Blog

Why quote spreads differ by state: prior approval vs file-and-use

States regulate auto rates in different ways, from prior approval to file-and-use. What those systems change, what they do not, and what it means for shopping.

Every state regulates what auto insurers may charge, but not in the same way. Some require the regulator to approve a rate before any driver is charged it (prior approval); others let an insurer start using a rate once it is filed (file-and-use) or even before it is filed (use-and-file). The system sets how fast prices can move and how much a regulator can review, but it does not remove the differences between insurers, so shopping pays in every state. How much it pays depends far more on your own profile, your ZIP code and the insurers you ask than on a label in the state's law.

This article explains the systems, shows where a few states sit on the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) chart, separates what the evidence says from what it does not, and ends with practical implications for how many quotes to collect.

What a rate filing is and why states regulate it

A rate filing is the paperwork an insurer submits to a state regulator describing the rates, rating manuals and rules it will use to price a line of insurance. The filing carries the actuarial support: loss experience, expenses, trend assumptions and the like. Florida's motor vehicle statute is a good example of what a regulator is told to look at. Florida directs its Office of Insurance Regulation to judge whether a rate is excessive, inadequate or unfairly discriminatory, considering past and prospective loss experience, expenses, "the degree of competition among insurers for the risk insured," investment income, the cost of repairs and medical services, reinsurance and trend factors (Florida Statutes 627.0651, checked November 2026). The guide loss ratios and rate filings: how insurers justify an increase explains how insurers justify an increase, and How to read a car insurance rate filing on SERFF shows what a filing looks like.

The filing method answers a narrower question: when may the insurer start charging the new rate, and what happens if the regulator objects?

The five systems in plain language

The NAIC's chart of rate filing methods defines the terms in its own words, and the definitions below are paraphrased from the chart's Fall 2022 edition, which was the one I could open (NAIC via the Maryland Insurance Administration: Rate filing methods for property/casualty insurance, Fall 2022, checked November 2026). States change their laws, so use the chart as a guide to categories, not as the current word for any one state.

System What the insurer must do What the regulator keeps
Prior approval Get the rates approved before using them. Many states add a "deemer" clause: approval is presumed if the regulator has not denied the filing within a set number of days. Power to approve, modify or deny first.
Modified prior approval Prior approval for some kinds of changes, such as a new expense ratio or rate relativity; experience-only changes use file-and-use. Review of the larger structural changes.
Flex rating Prior approval only when a change exceeds a set percentage above (and sometimes below) the previous rate. Review of large moves; small ones pass.
File-and-use File before using the rates; no specific approval needed. The right of later disapproval.
Use-and-file Use the rates, then file within a stated period. Review after the fact.
No file No filing; the insurer keeps its records and must make them available on request. Access to records if the commissioner asks.

States often use different systems for different lines, and sometimes for different parts of the same line. The chart also notes that a filing method may rest on whether the state has found the market competitive. So a state's auto rule may differ from its homeowners rule, and a state may have a special rule for the residual market (the plan for drivers other insurers decline). See assigned risk plan for that last point.

Where some states sit

The chart's Fall 2022 entries for private passenger auto show how varied the picture is. These are examples, not a ranking, and each was as the chart read in September 2022:

  • California: prior approval under Insurance Code sections 1861.05 and 1851, with rate changes deemed approved 180 days after receipt unless disapproved after a hearing or in extraordinary circumstances. See proposition 103 and California.
  • Illinois: use-and-file for private passenger auto, with a 10-day window noted in the chart. See Illinois.
  • Georgia: file-and-use for personal private passenger auto, under Georgia Code section 33-9-21. See Georgia.
  • Florida: auto is filed under Florida's motor vehicle statute, either as file-and-use (filed at least 60 days before the effective date, with the rate deemed approved if the regulator issues no notice of preliminary findings within 60 days) or as use-and-file (filed no later than 30 days after the effective date), at the insurer's choice and with the risk of a refund order if the rate is later found excessive (Florida Statutes 627.0651, checked November 2026). See Florida.
  • Texas: the Insurance Code says each insurer shall file its rates and rating manuals with the commissioner, and "an insurer may use a rate filed under this subchapter on and after the date the rate is filed," which is file-and-use (Texas Insurance Code 2251.101, via Texas Public Law, checked November 2026). See Texas.
  • North Carolina and New Jersey: the chart lists prior approval for personal auto, and in North Carolina the filing is made by a rate bureau.

