Blog
Depreciation curves by model: how long you stay underwater
How fast cars lose value by body style and powertrain, why a long loan keeps you underwater, and when gap coverage stops mattering, with a worked example.
You stay underwater on a car loan until the loan balance falls below what the car would sell for, and the answer depends on three numbers: how much you borrowed, how long the loan runs, and how fast that particular model loses value. With little or nothing down and a six-year loan, many buyers are underwater for the first two to four years. With a large down payment, a short loan or a model that holds its value, you may never be. The point of tracking this is practical: gap coverage is worth paying for only while you are underwater, and your insurer will pay a total loss only up to the car's actual cash value, never up to the loan balance.
What "underwater" means and why insurance cares
A loan is underwater, also called negative equity, when you owe more than the vehicle is worth. depreciation is the reason: a new car's market value drops the moment it is titled, while the loan balance falls slowly, because early payments are mostly interest. Standard collision and comprehensive coverage pay actual cash value, the market value just before the loss, less your deductible. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau describes the shortfall plainly in its page on guaranteed asset protection (GAP): standard auto insurance only pays up to the value of your vehicle, and GAP is an optional product meant to cover the difference between what you owe and what the insurer pays if the car is stolen or totaled (checked November 2026).
That means the depreciation curve decides whether a total loss in month 18 costs you only the deductible or costs you thousands. It also decides whether the extra premium for loan or lease payoff coverage is a bargain or a waste. See gap insurance explained for the product itself and what happens if your car is totaled and you still owe money for what happens to the check.
How fast cars actually lose value: the published numbers
No single curve fits every car, but published studies give a usable range. The most recent one I could open is iSeeCars' 2026 study of more than 950,000 five-year-old used cars sold from March 2025 to February 2026. iSeeCars is a used-car search site, so this is private-sector analysis rather than a government statistic, and it measures the gap between original MSRP and the used sale price (iSeeCars: cars that hold their value study, checked November 2026). Its findings:
- Average five-year depreciation across all vehicles was 41.8%, an improvement of 3.8 percentage points from 2025.
- Trucks averaged 34.2% and hybrids 35.4%, the best segments.
- Electric vehicles averaged 57.2%, more than 15 percentage points worse than the overall average.
- The Porsche 718 Cayman lost the least (9.6%); the Nissan Leaf lost the most in percentage terms (63.1%, or $17,743), while the Land Rover Range Rover lost 61.7%, which was $69,856.
- Toyota held 10 of the 25 spots for best value retention; 18 luxury models and eight EVs appear among the 25 highest-depreciating vehicles.
Two cautions apply to every study of this kind. A five-year average hides the shape of the curve, and the shape matters for loans: the early years matter most for loans, because that is when the balance is highest. And the averages move with the used market, as the next section shows.
Reading the shape by vehicle type
Use the study as a ranking, not a forecast. If you are shopping, the pattern in the published data is:
| Vehicle type | 5-year average loss (iSeeCars, 2026) | What it means for a loan |
|---|---|---|
| Trucks | 34.2% | Shortest time underwater, other things equal |
| Hybrids | 35.4% | Similar to trucks |
| All vehicles | 41.8% | Baseline for planning |
| Electric vehicles | 57.2% | Longest time underwater; highest gap risk |
A mid-priced model is not guaranteed to match its segment. Individual models inside a segment vary widely, which is why the same study lists a Toyota Tacoma near the top and a luxury SUV near the bottom. Compare the specific model you are considering, and for used EVs read Buying a used EV: battery health and what insurance will pay.
Why the used-car market makes the curve move
Depreciation is not a fixed schedule. It follows used-car prices, and those have swung. The Bureau of Labor Statistics tracks "used cars and trucks" in the consumer price index (1982-84 = 100, not seasonally adjusted). The index stood at 137.125 in December 2019, 203.867 in September 2022 and 184.395 in September 2026 (BLS: CPI used cars and trucks series, checked November 2026). From September 2022 to September 2026 it fell about 9.5%, and it remains about 34.5% above its December 2019 level.
