Blog
Does bundling really save money? Evidence on bundle discounts
What insurers' own pages, a published survey and regulator guidance say about home and auto bundle savings, when separate quotes win, and a test to run.
Bundling often lowers the price of the auto policy, and sometimes the total, but the evidence does not support a promise that it always beats the best separate quotes. The published savings figures come from insurers' marketing pages and surveys with different bases, and a discount on one policy says nothing about whether the other policy is priced well. The only reliable answer for your household is a side-by-side test of the bundled total against the cheapest separate pair.
This article reviews what is publicly documented about bundle discounts, where separate policies can win, how the discount can erode, and a step-by-step test.
What a bundle discount is
A multi-policy discount is a credit an insurer applies to one policy, usually auto, when you also buy another policy from the same company or its affiliate, most often homeowners or renters insurance. The glossary entries on bundling and the multi-policy discount cover the terms, and the guide bundling home and auto insurance: how the discount really works covers the mechanics.
The discount is a rating factor in the insurer's filed rates. Insurers in most states must file their rates with the state regulator, and the filings are public in many states. The Texas Department of Insurance says on its rate filing page (checked November 2026) that home and auto insurers must file rates before using them, that you can search filings by company name, and that full documents are available through SERFF using the filing's SERFF ID, though documents marked confidential do not appear. The blog article how to read a multi-policy discount in an insurer's rate filing shows how to read the factor in a filing.
What the published figures say
Three public sources show the range and the problems with the numbers. None is a regulator study, and the differences in basis matter.
Progressive
Progressive's bundling page (checked November 2026) says: "Bundle property and save an average of 5% on auto in most states." The footnote says the average savings are based on a 6-month term and not available in all states, and the page gives no as-of date or data source for the 5% figure. The page makes a separate claim: new customers who bundled home and auto "save over 25% on average," based on a survey of new customers who saved with Progressive from June 2025 through May 2026, with figures in the footnote of $975 for auto and $1,099 for the bundle. The page does not explain how that percentage relates to those two dollar amounts, and it says potential savings vary. The discount is applied to the auto policy and, per the footnote, is not available in all states or situations.
Read the two claims separately. One describes a discount on the auto policy. The other describes savings reported by customers who switched, which mixes the bundle discount with every other difference between their old and new policies.
State Farm
State Farm's bundling page (checked November 2026) says bundling homeowners and auto insurance "could save you up to $1,429." The footnote says this is the average annual per-household savings based on a 2025 national survey by State Farm of new policyholders who reported savings by switching. Another footnote says customers may buy only one policy, but the discount for two or more different lines will then not apply, and that savings, discount names, percentages, availability and eligibility vary by state.
"Up to" and a survey of people who reported savings both select for the households that saved. They do not describe the typical household that asks for a quote.
An independent survey, older
A November 2015 Insurance Business report on a study tabulated by Quadrant Information Services for InsuranceQuotes.com found that the Northeast generally had the smallest average bundle discounts, with auto plus homeowners bundles at 11% in New York and 12% in New Jersey, and auto plus condo bundles at 7% in Virginia and Rhode Island. The article (checked November 2026) also quotes the Insurance Information Institute's James Lynch saying the bundling discount is "just one of many factors" in setting a rate. The data is more than ten years old, so use it for the pattern, that discounts differ by state and bundle type, not for current percentages.
What the three have in common
None gives a household a number it can rely on. The discount varies by insurer, state, bundle type and household. Each source makes the same point in different words: it is one factor among many. That is why a test beats an average.
When separate policies can be cheaper
A bundle discount applies to one company's prices. If that company's base price for either policy is higher than a competitor's by more than the discount, the bundle loses. Common cases:
- The best home price is at a different company. Homeowners pricing depends on roof age, location, claims history and replacement-cost estimates, and companies differ widely on all of them. A discount of a given size on an uncompetitive home policy can still cost more than a competitor's home price plus its auto price.
- The best auto price is at a different company. The same applies to auto, especially for drivers with a ticket or accident, where insurers weigh records differently. See shopping for car insurance after an accident or violation.
- One policy is on a state or residual-market plan. Some homes can only be insured through a plan that does not bundle. See Bundling when your home is on a state plan like FAIR or Citizens.
- Different bundles by line. An auto-plus-renters bundle can discount differently from auto-plus-home, as the 2015 study's separate condo figures illustrate. See bundling renters and auto insurance.
- Fees and payment plans differ. A bundle may carry installment charges across two policies. The article installment fees and pay-in-full discounts across bundled policies covers them.
When bundling helps
Bundling is most likely to win when the same company is competitive on both policies, when you value a single claims contact and a single renewal date, and when the other discounts you qualify for stack with the multi-policy one. The guide Do car insurance discounts stack? How they combine and cap explains how discounts combine.
Some insurers also advertise single-deductible or other bundle features. Progressive's page footnote says its one-deductible benefit is available only when the home policy is underwritten by Progressive Home. Features like that have value only if you would use them, so price them rather than assume.
Renewal drift: the discount that does not stay
A bundle price quoted today is a new-business price. Over time, several things can erode the advantage.
- Rate changes land on each policy separately. A discount stays a fixed percentage while the base rates it applies to move. If the home rate rises faster than the market, the bundle's total can drift above separate quotes without any change to the discount.
- Renewal prices differ from new-customer prices. The blog article your renewal price vs a new quote: compare on the same terms shows why the same terms can be priced differently.
