Blog

How many quotes are enough? Diminishing returns in shopping

Three to five well-chosen quotes capture most of the available saving. A worked model, the published price-spread data and a quoting plan show where to stop.

For most drivers, three to five quotes from different kinds of insurers capture most of the saving that is available, and quotes beyond roughly six or seven add very little for the time they cost. The rule of three is not a law of nature: it comes from consumer advice and from simple arithmetic about how the lowest price in a group behaves as the group grows. Drivers whose profile insurers treat very differently, such as drivers with poor credit or a recent claim, can justify more.

Below, the published evidence on price spreads, a worked model with numbers you can change, the time cost of each quote, how to mix channels, and a quoting plan that tells you when to stop.

What the published data say about price spread

No single study measures the spread for every driver, but several published analyses point the same way: large differences between insurers exist for the same driver and coverage.

  • ValuePenguin (2023). Using Quadrant Information Services full-coverage quotes for every ZIP code in all 50 states and D.C., for a 48-year-old man driving a Nissan Altima with no accidents or tickets, ValuePenguin found a national average of $1,974 a year for good-credit drivers against a lowest premium of $1,022, a potential saving of $952. For poor-credit drivers the average was $3,398 against a lowest premium of $1,755, a potential saving of $1,643. The page notes that rates come from insurer filings and may differ from individual quotes, and it does not say how many quotes a driver needed to find the lowest one (ValuePenguin: Shopping around for car insurance study, published March 2023, checked November 2026).
  • CarInsurance.com (2026). Its State of Car Insurance report analyzed 65,756,440 quotes from 195 insurers across 34,595 ZIP codes and says there is "nearly a $1,200 difference" between the cheapest and most expensive carriers' average full-coverage premiums, excluding USAA because it sells only to military members and their families. The report's methodology note gives different totals and does not reconcile them, and the averages are national, not yours (CarInsurance.com: 2026 State of Car Insurance, checked November 2026).
  • NerdWallet via press syndication (June 2026). A syndicated article reports a June 2026 NerdWallet analysis finding that drivers can overpay by an average of $4,914 a year by not comparing carriers. The article does not state the method, sample or number of insurers, so treat the figure as unverified (KEYT/Stacker: Same driver, same car, why auto insurance quotes can differ by nearly $5,000 a year, October 2026, checked November 2026).

All three are commercial analyses, built from comparison-site or quote data, and none is a regulator's study. I did not find a state department of insurance study that counts how many quotes savings require. Regulator tools such as Texas's HelpInsure.com show sample prices for comparison; the Texas Office of Public Insurance Counsel says you still need an agent or company for exact prices (Texas OPIC: Auto Insurance Shopping Guide, checked November 2026).

What the data support is narrower than the headlines: the gap between the cheapest and the typical price is often several hundred dollars a year, it is larger for drivers whom insurers rate as higher risk, and it is a gap between the lowest quote in a large set and the average, not what one driver finds with a few clicks.

How shopping behaves in the real market

J.D. Power's 2025 U.S. Insurance Shopping Study found that 57% of auto customers shopped for a new policy in 2024, up from 49% a year earlier. Its sample was 12,720 customers who had requested an auto quote from at least one competing insurer in the previous six months, fielded from April 2024 through January 2025 (Insurance Journal: JD Power, Drivers Keep Shopping Even as Auto Insurance Price Increases Slow, May 2025, checked November 2026). The syndicated article cited above adds that 29% of those who shopped switched carriers; that figure comes from the secondary article, not from the study text I could open.

ValuePenguin's 2021 survey, quoted in its 2023 page, found that 26% of Americans had never compared multiple quotes and 76% of those who shopped around said they saved money. That is a self-reported survey, so it supports "shopping often helps" without saying how much.

A worked model of diminishing returns

Here is the arithmetic behind the rule of three. The numbers are hypothetical; change them for your market.

Suppose ten insurers would quote you somewhere between $1,200 and $2,100 a year for identical coverage, spread evenly across that range, and you meet them in a random order. If you collect n quotes and take the lowest, the expected lowest price is the bottom of the range plus the width divided by n + 1. With a $900 range:

Quotes collected Expected lowest price Expected saving vs one random quote Gain from the last quote
1 $1,650 $0 n/a
2 $1,500 $150 $150
3 $1,425 $225 $75
4 $1,380 $270 $45
5 $1,350 $300 $30
6 $1,329 $321 $21
8 $1,300 $350 $12.50 (from the 7th to the 8th)
10 $1,282 $368 about $8 (from the 9th to the 10th)

The first quote beyond the one you have captures a third of the potential saving. Three quotes capture about 61% of the saving that ten would find, and five capture about 82%. The pattern, with each extra quote adding less than the last, does not depend on the exact numbers. It depends only on prices being spread across a range and your sampling them without bias.

This is a model, not a measurement. Real quotes are not evenly spread: prices bunch around a typical level with a few low outliers, and the outliers are the quotes that matter. If the lowest price belongs to a company that prices only a narrow slice of drivers, random sampling will miss it, which is a reason to aim your quotes at insurers that tend to fit your profile instead of sampling at random.

The time cost of each quote

A quote has a cost in minutes. Set a rough value on your time and compare it with the marginal gain.