What that does to a borrower depends on when they bought. Someone who financed a car at the 2022 peak, borrowing against inflated used values, faced prices that then softened, so their cars lost value faster than a normal curve would suggest. Someone who bought in 2019 saw the opposite. The practical lesson: your loan was priced against the car's value on purchase day, and the market afterward is outside your control. iSeeCars notes that in 2026 every major segment retained more value than in 2025, which shows the swing can run both ways.
Down payment, loan term and the shape of the gap
Two decisions you control determine how long you stay underwater: how much you put down and how long you borrow. The numbers below are a hypothetical, not a market statistic. Assume a $38,000 total financed price (including tax and fees) at 7.0% APR, and assume a car that loses value by 20% in year one, then a further 12%, 10%, 8%, 8% and 7% in each following year. That path ends year five at about 46% below the starting price, a little worse than the iSeeCars all-vehicle average, which is useful for stress-testing.
| End of year | Car value | Balance, 72 months, $0 down | Equity (value minus balance) | Balance, 72 months, 20% down | Equity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $30,400 | $32,718 | -$2,318 | $26,175 | +$4,225 |
| 2 | $26,752 | $27,055 | -$303 | $21,644 | +$5,108 |
| 3 | $24,077 | $20,982 | +$3,095 | $16,786 | +$7,291 |
| 4 | $22,151 | $14,470 | +$7,681 | $11,576 | +$10,575 |
With no down payment the monthly payment is about $648 and the borrower is underwater at the end of year one by roughly $2,300, nearly even at the end of year two, and ahead by year three. With 20% down ($7,600), the payment is about $518 and the borrower is never underwater at any year-end in this path. A 48-month loan with no down payment ($910 a month) would be underwater for a shorter period but at a higher monthly cost. Real curves are lumpier; the model also ignores any dealer add-ons rolled into the loan, which push the starting balance up.
Negative equity carried over from a previous car works the opposite way. According to Edmunds' second-quarter 2026 data, as reported by Carscoops (Edmunds' own release was blocked to automated fetches, so this is a secondhand account, checked November 2026), 29.6% of trade-ins toward new-vehicle purchases carried negative equity, averaging $6,884, a record for a second quarter. Buyers who rolled it into a new loan paid an average of $944 a month, $167 more than the industry-wide average, and were expected to pay an average of $16,270 in interest. rolling negative equity into a new car loan: what is not covered covers why a total loss on such a car is not fully covered.
Total-loss value is not the price you paid or the price on the lot
Gap exists because the insurer pays market value, not your balance. Under the NAIC's model claims regulation, a cash settlement for a first-party total loss is based on the actual cost to purchase a comparable automobile, including applicable taxes, license fees and other fees incident to transferring ownership; any deduction for condition must be "measurable, discernible, itemized and specified as to dollar amount" (NAIC Model Regulation 902, 1997 text, checked November 2026). States adopt their own versions, so the exact rules vary; see how insurers calculate actual cash value and state car insurance requirements lookup.
Three consequences for a borrower follow:
- Your payout tracks comparable cars for sale in your area, so a hot or cold used market moves it directly.
- Dealer-installed accessories and extras rarely appear in a valuation at what you paid, and what you rolled into the loan may not be recoverable.
- Many standard policies pay nothing for the gap between the payout and the payoff. Some insurers sell loan/lease payoff coverage as an endorsement; its terms differ, so read the cap and what it excludes. what gap insurance does not pay: deductibles, fees, late payments lists the common exclusions.
Note the sequence on the claim: the insurer's payment normally goes first to the lender, and you owe any remaining balance. Use the total loss payout estimator to approximate the payout before you rely on a number.
When you can drop gap coverage
You can compare your own numbers with a simple monthly routine:
- Find your payoff. Log in to the lender or request a payoff statement; use the principal balance, not the "remaining payments" total.
- Estimate market value. Pull two or three comparable listings near you (same year, trim and similar mileage) and a pricing-guide estimate. If the car has a loan from a dealer plan, note whether the gap product is dealer-sold.
- Subtract. Value minus payoff. If it is positive by more than your collision deductible, gap is no longer protecting you.
