Blog
Apples-to-apples bundle quotes: a checklist for honest comparisons
A field-by-field checklist for matching auto and home or renters quotes across carriers, with what a declarations page shows and hides, and a table to fill in.
Two bundle quotes are comparable only when the limits, deductibles, valuation basis and optional coverages match on both the auto and the home side. A quote that is $300 cheaper because it has a $2,500 deductible and actual cash value on the roof is a different product, not a better price. The way to match them is to decide the coverage once, send the same list to every company, and read the declarations page of each quote against that list.
This article gives the list, field by field, for auto and for home or renters, explains what a declarations page shows and what it leaves out, and ends with a table you can copy. The coverage descriptions rely on the Texas Department of Insurance consumer guides and the NAIC's homeowners shopping tool, read in November 2026. Policy wording and available options vary by company and state, so treat the fields as prompts, not a complete list for your policy.
Decide your coverage before you ask for a price
A quote tool will choose defaults for you, and defaults differ. Before you request any bundle quote, write down the coverage you want. The NAIC's homeowners shopping tool recommends the same discipline: choose a coverage limit based on the estimated cost to rebuild, not on the purchase price or market value, and note that quotes are estimates of the premium for a particular coverage with a particular insurer (NAIC homeowners shopping tool). Its worksheet has room to compare offers from three companies side by side, and its text says it is a good idea to get at least three quotes.
Start from your current declarations pages for auto and home. They are the best record of what you have now. If you are changing coverage on purpose, mark each change so you can price it separately. how to read your car insurance declarations page explains the page, and use your declarations page as the script for every new quote shows how to use it to dictate a quote.
The auto checklist
The Texas Department of Insurance describes the main auto coverages and says the first page of a policy, the declarations page, summarizes your coverages, dollar limits and deductibles (TDI auto insurance guide). Match every line below.
Liability limits
Written as three numbers (bodily injury per person, per accident, and property damage). A quote with 50/100/50 and one with 100/300/100 are not the same product. Use liability limits decoder if the notation is new. Also check whether the limit is split or a combined single limit.
Deductibles
Collision and comprehensive deductibles are separate. TDI notes that you pay a deductible on collision, comprehensive and uninsured or underinsured motorist claims, and that liability and several other coverages instead have dollar limits (TDI auto insurance guide). Some insurers carry a separate glass deductible or none at all, so note that too.
Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage
TDI explains that this coverage pays if you are hit by a driver who had no insurance or not enough, or in a hit-and-run, that insurers must offer it, and that declining it requires a written statement in Texas. The limits and whether the coverage includes property damage vary by state and by quote. Match the limits, not just the presence of the line. See uninsured motorist coverage.
Rental reimbursement and towing
TDI describes rental reimbursement as paying for a rental car if yours is stolen or being repaired after an accident, and towing and labor as paying for a tow and for labor to change a flat or jump-start. Both are optional and have limits: a daily rental cap and a number of days, a dollar limit for towing. A quote that shows "included" without the cap has told you nothing. Ask for the numbers.
Medical payments, personal injury protection and optional items
If you have these, match them. Also compare any endorsements, such as gap coverage for a financed car, accident forgiveness or new car replacement. Differences in these are common between bundle quotes because the default package of each company differs, a pattern pre-checked add-ons and defaults that inflate an online quote describes.
Drivers, vehicles, mileage and use
A difference in the driver list, annual mileage or garaging address changes the price. If one quote omits a household member or lists a lower mileage, it is not comparable. Give the same VIN, drivers, mileage and use to every company.
The home checklist
TDI says most Texas home policies include six coverages: dwelling, personal property, other structures, additional living expenses, personal liability and medical payments (TDI home insurance guide). The NAIC tool lists the same family and adds optional extensions. Match each.
Dwelling limit
Coverage A pays to repair or rebuild the house. TDI says most companies require you to insure it for at least 80% of replacement cost, and some require 100%. Different companies estimate rebuilding cost differently, so the NAIC tool says that if you get more than one quote you will also get more than one estimate of the cost to rebuild. Pick one number, based on a builder's or an appraiser's estimate, and ask every company to quote that dwelling limit.
