Blog

Minimum earned premium: why a cancellation refund can be small

Why cancelling a new auto policy can return less than you expect: minimum earned premium, short rate, fees, and how to estimate the refund before you buy.

A cancellation refund can be small because the insurer keeps the part of the premium it has "earned," and some policies and some states let it keep more than the days you were covered. A minimum earned premium is a rule that the insurer keeps at least a stated amount or percentage even if you cancel in the first days. A short-rate refund keeps a penalty on top of the days used. Neither is allowed everywhere, and each has to be disclosed or filed, so the first step is to find out which one your policy uses.

This article explains the terms, shows what several states' statutes say as of November 2026, walks through three ways to calculate a refund with numbers defined for the example, and lists what to ask before you buy. The overlap with cancelling car insurance mid-term: how your refund is calculated is deliberate but brief: that article compares pro rata and short rate, and this one is about the minimum amount the insurer can keep and the fees that never come back. Rules vary by state, so check your state with the state car insurance requirements lookup or your insurance department.

The vocabulary, in plain terms

The Texas Department of Insurance defines earned premium as the portion of a premium that has been used to buy coverage. If you paid for a six-month policy in advance, two months in there are two months of earned premium and four months of unearned premium (TDI: auto insurance glossary, checked November 2026). That is the pro rata idea: you pay for time covered.

Three other terms explain why a refund can come out lower.

  • Pro rata: the refund equals the unearned fraction of the term times the premium. No penalty.
  • Short rate: the insurer refunds less than the pro rata amount when you cancel, using a table or a percentage. The difference is a penalty for cancelling early.
  • Minimum earned premium: a floor. The insurer keeps at least this much (a dollar amount or a percentage of the premium, or a minimum number of days) even if the pro rata share would be lower.

On top of those, fees are often separate from premium and are treated as earned when charged, so they do not come back. See policy fees, taxes and surcharges: reading the real cost of a policy for what shows up on a bill.

The standard personal auto form shows the starting point. A copy of Insurance Services Office form PP 00 01 06 98 hosted by the Nevada Division of Insurance says the named insured may cancel by returning the policy or giving advance written notice of the date cancellation takes effect, and the insurer may cancel with at least 10 days' notice for nonpayment or during the first 60 days of a new policy (Nevada DOI: ISO personal auto policy PP 00 01 06 98, checked November 2026). That form does not set a refund formula in the passage I read; refund rules come from state law, filed endorsements and the policy's own language. That is why two policies in the same state can behave differently.

Why some policies keep a minimum

A minimum earned premium is usually justified as covering the cost of writing a policy that is cancelled almost at once, such as underwriting, issuing documents and commissions; check the insurer's filing for its stated reason and amount. Which insurers use one, and how widely, I could not confirm from a regulator page, so ask for the actual rule. inside a nonstandard auto policy: fees, short terms, down payments describes down-payment and fee practices that often sit beside such a rule, and storefront agencies, big down payments and policies that vanish covers agency fees.

What the policy says counts, but state law limits what it can say.

What state rules say: six examples

The table summarizes statutes read for this article. Each row is a different approach, which is the point: do not assume your state follows another's.

State Rule as read Source
Florida If the insured cancels, the insurer may keep up to 10% of the unearned premium and must refund at least 90%; unearned premium is computed pro rata. If the insurer cancels, it refunds 100% of unearned premium. Fla. Stat. 627.7283
California A personal motor vehicle liability contract cannot make premium fully earned on any event except expiration (policy and membership fees excepted). Any non-pro-rata refund, including cancellation fees, must be disclosed in writing before the application and each renewal. Cal. Ins. Code 481
Michigan An insurer may file a rule for a minimum retention on auto insurance, applied only when it exceeds the pro rata retention, never on renewals, and not when you replace the policy with another insurer's and give proof. MCL 500.3020
Washington Private passenger auto refunds are computed pro rata, with minimum refund percentages of the unearned portion: 90% of the first $100, 95% from $100 to $500, and 97% above $500. RCW 48.18.300
Louisiana Refund at the customary pro rata rate unless the policy filed with the commissioner says otherwise; monetary penalties for cancelling are prohibited except for surplus lines, but a filed short-rate provision is allowed. La. R.S. 22:885
Texas The insurer must refund the unearned portion no later than the 15th business day after cancellation of a personal auto policy. Tex. Ins. Code 558.002

