Blog

ISO and advisory organizations: how shared loss data shapes rates

Who supplies the shared loss costs and vehicle symbols behind many car insurance prices, why regulators allow it, and why quotes still differ.

Many car insurers do not build their prices from nothing. They buy or adopt industry-wide statistics from an advisory organization, most prominently Insurance Services Office (ISO, a Verisk company), which collects claim data from insurers and publishes advisory loss costs, vehicle rating symbols, forms and rating rules. Each insurer then adds its own expenses, profit and judgment, and files the result with the state. Regulators allow the sharing because the federal McCarran-Ferguson Act leaves insurance regulation to the states and the advisory organizations are themselves licensed and examined by those states.

The result is that two insurers can start from the same data and still quote you very different prices. This article explains what the shared data is, how it reaches your premium, what the law permits, the one state that works very differently, and what it means for how you shop.

What an advisory organization does

An advisory organization collects statistics from insurers, compiles them, and offers back industry-level analysis that individual insurers can use. A multistate market conduct examination of ISO, adopted by the Alaska Division of Insurance in December 2013 and covering January 2007 through December 2011, gives the clearest public description we found. According to that report (checked November 2026):

  • ISO Data, Inc. provides "statistical agent services" to the property and casualty industry and makes statistical submissions to regulators.
  • Insurance Services Office, Inc. prepares and files advisory prospective loss costs, forms and manuals of rating rules for many lines, including personal and commercial auto, homeowners and others.
  • ISO was formed on April 1, 1971 through the consolidation of state, regional and national rating bureaus, and "by 1989" it was making advisory loss costs instead of advisory rates. By 1997 it had become an independent for-profit corporation, and Verisk Analytics became its parent in 2008.
  • Its functions include helping insurers "determine their own independent premium rates."

Verisk's own product sheet, ISO's advisory prospective loss costs (a 2019 document, checked November 2026), describes the product this way: loss costs "use historical data" to "project average future claim costs and loss adjustment expenses," broken out by coverage, class and territory, and "submitted to state regulators for review."

Loss costs versus rates

The distinction matters. A loss cost is the part of the price meant to pay claims and the expense of adjusting them. It excludes the insurer's own overhead, commissions, taxes and profit. A rate includes all of those. The older practice was for bureaus to publish full advisory rates that members used. The shift to loss costs, which the exam report places by 1989, left each insurer to supply its own expense and profit assumptions, usually as a multiplier applied to the loss cost. The related blog article loss-cost states: how advisory loss costs turn into your actual rate explains the multiplier, and Verisk (ISO) advisory loss costs: the data behind many insurers' rates covers the products in more depth; this article focuses on the regulatory framework and on what it means for shoppers.

How the shared data reaches your premium

Shared statistics show up in two places on your policy: the base cost of coverage in your territory and class, and the factor tied to your car.

Vehicle rating symbols

Verisk's FAQ on ISO symbols (checked November 2026) explains the program. For each vehicle within a vehicle series, defined by make, model and body style, Verisk assigns a Rating Symbol, and "a vehicle with a higher Rating Symbol will have a higher premium than a vehicle with a lower Symbol if all other rating variables are the same." There are two kinds:

  • Physical damage symbols for comprehensive and collision, set per model year. Verisk starts with a price-new symbol based solely on the manufacturer's suggested retail price, then adjusts it up or down using actual loss experience for the vehicle series.
  • Liability and PIP/medical payments symbols set per vehicle series, built from the series' actual loss experience plus a predicted loss ratio relativity from a model that uses factors such as curb weight and chassis type.

The FAQ states that symbols are advisory: "Insurers may use them without modification, modify them, or choose not to use them." It also explains why two cars with similar sticker prices can carry different symbols: some are stolen more, crash more or cost more to repair, and repair cost can matter more than replacement cost because most collision claims end in repair.

The New York Department of Financial Services notes on its page on factors impacting physical damage coverage premiums (checked November 2026) that ISO revised its program from 27 symbols to 75 symbols for 2011 and later model years, with separate collision and comprehensive symbols, and that higher symbol numbers reflect greater claim cost and therefore higher premiums. See vehicle safety ratings and insurance costs for how safety and theft data enter the picture from other sources.