The chart's own warning applies: it "does not constitute a formal legal opinion" and the statutes it cites should be consulted. To see your state's current rule, read the state's statute or ask the department of insurance; state car insurance requirements lookup covers minimum coverage, not rate rules.

What the system changes

Three things differ most in practice.

How fast prices can change

Under prior approval, a rate increase waits for the regulator's decision or for a deemer period to pass. The chart shows that waiting periods are written into law: California's 180-day deemer is one example, and the chart lists 60-day and other deemers for other states. Under file-and-use or use-and-file, an insurer can raise rates sooner. For a driver, this affects the timing of renewals more than the level of any one quote; see from filing to your bill: the timeline of an auto rate increase.

How much a regulator can review

Prior approval gives the regulator the first look. File-and-use and use-and-file give it a look after the fact, with a power to order a change or, in Florida's case, to order that excess premium be returned. A review is not the same as a price cap: a regulator can reject a rate as excessive, but it does not choose which insurer you will find cheapest.

How easy it is for a new rate plan to reach the market

An insurer that wants to introduce a new rating factor or a new tier must file it everywhere it sells. In prior-approval states the new plan waits for approval; elsewhere it can be used sooner. That can make the set of prices on the market look different in different states at the same moment, which is one source of the differences you see between states in dated studies.

What the system does not change

Rate regulation does not require every insurer to charge the same price for the same driver. Each insurer files its own rates, built from its own claims, expenses and appetite. A filing method decides when those rates may be used; it does not make them converge. The result is that large differences between insurers exist in every state, whichever system applies.

Two dated, non-regulator sources show the size of those differences. They use different methods, and neither sorts states by filing system, so neither proves that a system causes a spread.

  • ValuePenguin's 2023 study used Quadrant Information Services full-coverage quotes for every ZIP code in all 50 states and D.C., for a 48-year-old man driving a Nissan Altima with no accidents or tickets, on a stated set of limits. It found a national average of $1,974 a year for good-credit drivers against a lowest premium of $1,022, a potential saving of $952; for poor-credit drivers, an average of $3,398 against a lowest premium of $1,755, a potential saving of $1,643 (ValuePenguin: Shopping around for car insurance study, published March 2023, page last modified June 2026, checked November 2026). The page notes that the rates come from insurer filings and may differ from individual quotes. The study reports the lowest premium found, not how many quotes a driver needed to find it.
  • CarInsurance.com's 2026 State of Car Insurance report analyzed 65,756,440 quotes from 195 insurers across 34,595 ZIP codes, and said there is "nearly a $1,200 difference" between the cheapest and most expensive carriers' average full-coverage premiums; it excludes USAA from that comparison because USAA sells only to military members and their families (CarInsurance.com: 2026 State of Car Insurance, checked November 2026). The same page gives different totals in a methodology note and does not reconcile them, and the figures are national averages for full coverage.

Both sources are commercial analyses of quote data. Treat them as evidence that spreads are wide, not as measurements of any state's regulatory system.

What the research says about regulation and prices

Economists have compared prior-approval states with open-competition states, mostly looking at price levels and loss ratios rather than the spread between quotes. I did not find an opened, state-by-state measure of quote spread sorted by filing system, so this article makes no claim that one system produces wider or narrower spreads. The practical lesson does not depend on one: a statute's label does not tell you how much a quote varies. The related article prior approval vs file-and-use: do regulated states pay more or less? covers what is known about price levels.

The mechanisms are worth stating as reasoning, not as measured results:

  • Regulators in some prior-approval states may limit how quickly an insurer can move toward its preferred price. If insurers are held at different distances from the price they want, the gap between insurers at a given moment can widen.
  • In states where insurers can change rates quickly, prices may converge sooner after each change.
  • Neither effect has to be large, and both may be swamped by the number of insurers competing in a state and by each driver's own rating factors.

Competitive and regulated markets, and state-run plans

Some states let competition do more of the work. The chart notes that in some states filing requirements depend on a finding that the market is competitive, and in states with "no file" systems the insurer only keeps records for the commissioner. Others set up plans that function as a backstop rather than a competitor.