Hypothetically, if each quote takes 25 minutes and you value an hour at $30, each quote costs about $12.50 in time. In the table above, the gain from the eighth quote is about $12.50, so the break-even sits near eight quotes. If you value an hour at $60, each quote costs $25 and the break-even falls to roughly five quotes. If one quote takes five minutes because you have your details to hand, the break-even rises. Gains also scale with the size of the premium: a household paying $4,000 a year has a much wider range to sample than one paying $1,000, so more quotes pay.

Some time costs are not obvious. Your phone can ring for weeks after online quote requests; see why your phone rings after a car insurance quote. Quotes use personal data, and what is needed varies; see what personal data a car insurance quote really needs. Whether a quote touches your credit report depends on the insurer and the data it pulls; see do car insurance quotes hurt your credit score?.

Channel mix matters more than raw count

The Insurance Information Institute advises getting "at least three price quotes" and suggests quotes from different types of insurers: those that sell through their own agents, those that sell through independent agents who offer policies from several companies, and those that sell directly to consumers; it also notes that your state insurance department may provide price comparisons of major insurers (Triple-I: Nine ways to lower your auto insurance costs, checked November 2026). That advice is about variety.

Consider what each channel gives you:

Channel What one conversation returns Watch for
Captive agent One company's price One data point only; see captive agent
Independent agent Several companies' prices from one set of questions The agent can only quote the companies they represent; see independent agent
Direct insurer (website or app) One company's price, often fast You enter the data yourself; see direct writer
Comparison site Several prices or estimates Estimates may not be bindable; see how car insurance comparison sites and lead generators work and comparison site estimates vs bindable quotes: what the number promises
State tool (where offered) Sample prices from many insurers Sample prices are estimates; the OPIC page says to contact an agent or company for actual prices

An independent agent or a comparison tool can return several prices from one set of answers, so "number of quotes" and "number of conversations" are different things. Five quotes from one conversation cost much less time than five separate ones. A sensible mix is one independent agent or comparison tool (several prices), one or two direct insurers you are curious about, and your current insurer's renewal price.

Random variation and why one quote can mislead

Two quotes for the same driver can differ for reasons that are not about price level.

Random variation is a reason to treat small gaps with suspicion. If the two lowest quotes differ by $20 a year, you have found a tie, and the decision should turn on service, claims handling and financial strength, not price.

When to stop

Stopping rules are easier to follow than a fixed number. Stop when any two of these are true:

  1. You have at least three comparable quotes across at least two kinds of insurers.
  2. The last two quotes you collected did not beat your best by more than a figure you pick in advance (for example, 3% of the annual premium).
  3. Your best quote beats your current renewal price by enough to cover the work of switching, and you have checked the insurer's financial strength and complaint record.
  4. The time you have spent has reached your break-even.

Continue past that point when your profile is unusual (a recent accident or violation, a lapse in coverage, a young driver, a poor credit score), when you own several cars or drivers, or when the saving at stake is large, because the spread is wider and the gains bigger. ValuePenguin's own figures show a larger potential saving for poor-credit than for good-credit drivers.

  1. Collect your details once. Gather your current declarations page, driver license numbers, vehicle identification numbers, annual mileage and claims history, so each quote takes minutes. See what you need to get a car insurance quote.
  2. Set the coverage. Choose limits and deductibles and write them down. Every quote uses them.
  3. Get your renewal price first. Ask your current insurer for the renewal terms. This is your benchmark.
  4. Collect three to five quotes in a mix of channels. For example, one independent agent or comparison tool, one captive agent or direct insurer, and one more insurer you have reason to check.
  5. Compare totals on one sheet. Use the car insurance quote comparison worksheet and the method in how to compare car insurance quotes apples to apples. Include fees and the payment plan.
  6. Extend only if the gains justify it. If the best quote beats your benchmark by a large margin, or your profile is unusual, add two or three more.
  7. Check the finalists. Look up financial strength and complaint data for the winner; see how to research a car insurance company before you buy.
  8. Switch cleanly. Start the new policy before cancelling the old one; see how to switch car insurance without a gap.
  9. Set a reminder. Re-quote at the next renewal, or sooner if your circumstances change; see how often should you shop for car insurance?.

Rules and prices vary by state; your state's insurance department can tell you which comparison tools it offers, and the companion article why quote spreads differ by state: prior approval vs file-and-use explains how state rate regulation fits in.

Common questions

Is three quotes really enough?

It captures a large share of the saving in the model above and matches the Triple-I's "at least three" advice, but it is a minimum, not a ceiling. If your profile is unusual or the premium is large, five to seven can pay.

Do more quotes hurt my credit?

It depends on what each insurer pulls, and you can ask before you quote; the article do car insurance quotes hurt your credit score? covers what to check.

Should I quote my current insurer too?

Yes. Ask for your renewal price and also for a new-customer quote if one is offered, so that you know what staying costs.

How often should I repeat the exercise?

At least when you renew and after big changes such as a move, a new car, a new driver or a change in credit. The guide how often should you shop for car insurance? covers timing.

Key takeaways

  • Published analyses of 2022-2026 quote data show spreads of hundreds of dollars a year between insurers for the same profile; they are commercial studies and averages, not guarantees for you.
  • In a simple model, each added quote helps less than the last: three capture about 61% of the available saving and five about 82%.
  • Mix channels (agent, direct, comparison tool) rather than repeating one, and use identical coverage in every quote.
  • Stop when the last quotes stop beating your best by a margin you set, and go further if your profile is unusual.

Sources

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Related tools

Latest on this topic