Details, with the pages checked November 2026:

Florida. The statute sets a 30-day deadline when the insured cancels and 15 days when the insurer cancels, with 8 percent interest on late refunds, and requires 100% of unearned premium back for a servicemember who cancels because of active-duty orders or a transfer (Florida Statutes 627.7283). A separate statute, 627.7295, bars an insured from cancelling a policy or binder in the first two months except for total destruction of the vehicle, transfer of ownership, or purchase of another policy covering it, and generally requires a policy term of at least six months (Florida Statutes 627.7295). It also allows an agent a per-policy fee of up to $10 on a basic policy, which is not part of the premium, and a nonrefundable fee for motor vehicle reports not exceeding the agent's actual cost. These fees are why a Florida refund can be smaller than the unearned premium alone suggests.

California. Section 481 sets the baseline: the person insured is entitled to the unexpired portion of premium on a policy for a definite period (California Insurance Code 481). Under the same section, a disclosure is not required when the policy allows a non-pro-rata refund but the insurer actually refunds pro rata.

Michigan. The statute lets the insurer file a minimum-retention rule, but sets conditions that include no retention on renewals and none when the policy is replaced with proof of other coverage. It also permits a noncancelable, nonrefundable six-month prepaid policy to satisfy vehicle registration requirements (MCL 500.3020). If you buy that kind of policy, you are choosing no refund.

Washington. The refund floor in RCW 48.18.300 applies to refunds on private passenger auto, which are computed pro rata, with a note that if a refund is under $2 no refund need be made, and the insurer must pay within 30 days of receiving the cancellation notice (RCW 48.18.300).

Louisiana. The statute's text allows a filed short-rate provision and prohibits monetary penalties, so what the policy says, as filed, governs (La. R.S. 22:885).

Texas. The refund timing is set by statute: not later than the 15th business day after the effective date of cancellation for personal auto (Texas Insurance Code 558.002). The Texas Department of Insurance separately says a company must refund unearned premium within 15 days of cancellation (TDI: was your auto insurance not renewed or canceled). When two official sources phrase a deadline differently, ask the insurer which it applies and put your request in writing.

Not every state is covered here, and the six differ enough that one rule cannot be assumed. For the others, find the state's cancellation statute through the insurance department.

Is there a free-look window on auto insurance?

A "free look" is a period after purchase when you can cancel for a full refund. It is standard in some other insurance lines. For auto insurance I did not find a general free-look statute in the sources above, and Florida's rule runs the other way: an insured cannot cancel during the first two months except for the three listed reasons. Michigan's rule on replacing a policy removes the retention when you replace coverage and show proof, which achieves something similar for a switch. If an insurer advertises a "full refund if you cancel in 30 days" promise, ask for it in writing and check whether it is in the policy or only in marketing. See short-term car insurance and binders: when they make sense for binders and short terms.

How to estimate your refund: three methods

Define a hypothetical: a six-month policy with a 180-day term and a premium of $1,200, fully paid, cancelled after 20 days, so 160 days are unexpired. All numbers are invented for the example.

Method 1, pro rata. Unearned premium is 160 divided by 180 times $1,200, or $1,066.67. Refund $1,066.67, less any non-refundable fees.

Method 2, Florida-style cap. If the insured cancels, the insurer may keep up to 10% of the unearned premium, so it must refund at least 90%: 90% of $1,066.67 is $960.00. The retention is $106.67 at most.

Method 3, Washington-style floors. Take 90% of the first $100 of unearned premium ($90.00), 95% of the next $400 ($380.00) and 97% of the remaining $566.67 ($549.67). That is $1,019.67, so the insurer keeps at most about $47.