- Losing one policy removes the discount. State Farm's footnote says the discount for two or more lines does not apply if you buy only one policy. If you sell the house, cancel the home policy or move to a rental the discount can disappear.
So the test belongs at every renewal, not only at purchase. The renewal rate increase checker helps spot a change.
Claims and nonrenewal effects
Bundling ties two policies to one insurer, which changes what a claim on either can do.
- Home claims can affect your auto price and vice versa. The Texas Department of Insurance says on its claims and premiums page (checked November 2026) that "your home and auto premiums can go up if you file claims," and that you could lose claim-free discounts. A bundle puts both in one underwriter's view. See CLUE reports and home claim history in a bundle quote.
- Claims history is shared across insurers. The TDI explanation of the CLUE report, the database that shows claims on homes and cars for the past seven years, says it can show claims filed with other insurers, so a bundle is not the only way your claims reach a new underwriter.
- Nonrenewal can affect both policies. If an insurer decides not to renew one policy, ask whether it will renew the other and at what price. New York's Department of Financial Services states in its automobile FAQ (checked November 2026) that nonrenewal notices must be mailed 45 to 60 days before expiration and that each year an insurer may non-renew up to 2% of its non-commercial policies in each rating territory plus one policy for every two new policies written. That is a New York rule on auto policies; other states and lines differ.
The same page lists a multi-policy or account discount among available discounts but gives no eligibility details or savings. A state regulator's list of available discounts is a place to confirm that the discount exists in your state, not what it is worth.
A testing method: separate versus bundle
Run this before you buy, and again at each renewal. It takes about an hour with quotes from three to five insurers. The car insurance quote comparison worksheet holds the numbers, and how to compare car insurance quotes apples to apples explains how to keep coverage identical.
- Fix the coverages. Write down the liability limits, UM, deductibles and home coverage amounts and deductible you want. Use identical values in every quote.
- Collect bundled quotes. From each of at least three insurers, get a quote for auto plus home with the discount applied. Record the total for the same term and payment method.
- Collect standalone quotes. From the same insurers and from others, get auto-only and home-only quotes. Ask each whether the auto-only price already includes any other discount.
- Compute the cheapest separate pair. Pick the lowest auto quote and the lowest home quote, even if from different companies. Add them.
- Compare the totals. If the best bundle total is lower than the best separate pair, the bundle wins. If not, the gap is what you pay for convenience.
- Price the extras. Add fees, installment charges and any coverage differences. Subtract the value of features you would actually use.
- Ask the renewal question. Ask each insurer for the rate-change history of both policies, or look at its filings using the TDI-style search above where available.
- Repeat at renewal. Re-run steps 2 through 5 with the renewal offer in hand.
Worked example (hypothetical numbers)
All figures below are defined for illustration and are not quotes. A household gets the following annual prices.
| Insurer | Auto alone | Home alone | Bundle total (discount applied) |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | $1,400 | $2,300 | $3,330 |
| B | $1,500 | $2,000 | $3,260 |
| C | $1,250 | $2,600 | $3,500 |
Insurer B's bundle ($3,260) beats A's and C's bundles. The cheapest separate pair is auto at C ($1,250) plus home at B ($2,000), $3,250. Separate is $10 cheaper than the best bundle, which is too small to justify two renewals and two claims contacts, so the household might choose B's bundle. If instead C's auto were $1,100, the separate pair would be $3,100, which is $160 below B's bundle, and separate would win. The rule is the comparison, not the percentage.
The break-even calculation is covered in bundle break-even: how high can the home price go before you lose.
Common questions
Is the bundle discount the same everywhere?
No. Progressive's page says its auto savings apply in most states and not all, and State Farm's footnote says percentages and eligibility vary by state. The 2015 study also found different discounts by state and bundle type.
Do I need to bundle with the same company?
Usually the discount requires the same insurer or an affiliated company. The article bundles through partner carriers: when two insurers sell one package explains partner packages.
Can I keep the discount if I drop one policy?
Not under the terms State Farm describes: the discount for two or more lines does not apply if you buy only one policy.
Does bundling raise the risk of losing both policies?
It concentrates exposure with one insurer. Ask each insurer how it handles a nonrenewal on one policy.
Key takeaways
- Published bundle figures come from marketing pages and surveys of customers who switched, so they are not a promise for your household.
- Separate policies win when either company's base price is uncompetitive by more than the discount.
- The discount can drift away at renewal as rates change on each policy or as you drop one.
- The reliable answer is a test: the best bundle total against the cheapest separate pair, repeated at every renewal.
Sources
- Progressive: Bundle home and auto insurance, supports the 5% average on auto, the 25% survey claim, footnote limits and the one-deductible condition, checked November 2026
- State Farm: Bundle home and auto insurance, supports the "up to $1,429" claim, its survey basis and the one-policy footnote, checked November 2026
- Insurance Business: Northeast states offer only modest discounts in insurance bundling, supports the 2015 Quadrant study figures by state and bundle type, checked November 2026
- Texas Department of Insurance: Home and auto insurance rate filings, supports that rates are filed before use and searchable, with documents in SERFF, checked November 2026
- Texas Department of Insurance: Will my premium go up if I file a claim?, supports the effect of claims on home and auto premiums and discounts, checked November 2026
- Texas Department of Insurance: Get a free CLUE about your insurance claims history, supports the seven-year CLUE record across insurers, checked November 2026
- New York DFS: Automobile insurance consumer FAQ, supports the multi-policy discount listing and the nonrenewal notice and 2% rule, checked November 2026