Blog

Adverse action notices and your credit data in car insurance

A notice says credit raised your car insurance price. What federal law requires it to say, the 60-day free report, how to dispute errors and ask for a re-rate.

A letter or email saying that information in your credit report affected your car insurance is called an adverse action notice, and it is required by the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA). It is your cue to do three things within 60 days: ask the credit bureau named in the notice for a free copy of the file, check it for errors, and, if you find one, dispute it and ask the insurer to re-rate your policy.

This article walks through what the law requires the notice to contain, what it does not tell you, how the clock works, and a checklist for disputing a mistake. Rules about credit in rating are partly state law, so the second half explains how to check yours.

What triggers a notice

The FCRA's section 1681m(a) says that when a person takes an adverse action against a consumer based in whole or in part on information in a consumer report, the person must give notice. For insurance, "adverse action" is defined as a denial or cancellation of, an increase in any charge for, or a reduction or other adverse change in the terms of coverage of insurance, existing or applied for. The Supreme Court quoted that definition in Safeco Insurance Co. of America v. Burr (2007), a case about GEICO and Safeco.

The Court held that a higher initial rate for a new policy can be an adverse action, not only a renewal increase. The test is a comparison: the baseline is the rate you would have received had the company not taken your credit score into account (a neutral score). If credit put you in a more expensive tier or company than a neutral score would have, a notice is owed. Once you have been told that credit raised your price, the Court said you need not be told again at each renewal if the rate has not changed, because after the first dealing the baseline becomes the previous rate.

That is why some drivers get a notice at the quote stage and none at renewal, and why others get nothing even though credit affected their price. If your price was the same with or without credit, no notice is required. Compare with adverse action notices: what an insurer must tell you about a rate, which covers notices triggered by driving records as well.

What the notice must contain

Under 1681m(a), the notice must provide:

  • oral, written or electronic notice of the adverse action;
  • the name, address and telephone number of the consumer reporting agency that furnished the report, including a toll-free number if it is a nationwide agency;
  • a statement that the agency did not make the decision and cannot give the specific reasons for it;
  • notice of your right to obtain a free copy of the report from that agency within 60 days; and
  • notice of your right to dispute the accuracy or completeness of anything in the report with that agency.

The same section also requires disclosure of a numerical credit score and certain related information. The score disclosure points to the definition of "credit score" in section 1681g(f), which describes a score used to predict credit behavior such as default. An insurer's insurance score is built differently (see credit-based insurance scores and car insurance), and we did not find an opened source stating how regulators or courts apply that definition to insurance scores. So do not assume the notice lists your score. When 1681g(f) applies, the "key factors" are the elements that adversely affected the score, listed in order of importance, and their number may not exceed four.

If your notice does not explain what drove the decision, ask the insurer for the factors in writing. The agency itself cannot tell you why the insurer made its decision, so the insurer is the one to ask.

The three clocks that start when the notice arrives

  1. 60 days to request the file free. Under 1681j(b), a consumer reporting agency must make its disclosures without charge if you ask within 60 days after receiving the notice. Count from the day you received it, but do not wait.
  2. 30 days to investigate a dispute. Under 1681i(a), once you notify the agency of a dispute, it must conduct a reasonable reinvestigation free of charge within 30 days. The period can extend by up to 15 days if you send relevant information during the 30 days, but not if the item is found inaccurate or cannot be verified. If the agency decides the dispute is frivolous, it must tell you within five business days.
  3. Your insurer's timing. We found no federal deadline for an insurer to re-rate after a fix in the sections we opened. Some states set one. Oregon, for example, requires a re-rate within 30 days of a request (below).

Whether credit data came from one of the three nationwide bureaus or from a smaller agency, the notice names which one. Request that agency's file by the method on the notice.

Get your file and read it

A free annual disclosure is separate: section 1681j(a) requires nationwide agencies to give you a copy once in any 12-month period on request, through the centralized source, AnnualCreditReport.com. The 60-day request after a notice is an additional free copy, so you can use both. Read the file for:

  • accounts that are not yours, or that show a wrong status;
  • an old collection, lien or judgment that is past the reporting limit. Under 1681c, civil suits, civil judgments, paid tax liens and accounts placed for collection generally may not be reported after seven years, and bankruptcies after 10 years, with exceptions;
  • a mixed file, where another person's data is merged with yours;
  • identity theft.

Inquiries are a separate question: Oregon and Maryland both restrict how insurers may use them, as discussed below, and do car insurance quotes hurt your credit score? explains the rest.

A worked example

This is a hypothetical with numbers we define. Dana renews with a premium of $1,500 per year. On renewal, a notice says credit information was used. Dana requests her file on day 10, receives it on day 20, and finds a $900 collection account that belongs to another Dana with a similar name. On day 22 she sends a written dispute to the bureau with a copy of her ID and a copy of the file with the entry circled. On day 24 she also writes to the collection agency that reported it, since the FTC and CFPB advise disputing with both the bureau and the business that supplied the data.

