Blog

Agreed value, stated value and actual cash value compared

Which valuation basis governs a total loss, and can you choose it? How the three policy wordings pay, with a worked example and what to ask before buying.

Most car policies pay actual cash value when a car is totaled: what a comparable car would cost on the market just before the loss, less your deductible. Agreed value is different. You and the insurer fix an amount when the policy starts, and that is what a total loss pays. Stated value sounds similar but usually is not: the amount you state is a ceiling, and the insurer pays the lower of that figure and actual cash value.

You can choose among these only where the insurer sells them. An ordinary policy on an ordinary car pays actual cash value. Agreed value is mainly a collector-car product with eligibility rules. Stated value appears on some other policies, and the word alone does not tell you what you will be paid.

The three bases in one table

Basis What it pays in a total loss Who sets the number Typical use
Actual cash value (ACV) Market value of a comparable car just before the loss, adjusted for condition, less deductible The insurer proposes, using comparable cars; you can dispute Everyday cars
Stated value The lower of the stated amount and ACV (per the insurers described below) You state an amount; the insurer then compares it with ACV Some collector and commercial policies
Agreed value The amount written in the policy You and the insurer, before the loss Collector and specialty cars

Everything beyond this table depends on policy wording. The sections below show what the wording looks like when you can read it.

Actual cash value: how the basic settlement works

The State Farm Car Policy Booklet for Oklahoma (form 9836A) is a useful example because it is posted by a state regulator. In its loss settlement terms, the insurer may either pay the cost to repair the covered vehicle minus the deductible, or "pay the actual cash value of the covered vehicle minus any applicable deductible." The owner and the insurer must agree on the actual cash value. If they disagree, either side can ask in writing for appraisal, in which each picks an appraiser and a written appraisal agreed to by two appraisers is binding. The same form says that if the owner keeps the damaged car, the payment is reduced by the car's value after the loss.

Actual cash value is not defined the same way everywhere. The California Department of Insurance says that, unless the policy defines it otherwise, actual cash value in California means fair market value, the price a knowledgeable buyer under no pressure would pay a knowledgeable seller. State regulations then set how the insurer must work it out.

What state rules require

Three public texts show the pattern. The details differ by state, so use them as examples and check your own state.

  • California, 10 CCR 2695.8. The insurer may pay cash based on the actual cost of a "comparable automobile" less the deductible. The settlement must include applicable taxes and one-time transfer fees. A comparable must be of like kind and quality: same manufacturer, same or newer year, similar body type, options and mileage, and available in the local market within 90 days of the final offer. The cost of the comparable may not be reduced for the loss vehicle's condition unless its documented condition is below average, and any adjustment must be "discernible, measurable, itemized, and specified." Under the regulation as published by Cornell's Legal Information Institute, the insurer must also tell you it will reopen the claim if you cannot buy a comparable car with the settlement within 35 days.
  • Washington, WAC 284-30-391. The rule lets the insurer offer a comparable vehicle, a cash settlement based on actual cash value of a comparable vehicle, or appraisal if the policy has an appraisal clause. It includes taxes and fees that you would have incurred, requires itemized, verifiable dollar adjustments for options, mileage and condition, and allows an agreed value: "the agreement must be documented in the claim file," and the insurer must take reasonable steps to ensure the agreed value is accurate. That is a regulator acknowledging that a value can be agreed rather than computed.
  • NAIC Model Regulation 902. The model text (1997 edition) has the same shape: a cash settlement based on the actual cost of a comparable car including taxes and fees, deductions that are "measurable, discernible, itemized and specified as to dollar amount," and betterment deductions for wear, tear or rust limited to no more than $1,000. States adopt their own versions, so the cap may not apply where you live.

For the mechanics behind a valuation report, see how to read a total loss valuation report line by line, condition adjustments: why a totaled car is valued below its price and what state rules require insurers to do in a total loss valuation.

Stated value: a ceiling, not a promise

Stated value means different things in different policies, so the wording matters more than the label. Two public sources describe the common version.

Progressive Commercial's page on stated amount explains that after an accident the insurer compares the stated amount with actual cash value and pays "whichever is less." Its example is a delivery van with a $50,000 stated amount and a $35,000 actual cash value: the owner receives $35,000, but has paid premium based on $50,000. That page concerns commercial vehicles. We found no personal auto policy form that uses the term "stated amount," so we cite it only for the mechanism.

