The Illinois guide says state minimums may not be enough to protect you from lawsuits. |
| Uninsured/underinsured motorist | It is required or must be offered in many states. Idaho says insurers must offer UM/UIM bodily injury coverage in that state. |
| Rental reimbursement | Do you have a second car or an easy alternative for the days a repair takes? |
| Roadside assistance | Do a credit card, auto club or vehicle manufacturer program already provide it? |
| Medical payments | Does your health insurance cover crash injuries, and what are its deductibles? See MedPay or health insurance: who pays first after a crash. |
| Gap | Do you owe more than the car is worth? If not, gap pays nothing extra. |
| Rideshare endorsement | Needed if you drive for a platform. Not needed otherwise. |
Rejection of a protection a state treats as required usually has a formal step. Florida's statute, for example, requires uninsured motorist coverage on a policy with bodily injury liability coverage unless a named insured makes a written rejection on behalf of all insureds (Florida Statutes 627.727, 2025 edition, checked November 2026). In a state like that, an unchecked box on a web form is not the same as a signed rejection, and a missing coverage is easier to fix before a claim than after one. Rules differ by state, so check yours with state car insurance requirements lookup or your state insurance department.
Defaults that hide in the checkout, not just the quote
Defaults are not limited to coverages. Look for these on any form:
- A pre-selected billing plan. The default may be monthly installments with a fee rather than a pay-in-full price. See paying in full vs monthly: installment fees and discounts.
- A pre-selected policy term. Six months and twelve months are priced differently. Progressive's page notes, for instance, that its 5% average bundle saving is based on a six-month term (Progressive: Car Insurance, checked November 2026).
- Pre-checked discounts. A discount that was applied because you answered a question a certain way can be removed when the answer changes, and the price moves with it. how to audit your policy for discounts you are not getting covers this from the other side.
- Add-on products. Related products, such as renters or home quotes, may appear beside the auto quote. They are separate and optional.
Comparing quotes that were built differently
Nationwide's own guidance on its auto insurance page puts the principle in one place: when comparing quotes, make sure you are getting the same value, because a policy with a lower premium may have a higher deductible or less coverage. Its advice is to review the details of each policy to understand what it does and does not include, and to compare only once you have two policies with the same or very similar coverages (Nationwide: auto insurance, checked November 2026). Regulators say the same. The Illinois guide says to ask for the same coverages and limits when comparing written quotes, and the Idaho guidance lists liability limits, uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage, deductibles and optional coverages as the items that should be the same for every quote. The California Department of Insurance guide says auto policies can vary a lot, and that you should always get several quotes, since a quote is an estimate of your premium cost (California Department of Insurance: Auto Insurance Guide, checked November 2026).
Here is a method that works whichever site you start with.
- Write your baseline: the limits, deductibles and extras on your current declarations page, or the ones you have decided you want.
- On each form, set every coverage to your baseline before looking at the price. If a form cannot match a line, note the difference.
- If a quote was already built from defaults, call or use chat and ask for a revised estimate at your baseline. Idaho's guidance says to do exactly this when quotes do not have matching coverages or limits.
- Record the final price, the term and the payment plan for each quote.
- Compare totals only after every row matches. Treat any remaining difference as a real price difference.
- If a quote is far below the others, find out which line it dropped before getting excited.
Comparison websites add another layer. how car insurance comparison sites and lead generators work explains how those sites pass your information on, and Idaho's guidance warns that some websites send your information to an agent who then quotes and writes the policy. Matching coverages matters at least as much there.
What the advertising rules say, and what we could not find
State insurance laws generally prohibit misleading statements about the terms or benefits of a policy. Florida's definition of unfair or deceptive acts, for example, covers knowingly making a statement, sales presentation, omission or comparison that misrepresents the benefits, advantages, conditions or terms of an insurance policy (Florida Statutes 626.9541, 2025 edition, checked November 2026). A quote screen that shows a lower price for materially less coverage, without making that clear, is the kind of situation these laws are meant to reach.
We did not find a state rule that says a quote form may not pre-select a coverage, or that prescribes how defaults must be displayed. If you believe a form or an agent misrepresented what a quote included, the state insurance department takes complaints, and how to file a complaint against a car insurance company explains the steps. A licensed attorney can advise on a specific dispute.
Common questions
Is the pre-selected coverage the best choice for me?
Not necessarily. It is the form's starting point. A recommendation reflects your answers to a short questionnaire, and the Progressive page says its own tool is informational and that you are responsible for choosing coverages, limits and deductibles.
Why did the same company give two different prices?
Often the coverage differed, or the form made different assumptions about term and billing. Make the coverage lines identical, then compare. If the price still differs, ask the company which rating inputs changed.
Can I add or remove coverage after I buy?
Policies generally allow changes by contacting the insurer, and the premium is adjusted to match. Some changes, like removing collision on a financed car, may conflict with your loan terms. Check your policy and loan documents, and ask the insurer how it handles mid-term changes.
Does removing an extra always lower the price?
It usually lowers it, but the amount is often small compared with changes to limits or deductibles. Weigh the saving against how likely you are to need the coverage and what else covers the same loss.
Key takeaways
- A pre-selected coverage is the form's starting point. Required coverage, pre-filled coverage and recommended coverage are three different things.
- Compare quotes line by line. Regulators in Illinois, Idaho and California, and Nationwide on its own site, all say to match coverages, limits and deductibles first.
- Remove an extra only after asking what it covers and what else already covers it. Lenders, state law and your own savings decide which coverages are non-negotiable.
- If quotes arrive built differently, ask for a revised estimate at your baseline instead of guessing which is cheaper.
Sources
- Illinois Department of Insurance: Auto Insurance Shopping Guide, required Illinois liability limits, the advice to ask for the same coverages and limits, checked November 2026
- Idaho Department of Insurance: online shopping tips, coverage options to match across quotes, UM/UIM must be offered, ask for revised estimates, September 2011, checked November 2026
- California Department of Insurance: Auto Insurance Guide, policies vary, get several quotes, a quote is an estimate, checked November 2026
- Progressive: Car Insurance Coverages, the coverage calculator's questions, "why we ask" notes and its disclaimer, checked November 2026
- Progressive: Car Insurance, footnote on six-month-term averages, checked November 2026
- Nationwide: auto insurance, the company's guidance on comparing quotes for the same value, checked November 2026
- Florida Senate: Florida Statutes 627.727, written rejection of uninsured motorist coverage, checked November 2026
- Florida Senate: Florida Statutes 626.9541, unfair or deceptive acts including misleading comparisons, checked November 2026