- Ask before you cancel. CFPB says that if you finance GAP and you sell, refinance or prepay the loan, you may be entitled to a refund, and that you have the right to cancel optional add-on products (CFPB, GAP page). Get the refund calculation in writing. dealer gap vs insurer gap: refunds, cancellation and refinancing explains how dealer-sold and insurer-sold products differ.
Keep gap longer if the car is an EV, a luxury model or a high-depreciation body style, if you financed more than 100% of its price, or if your loan is longer than six years. Run your own numbers through the gap insurance calculator.
Where to buy gap, and what it should cost you
The CFPB notes that the price of GAP can vary greatly, that your own auto insurer may offer a policy, that some direct lenders do too, and that you should compare prices and coverage before you buy (CFPB: what is GAP). If you finance it at the dealership, it adds to the loan and to the interest you pay. The CFPB's separate answer on optional add-ons says that generally you cannot be required to buy an extended warranty, GAP or credit insurance, and that you may walk away from pressure to buy them (CFPB: am I required to purchase GAP, checked November 2026).
To save money, ask your auto insurer for a quote on loan/lease payoff coverage before you sit down in the finance office. Compare the monthly add-on on your policy with the dealer's one-time price plus interest over the loan's term, and note who pays if you cancel early.
Ways to shorten the time underwater
- Put money down. In the example above, 20% down turned a two-year gap into none.
- Pick a shorter term or pay extra principal. Every dollar of early principal reduces the balance faster than depreciation can.
- Choose a model with a good retained-value record. The iSeeCars ranking is one input; ask a lender or insurer what they use.
- Skip add-ons you can decline. Items rolled into the loan raise the starting balance without raising the value of the car.
- Do not roll old negative equity forward unless you have run the numbers above.
- Shop your insurance at renewal. The same car can carry very different collision premiums, which affects the combined cost of owning it; how to compare car insurance quotes apples to apples walks through it.
Common questions
Does a down payment guarantee I will not be underwater?
No. A large down payment makes it much less likely, as the worked example shows, but fees, taxes and add-ons financed into the loan raise the balance, and a steep early drop in value or a falling used market can still produce a gap.
Is a long loan always bad?
Not by itself, but a longer term keeps the balance high relative to value. A 72-month loan with no money down was underwater at the end of year one in the example above; the same car on a 48-month loan reached positive equity sooner, with a much larger monthly payment.
Does gap cover my deductible?
That depends on the product. Many gap products do not pay the collision or comprehensive deductible, and some do. Ask for the written terms. what gap insurance does not pay: deductibles, fees, late payments covers it.
Can I rely on one study's depreciation number?
No. Studies differ in method and sample. iSeeCars' 41.8% is a five-year average of one set of sales; your model and local market may differ. Use it to rank options and then check live listings.
Key takeaways
- You are underwater until value exceeds payoff; the insurer pays value, not payoff.
- iSeeCars' 2026 study found EVs lost 57.2% over five years against 41.8% overall and 34.2% for trucks, so powertrain and body style change how long gap matters.
- Down payment and loan term are the two levers you control; in the hypothetical example, 20% down removed the gap entirely.
- Re-check value against payoff once or twice a year and cancel gap, with a refund request, when you are comfortably ahead.
- Quote gap from your own insurer before agreeing to the dealer's price.
Sources
- iSeeCars: The Top 25 Cars That Hold Their Value Best, and the 25 Worst, five-year depreciation by segment and model, 2026 edition, checked November 2026
- BLS: Used cars and trucks, U.S. city average (CUUR0000SETA02), used-car CPI values for 2019, 2022 and 2026, checked November 2026
- Carscoops: US negative equity trade-ins (reporting Edmunds Q2 2026 data), share and size of negative equity, payments and interest, checked November 2026
- CFPB: What is Guaranteed Asset Protection (GAP) insurance?, what GAP covers, price variation, refund and cancellation rights, checked November 2026
- CFPB: Am I required to purchase an extended warranty, GAP insurance or credit insurance?, add-ons are generally optional, checked November 2026
- NAIC: Unfair Property/Casualty Claims Settlement Practices Model Regulation (MO-902), total-loss cash settlement standard, checked November 2026