Hagerty's classic car page describes stated value in similar terms: a policy that "gives the insurer the right to pay you" either depreciated cash value or replacement cost, "they'll choose the lower of the two amounts." And Grundy's Insurance 101 page calls stated value an actual cash value policy with a payout cap.

Both are insurers describing a competitor's product, so read them as warnings to check the policy wording, not as findings about every stated-value policy. The label alone does not settle it. The test is the loss settlement clause: does it say "pay the stated amount," or "pay the lesser of"?

Why stated value can cost you twice

Overinsuring costs premium without adding payout. In the Progressive Commercial example, the owner paid a higher premium without getting the coverage expected. Underinsuring has its own cost: a limit below the car's value caps recovery at the stated figure even if ACV is higher.

Agreed value: what it is and who qualifies

Agreed value fixes the payout in advance. The Insurance Information Institute's page on classic car insurance describes the first step as reaching an agreement with the insurer on the vehicle's value, after which the car is covered up to that value without depreciation. It warns that classic cars may increase in value, so the coverage should be updated.

Hagerty describes its version as "Guaranteed Value," which "will be paid to you in the event of a covered total loss." Its footnote says the guaranteed value includes all taxes and fees unless prohibited by state law. Taxes and fees are worth asking about, because a basic ACV settlement adds them by regulation in some states, and an agreed value may or may not include them.

Eligibility is the price of the guarantee. The sources we opened describe these conditions:

  • Use. Hagerty says the main requirement is that the car is not a daily driver, with occasional pleasure use allowed and daily commuting not. It says mileage is considered and that 3,500 miles a year or fewer is typical for collectible vehicles, with up to 7,500 considered.
  • Storage. Grundy says cars must be kept in a secured enclosed garage when not in use.
  • Driver record. Grundy lists a valid license for all drivers and a clean driving record with no major violations in the past three years for its Motor Vehicle Program.
  • Age and type. Grundy says it insures collector cars of all years, and Hagerty says to ask about usage if you own a vehicle generally 1990 or newer.

These conditions are company specific, and eligibility varies by insurer and state. Because Hagerty says the car should not be a daily driver, an agreed value policy is typically for a car you own in addition to the one you drive every day. See classic and collector car insurance and insuring a classic or collector car: agreed value and usage limits.

Replacement cost for new cars

A fourth basis applies to cars that are new. New car replacement coverage pays for a new car instead of an actual cash value. Amica's website describes the version it includes with all auto policies: the vehicle must have been new when purchased and never titled or leased, and the total loss must occur "within 365 days of purchase or before 12,000 miles, whichever comes first." It requires collision and comprehensive coverage and pays the replacement cost of a new vehicle of the same make, model, year and equipment, less your deductible. For older cars, its Better Vehicle Replacement, included with its Signature policies, bases the settlement on the actual cash value of the same vehicle one model year newer.

Other insurers' terms differ in age, mileage and availability, and the Amica page states that availability, limits and deductibles vary by state and policy. We use it as an example, not as a comparison. For details, see better car replacement claims: what you actually get paid and new car replacement, better car and gap: endorsements compared.

Appraisals and documents drive the payout

For ACV, the insurer builds the number from comparables, so your job is to supply evidence it did not consider: service records, recent tires, a new engine, options and condition. For agreed value, you do the opposite: you supply the evidence before the policy starts, and it becomes the contract.

What insurers say they ask for:

  • Photos. Hagerty says it needs one good full side-view photo for stock vehicles and four photos for custom or modified ones (full vehicle, engine, interior, trunk or bed).
  • Appraisals. Hagerty says it typically does not require appraisals but may ask during underwriting if more support is needed.
  • Receipts and comparables. Grundy says underwriters review the requested value against photos and documentation and "the agency's guidelines on similar vehicles in similar condition," and may ask for restoration receipts or more photos.
  • Updates. Grundy offers to adjust the insured value annually before a loss, and the Insurance Information Institute advises keeping coverage current as values rise.