The Texas Office of Public Insurance Counsel's shopping guide shows one such backstop: the Texas Automobile Insurance Plan Association offers minimum liability limits, personal injury protection of $2,500 and uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage of 30/60/25 to drivers who cannot find coverage (Texas OPIC: Auto Insurance Shopping Guide, checked November 2026). Plans like this are priced and offered under their own rules and are for drivers who cannot buy coverage in the ordinary market; they are not a way to find a cheaper policy. See assigned risk plan and state low-cost auto insurance programs.

A dated numeric example, with your own numbers

The study figures above show spreads for a particular profile at a particular time. To see the spread for you, set up a small table of quotes. The numbers below are hypothetical, defined here only to show the method.

A driver in a prior-approval state and a driver in a file-and-use state each collect five quotes for the same coverage:

Quote State A (prior approval) State B (file-and-use)
1 $1,420 $1,380
2 $1,510 $1,640
3 $1,560 $1,720
4 $1,680 $1,900
5 $1,790 $2,150
Spread (high minus low) $370 $770

In this made-up table, State B has the larger spread, but nothing about the filing systems made it so; the same spreads could appear the other way around. The useful comparison is between the lowest quote and the quote you already have. A driver paying $1,720 in State B would save $340 a year by moving to the $1,380 quote, while a driver paying $1,560 in State A would save $140 by moving to the $1,420 quote. Replace these numbers with real quotes at identical coverage; how to compare car insurance quotes apples to apples explains how to keep them comparable.

What this means for shopping

  1. Do not skip shopping because your state "regulates rates." Regulation reviews each insurer's own filing; it does not set one price. The Insurance Information Institute advises collecting at least three price quotes and mixing insurer types, and notes that state insurance departments may offer price comparisons (Triple-I: Nine ways to lower your auto insurance costs, checked November 2026).
  2. Use your state's own comparison tools. Texas runs HelpInsure.com, which shows sample auto rates, complaint indexes and financial ratings for the top 25 insurance groups, with the caveat that sample prices are estimates and you must contact an agent or insurer for an actual price (Texas OPIC: Auto Insurance Shopping Guide, checked November 2026). See state-run auto insurance price comparison tools and shopper's guides for other states.
  3. Expect timing effects in file-and-use and use-and-file states. Prices can move sooner, so a quote can age faster. Re-check at each renewal; see how often should you shop for car insurance?.
  4. Use the department of insurance for rules that apply to you. Ask your state regulator how it handles auto rate filings, and whether any limits on rating factors (credit, gender, ZIP code) apply to your quote.
  5. Decide how many quotes to get by your profile, not by the system. The companion article How many quotes are enough? Diminishing returns in shopping works through the arithmetic. The ValuePenguin figures above hint at one pattern: its poor-credit drivers had a larger potential saving ($1,643) than its good-credit drivers ($952), so a profile that insurers treat differently can mean more to gain from extra quotes.

Common questions

Does prior approval mean cheaper insurance?

Not necessarily. Prior approval controls when a rate can be used, not which insurer is cheapest for you. Research on price levels is mixed, and prior approval vs file-and-use: do regulated states pay more or less? discusses it. Whatever your state's system, quote several insurers.

Can the regulator order a refund?

In some systems it can. Florida's statute says an insurer making a use-and-file filing is potentially subject to an order to return to policyholders portions of rates found excessive (Florida Statutes 627.0651, checked November 2026).

Where can I see my state's rule?

The NAIC chart lists the citation for each state, and the state department of insurance can confirm the current rule. Check the chart's date; the one I could open was Fall 2022.

Is a state with a hearing process safer for consumers?

Not on that basis alone. A hearing or review process applies to an insurer's filing, but it does not tell you which insurer is cheapest for you. Your own quotes do.

Key takeaways

  • States use prior approval, flex rating, file-and-use, use-and-file or no filing for auto, and the choice mostly sets timing and review, not a single price.
  • Quote spreads are wide in every state; commercial studies of 2022-2026 quote data show hundreds to over a thousand dollars between insurers for the same profile.
  • A filing system's name does not predict how much you will save by shopping; your own quotes do.
  • Use your state's comparison tools and department of insurance, and re-shop at renewal.

Sources

Terms used in this guide

Related states

Related guides

Related tools

Latest on this topic