If the bureau finds the item inaccurate or unverifiable, it must delete or correct it, send her a written result, and send a free updated report if anything changed. Dana then sends her insurer the revised report and asks for a re-rate at her original renewal date. If the insurer recalculates to $1,380, her refund is $120 (hypothetical), and she keeps the proof in a folder. She has used about 30 of the 60 free-request days and none of her patience.

Disputing an error

The CFPB's dispute guide (last reviewed September 2026) and the FTC's guidance agree on the method. Dispute with the consumer reporting company and with the business that supplied the information, in writing, with copies (not originals) of supporting documents, preferably sent by certified mail with return receipt. The CFPB says a dispute letter should include your contact information, each error and the account number, a clear explanation, a request that the item be removed or corrected, and a copy of the report page with the entries circled.

After the dispute:

  • The bureau forwards your evidence to the furnisher, and the furnisher must investigate. Under 1681s-2(b), after receiving notice from the bureau the furnisher must investigate, review what the bureau sent, report results, and, if the information is wrong, report to the other nationwide agencies and modify, delete or permanently block it.
  • If the dispute is not resolved, you may add a brief statement of the dispute to your file under 1681i(b), and the agency may limit it to 100 words if it helps you write a clear summary.
  • The bureau must send you the results in writing and a free updated report if the file changed (FTC).

Be careful with credit repair companies. The FTC notes that anything they can legally do you can do yourself.

Asking the insurer to re-rate

Once the file is fixed, send the insurer the new report or letter of correction, ask in writing that it re-rate your policy using the corrected information from the date the wrong data raised the price, and ask for the effective date and any refund in writing. If the insurer says no, ask which factor controls and whether the premium was refiled under approved rating rules. See credit-based insurance scores: asking for a re-rate and extraordinary life events: asking insurers to set aside credit damage for situations where credit damage is real but caused by illness, job loss or disaster.

State rules that go beyond the FCRA

The FCRA sets the floor; states regulate how credit may be used. According to the Oregon statute, ORS 746.661, an insurer may not cancel or nonrenew a personal policy that has been in effect more than 60 days based on credit history or insurance score, and if it uses credit in rating, the consumer may request a re-rate no more than once a year, which the insurer must complete within 30 days. If a disputed credit item raised the price and the consumer resolves the dispute under the FCRA and tells the insurer in writing, Oregon requires the policy to be re-rated retroactive to the start of the current term. Oregon also bars using consumer-initiated inquiries and insurance-related inquiries, and limits using the absence of a credit history as a negative.

In Maryland, Insurance Article 27-501 allows credit history to be used to rate new private passenger auto policies, bars factors more than five years old and the number of credit inquiries, requires the insurer to tell the applicant at the time of application that credit is used, and requires a review of an insured who was adversely affected by credit every two years or on request. Other states ban or limit credit use outright; see rating factors some states have banned: gender, credit, occupation for the list. Check your state with state car insurance requirements lookup and its department of insurance.

How common is the effect? An Arkansas insurance department analysis summarized by the Triple-I of about 3.4 million personal lines policies in 2016 found credit information lowered the final premium in 57.4% of auto policies and raised it in 23.4%. The figures come from one state and one year, but they show that credit can cut as well as add.

If the notice is wrong or never came

Federal law gives a private right of action for violations. Under 1681n, a willful violation can bring actual damages or statutory damages of $100 to $1,000, plus other relief; the Safeco opinion notes negligent violations support actual damages. That is a matter for a licensed attorney. A faster step is a complaint to your state department of insurance, which regulates how insurers use credit, and one to the CFPB if the bureau or furnisher fails to fix the file. We do not give legal advice, and each state is different.

Dispute checklist

  1. Save the notice and the envelope or email, with the date you received it.
  2. Within 60 days, request your file from the agency named in the notice.
  3. Read every entry against your own records.
  4. Write one dispute letter per bureau, listing each error with proof.
  5. Write to the furnisher too, and send by certified mail.
  6. Calendar day 30 after the bureau receives your letter.
  7. When the result arrives, send the corrected file to your insurer and request a written re-rate.
  8. Re-shop with insurers if the re-rate is small. Use renewal rate increase checker and car insurance quote comparison worksheet.

Common questions

Does the notice mean my credit is bad?

No. It means credit information played a part in the price or tier. Your price may still be lower than with neutral credit, in which case no notice is required.

Can I get a free report even if I already used my annual one?

Yes. The 60-day free disclosure after an adverse action is separate from the annual one, under 1681j(b).

Can the credit bureau tell me why my price went up?

No. The notice must say the bureau did not make the decision and cannot give the reasons; ask the insurer.

Key takeaways

  • An adverse action notice is required when credit information contributed to an increase, denial or worse terms, including a higher first-time rate (Safeco v. Burr).
  • You have 60 days to request a free copy of the file, and the bureau has 30 days to reinvestigate a dispute.
  • Dispute with both the bureau and the furnisher, in writing, with copies.
  • Ask the insurer in writing to re-rate after a correction; some states, such as Oregon and Maryland, require it.

Sources

Terms used in this guide

Related states

Related guides

Related tools

Latest on this topic