Documents that tend to support an agreed value, in line with those descriptions:

  1. Dated photographs of all sides, the interior, the engine bay and the odometer.
  2. Restoration or major-repair invoices and parts receipts.
  3. A recent independent appraisal if the car is rare or heavily modified.
  4. Auction results or sale listings for comparable cars, with dates.
  5. Title and registration showing ownership and the VIN.

Keep copies off the car and in the cloud. A flood or fire can destroy the paperwork with the car.

A worked total-loss example (hypothetical numbers)

Assume a driver has a well-kept 1990 roadster. The numbers are invented for illustration.

  • Documented value when the policy started: $60,000.
  • Market value of comparable cars just before the loss: $48,000.
  • Deductible: $500.
  • Sales tax and transfer fees on a replacement at $48,000: $2,400.
Basis Calculation Payout
Agreed value of $60,000 The agreed amount, less deductible if the policy applies one $60,000 (or $59,500 with the deductible)
Stated value of $60,000 (lesser of stated and ACV) Lesser of $60,000 and $48,000, less deductible $47,500
Actual cash value, in a state that adds taxes and fees $48,000 plus $2,400 taxes and fees, less deductible $49,900

The three bases differ by more than $10,000 on the same car. Notice two things. First, the stated value line reduces to ACV because the stated figure ($60,000) is higher than ACV ($48,000); the $47,500 leaves out the $2,400 of taxes and fees, which a policy or state rule might add. Second, the agreed value of $60,000 is higher than the market value of $48,000 because the market fell after the policy began. Agreed value also has a ceiling for the insurer: if the market had risen to $70,000, the payout would still be $60,000 unless the value had been updated.

For a second example on an ordinary car, assume a 2019 sedan with two comparables at $21,000 and $21,800, an average of $21,400, taxes and fees of $1,434, a $500 deductible, and an itemized condition deduction of $350 for documented prior damage. Under an ACV rule like California's, the settlement is $21,400 plus $1,434 minus $350 minus $500, or $21,984. Without documentation of the prior damage, the $350 should not apply. The total loss payout estimator runs similar arithmetic with your own figures.

What to ask when shopping

  1. Is the vehicle valued at actual cash value, stated value, agreed value or replacement cost? Please show me the loss settlement clause.
  2. If it is agreed value, is the agreed amount in the declarations, and does it include taxes and fees?
  3. If it is stated value, does the policy pay the stated amount or the lesser of stated amount and ACV?
  4. What evidence is needed to establish the value, and who decides if it is accepted?
  5. What are the use, mileage and storage conditions, and what happens if I break one?
  6. How often can the value be changed, and is there a charge?
  7. What deductible applies to a total loss?
  8. Is there an appraisal clause, and how is an umpire chosen? See the appraisal clause: settling a dispute over value.
  9. If my car is new, does new car replacement apply, and until what age or mileage?
  10. If I have a loan, how does the policy pay the lender? See what happens if your car is totaled and you still owe money.

Common questions

Can I choose agreed value on any car?

Not always. Agreed value is mainly sold for collector and specialty cars, with use and storage conditions. For an ordinary daily car, the sources we read describe actual cash value as the basis.

Is stated value the same as agreed value?

Usually not. In the sources we read, stated value caps the payout at the lower of the stated amount and actual cash value. Check the settlement clause.

Does actual cash value include sales tax?

In some states yes. California's rule and Washington's rule both require applicable taxes and fees in the settlement, and the NAIC model does too. Confirm for your state with state car insurance requirements lookup.

What if I disagree with the insurer's value?

Ask for the valuation report and your state's total-loss rules, give the insurer your own evidence, and consider the policy's appraisal clause. See how to negotiate a total loss settlement. A licensed attorney or your state insurance department can advise on a specific dispute.

Key takeaways

  • Actual cash value pays market value just before the loss, adjusted and itemized under state rules. It is the default.
  • Agreed value fixes the payout in the policy, backed by documents you give the insurer. It comes with use, storage and eligibility conditions.
  • Stated value is often a ceiling: the insurers we read pay the lower of the stated amount and ACV. Read the settlement clause before relying on the word.
  • New car replacement is a separate coverage with age and mileage limits that vary by insurer.
  • Keep photos, receipts and comparables for your car now, not after a loss.

Sources

Terms used in this guide

Related insurers

Related states

Related guides

Related tools

Latest on this topic