Valuation: replacement cost or actual cash value
This is the field with the largest effect on what a claim pays. TDI's example: a roof is replaced after a storm; replacement cost coverage pays today's price for a new roof, while actual cash value pays replacement cost minus depreciation, so with a $2,000 deductible the insurer in its example pays $5,000 on a $10,000 roof whose actual cash value is $7,000. The NAIC tool lays out a ladder of levels for the dwelling: actual cash value, functional replacement cost, replacement cost, extended replacement cost and guaranteed replacement cost, and says that many replacement cost policies pay only actual cash value until repairs begin or are complete. Ask which level each quote uses, and whether the roof is on a different basis.
Personal property basis
Contents can be covered at actual cash value or at replacement cost. The NAIC tool notes that the two differ in what a claim pays and that replacement cost premiums are likely higher. A quote that is cheaper because contents are on actual cash value is cheaper for a reason.
Other structures, loss of use and liability
TDI defines other structures as detached buildings such as a garage, shed or fence. Additional living expenses, called loss of use, pays rent and other extra costs while the house is repaired. Personal liability pays when you are legally responsible for injury or damage. Match the limits, and match the medical payments limit. The NAIC tool lists liability and medical payments on its worksheet.
Deductibles
Home policies can have a flat dollar deductible, a percentage deductible, a separate wind or hail deductible, and a separate roof deductible, all of which the NAIC worksheet names. A percentage deductible is a share of the dwelling limit, so a 2% deductible on a $400,000 dwelling is $8,000. Ask for the dollar amount of each.
Water backup, ordinance or law and other options
The NAIC worksheet lists optional coverages to ask about: sewer, drain and sump pump backup, ordinance or law (which it describes as paying the extra cost to rebuild to updated codes), equipment breakdown, and increased limits for jewelry, firearms and art. These are commonly priced add-ons rather than defaults. Compare them one by one, and see auditing your add-ons: which endorsements to keep, drop or add for deciding which you want.
Renters and condo policies
For a renters bundle, the fields shrink but do not disappear: personal property limit and basis, liability, medical payments, loss of use, and deductible. A condo policy adds the building-items coverage and the interaction with the association's master policy, which Condo owners: the HOA master policy, your HO-6 and the auto bundle explains. bundling renters and auto insurance covers the renters case in a guide.
What a declarations page shows and what it hides
The declarations page is the best single document for a comparison because it lists coverages, limits and deductibles in one place. TDI describes it as the first page of the policy and a summary. It is a summary, and it has limits as a comparison tool.
It shows: the named insured and the address, the policy period, each coverage with its limit and deductible, the premium by coverage, and a list of forms and endorsements by number.
It does not show:
- How a term is defined. The NAIC tool warns that each insurance company may define terms differently in the policy and says to ask the agent about differences in definitions. A peril or an exclusion lives in the policy form, not on the declarations page.
- What an endorsement does. An endorsement listed as a form number may expand or restrict coverage, and the page may not say how.
- Settlement conditions. Whether replacement cost is paid up front or after repairs are made is a policy provision. The NAIC tool lists it as a question to ask.
- Underwriting conditions. A quote may be subject to inspection or verification, which a declarations page may not mention until later. conditional bundle quotes: how a home inspection can undo the discount covers the problem.
- The multi-policy credit in dollars. Some pages list it by coverage, others fold it into the premium. Ask for it separately.
To close the gap, ask each company for the policy form numbers and read the definitions of the items that matter to you. how to read the auto policy contract, not just the declarations page explains how to read the contract.
Get the quotes in the same week, with standalone prices
Quotes expire and prices move. A quote from three weeks ago may not be available now, and it may have been built on data the company has since changed. Get all bundle quotes within the same week, state the same effective date to every company, and note each quote's expiry. how long a car insurance quote is good for and what changes it explains typical windows.
Ask every bundling company for four prices: auto with the bundle, home with the bundle, auto alone and home alone. The standalone prices show the discount in dollars, and they let you test whether the bundle beats your best separate quotes; see bundle break-even: how high can the home price go before you lose. Progressive's bundle page says its discount is applied to the auto policy and that coverage and discounts are not available in all states and situations (Progressive bundle page), and State Farm's page says that if you buy only one policy the multi-line discount does not apply (State Farm homeowners page). The standalone number tells you what you lose if you ever drop one policy.