If the policy has a $25 non-refundable policy fee, subtract it. If you financed, a finance charge is another cost, and the refund goes first to the finance company in many arrangements, as Florida's premium finance statute describes (Florida Statutes 627.848 for the Florida version). What reaches you is the leftover.

If the policy uses a hypothetical minimum earned premium of 25% of the term premium, that is $300 retained regardless, which is more than the pro rata earned amount of $133.33 (20 days of 180 times $1,200). In that case the refund would be $900. A rule like that has to be allowed by your state and disclosed.

A worksheet in six steps

  1. Find the premium and the term on the declarations page.
  2. Find the cancellation clause in the policy or on the endorsement list. Look for the words "short rate," "minimum earned," "minimum retained" or "cancellation fee."
  3. Count the days used from the effective date to the date you will cancel, and the days in the term.
  4. Compute the pro rata earned premium and the unearned remainder.
  5. Apply any retention percentage or minimum, then subtract fees listed as non-refundable.
  6. Compare the result with what the insurer says it will refund, and ask for the calculation in writing if the figures differ.

How to avoid the penalty

  • Ask before you pay. Ask whether the policy has a minimum earned premium, short rate or cancellation fee, and ask to see the clause. In California, the written disclosure of non-pro-rata refunds is required before application.
  • Compare policies on cancellation terms, not just price. A cheaper quote with a short-rate clause can cost more if you switch after two months. Add a row for it in the car insurance quote comparison worksheet.
  • Do not cancel the old policy until the new one is in force, and give proof of replacement. In Michigan, retention does not apply when you replace the policy and give proof. replacing a policy without a gap: the overlap day and the refund covers the sequence.
  • Time the cancellation. If a month-end or renewal is near, compare the cost of waiting a few days with the penalty.
  • Pay in installments only if you can keep them, since a policy cancelled for nonpayment may lead to retention. See cancelled for nonpayment: reinstate the policy or start over?.
  • Request the refund in writing and record the date; statutory deadlines run from the cancellation or the request. getting your money back: refund timelines and credit balances covers what to do if it is late.

Questions to ask an insurer or agent

  1. Does this policy have a minimum earned premium or a minimum retained amount? How much?
  2. If I cancel, is the refund pro rata or short rate? Which statute or filing sets that?
  3. Which fees are not refundable, and are any agency fees refundable?
  4. Is there a time window in which I can cancel for a full refund, and is it written in the policy?
  5. Does the penalty change if I cancel because I sold the car, moved, or replaced the policy with another insurer's?
  6. How many days will the refund take, and in what form?
  7. If my premium is financed, who receives the refund first?

Common questions

It depends on the state. California bars a motor vehicle liability contract from making premium fully earned on any event but expiration, and requires disclosure of non-pro-rata refunds. Michigan lets insurers file a minimum retention rule with limits. Florida caps what an insurer may keep at 10% of unearned premium when the insured cancels.

Will I get my money back if the insurer cancels?

In Florida, the statute requires 100% of unearned premium back when the insurer cancels. Check your state's equivalent.

Do policy fees come back?

Often not. California's section 481 states that its prohibition on fully earned premium does not apply to policy fees or membership fees, and Florida treats a permitted agent fee as outside the premium.

How long does the refund take?

Statutory deadlines vary: Texas sets the 15th business day after cancellation for personal auto, Florida 30 days when the insured cancels, and Washington 30 days after receiving notice. Ask for the date in writing.

Key takeaways

  • Minimum earned premium and short-rate refunds are rules that let an insurer keep more than the days you used; each must be allowed by your state and disclosed.
  • Florida, Washington, California, Michigan, Louisiana and Texas show six different approaches, so your state's statute matters.
  • Fees often do not come back, so subtract them when estimating a refund.
  • Compute pro rata first, then apply any retention or minimum, and ask for the calculation in writing.
  • Compare policies on cancellation terms before you buy, and never cancel the old policy before the new one is active.

Sources

Terms used in this guide

Related states

Related guides

Related tools

Latest on this topic