Ask the eligibility questions up front
The NAIC tool lists questions worth asking before you pay for a quote: whether the company will insure you if you had a prior home claim, if the house had a claim under the previous owner, if you have a dog, a pool, a trampoline or solar panels, whether the insurer will visit and photograph the home before or after insuring it, and whether it looks at credit. The answers decide whether the quote you are shown is the quote you will get. If you plan to cancel an existing policy to take a bundle, read the sequencing advice in conditional bundle quotes: how a home inspection can undo the discount first.
Record effective dates and cancellation steps
Once you choose, write down the following before you cancel anything:
- The effective date and time of each new policy, and a copy of its declarations page or binder.
- The expiry of each old policy and the cancellation method the company requires.
- The refund rule. TDI says that when either you or the company cancels, the company must refund any unearned premium within 15 days after the cancellation date (TDI auto insurance guide). Other states have different rules, and some insurers apply a short-rate penalty, a topic short-rate vs pro-rata refunds: what switching mid-term really costs covers.
- Whether a lienholder or mortgage lender must be told. TDI notes that if you cancel collision and comprehensive on a financed car, the lender will buy expensive single-interest coverage and add the cost to your loan payment.
- The first date by which you must have the new policy to avoid a gap. TDI advises getting a new policy before the old one ends so you do not have a lapse in liability coverage.
overlap days when switching: pay twice or risk a gap? explains why a day or two of overlap can be worth the cost.
A table to fill in
Copy this table for each company. Mark mismatches in the last column and requote until none remain.
| Field | Your target | Company A | Company B | Company C |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quote date and expiry | same week | |||
| Legal name of auto insurer | ||||
| Legal name of home insurer | ||||
| Auto liability limits | ||||
| Collision / comprehensive deductible | ||||
| Uninsured / underinsured limits | ||||
| Rental reimbursement (daily cap, days) | ||||
| Towing and roadside limit | ||||
| Auto optional endorsements | ||||
| Dwelling limit | ||||
| Dwelling basis (RC / ACV / roof schedule) | ||||
| Personal property limit and basis | ||||
| Other structures | ||||
| Loss of use | ||||
| Liability and medical payments | ||||
| Home deductible(s), dollars | ||||
| Water backup | ||||
| Ordinance or law | ||||
| Auto price with bundle | ||||
| Home price with bundle | ||||
| Auto price alone | ||||
| Home price alone | ||||
| Conditions (inspection, verification) | ||||
| Mismatch notes |
Common questions
Do I need to compare the same company's home form number?
Not exactly, but you need the same level of protection. Ask each company which policy form it is quoting and which perils it covers. The NAIC tool describes the common forms, from basic to comprehensive, and the HO-3 special form is the most common.
What if a company will not quote my chosen deductible?
Ask what it offers and requote the others at that deductible, or note the difference in dollars. Do not drop the field from the comparison.
Is a lower price with a higher deductible a worse quote?
Not automatically. A higher deductible can lower the premium, as the NAIC advises, if you can pay it. It is a different bargain, and the table should show both.
Who can help if a quote and policy differ?
Your state insurance department takes complaints and answers general questions. Texas has a TDI help line, and every state lists its own contact on its department website.
Key takeaways
- Decide the coverage first, then send identical specifications to every company.
- The fields with the biggest effect are the dwelling limit, the valuation basis, deductible type and the auto liability limits.
- A declarations page summarizes coverage but not definitions, endorsement wording, settlement conditions or underwriting conditions.
- Get quotes the same week, and ask for standalone prices as well as bundle prices.
- Record effective dates, refund rules and lender notices before cancelling anything.
Sources
- NAIC: Homeowners shopping tool, rebuild-cost limit, comparison worksheet, replacement cost levels, definitions and questions to ask (a version with reviewer comments), checked November 2026
- Texas Department of Insurance: Auto insurance guide, auto coverages, deductibles, declarations page, refunds and lender notice, checked November 2026
- Texas Department of Insurance: Home insurance guide, the six home coverages, replacement cost example and 80% rule, checked November 2026
- Progressive: Bundle home and auto, how the discount is applied and its availability limits, checked November 2026
- State Farm: Homeowners insurance, the single-policy footnote, checked November 2026
- NAIC: Searching for a homeowners insurance policy? Tips to get the most value, compare price and coverage, ask about discounts, checked November 2026