Territory and class

Loss costs are published by coverage, territory and class, as the Verisk sheet says. territory rating is the glossary entry for the territory piece; a ZIP code or rating territory in your policy is one of the rating factors that can start from shared data. An insurer that uses ISO's territories and class codes without change would, all else equal, price you the way its peers do on those pieces.

What the insurer adds

Between the shared loss cost and the price on your declarations page sit the insurer's own choices:

  1. Expense and profit load. The multiplier covers overhead, commissions, taxes and target profit.
  2. Its own experience. An insurer with a large book may blend its claim data with the industry's, in a process actuaries call credibility weighting.
  3. Its own rating variables. Tiers, discounts and surcharges, and any variables not in the shared manual.
  4. Underwriting rules. Which risks it accepts at all (see underwriting).

The hypothetical below uses numbers we define, to show why the same loss cost can lead to different prices. Suppose the shared loss cost for a coverage in your territory is $600 a year. Insurer A files a multiplier of 1.30 and Insurer B files 1.45, because B spends more on agent commissions and aims for a higher margin. Before any other factor, A would charge $780 and B $870. The gap has nothing to do with you. It comes from each company's costs and strategy.

Why regulators and the law allow joint data

There are two layers: federal antitrust law and state insurance law.

Federal. Under the McCarran-Ferguson Act, 15 U.S.C. section 1012 says that "the business of insurance ... shall be subject to the laws of the several States which relate to the regulation or taxation of such business," and no Act of Congress is construed to invalidate or supersede a state law regulating insurance unless it specifically relates to insurance. The federal antitrust statutes (the Sherman, Clayton and Federal Trade Commission Acts) apply to the business of insurance only "to the extent that such business is not regulated by State Law." Section 1013 adds that the Sherman Act still reaches "any agreement to boycott, coerce, or intimidate, or act of boycott, coercion, or intimidation." The result is a limited exemption, not blanket immunity: gathering and sharing data under state regulation is within it, while agreements to boycott or coerce are not. For the history, see Why insurance is regulated by states, not Washington.

State. The ISO examination was run by the NAIC's Advisory Organization Examination Oversight Working Group under state direction, with New Jersey, Maine and New York as lead states, to validate that the organization was "performing its permitted regulated functions in a manner consistent with state laws and regulations." The report reviewed whether ISO has written policies to prohibit anticompetitive practices, noting that ISO "receives proprietary data from its statistical reporting insurers" and that it is essential to keep controls that prevent anything that "might limit or prevent competition." It also tested a sample of ten loss cost filings against actuarial standards. The Alaska exam covers 2007 to 2011, so check for newer examinations when you rely on this point. See The NAIC explained for how the NAIC organizes such work.

The reason for the arrangement is a practical one. A small insurer with a few thousand policies cannot produce statistically credible claim data for every vehicle and territory on its own. Pooled statistics give it a starting point. The NAIC does not choose prices, and nothing in the sources above requires an insurer to adopt an advisory loss cost.

The contrast: North Carolina's rate bureau

Most states treat the advisory loss cost as optional. North Carolina is different. Under G.S. 58-36-1 (checked November 2026), the legislature created the North Carolina Rate Bureau, and the Bureau "shall promulgate and propose rates" for private passenger vehicle coverages, including theft and physical damage, liability, medical payments and uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage. G.S. 58-36-15 says the Bureau files rates, loss costs and classification plans with the Commissioner of Insurance, that a filing takes effect on its specified date "not earlier than 210 days" after receipt, and that filings are open to public inspection on submission. G.S. 58-36-10 requires the Bureau to review its motor vehicle classification rates at least once every three years and nonfleet private passenger territories at least once every 10 years.

The statutes we opened do not say whether members may deviate from the Bureau's rates, so we do not state that here; the North Carolina Department of Insurance can answer. The blog article North Carolina's rate bureau and Reinsurance Facility: a system apart covers the bureau and the state's backstop market in more detail, and North Carolina is the state profile. The point for this article is the structure: in North Carolina a statutory bureau proposes rates for the state and the Commissioner reviews them in public, while elsewhere each insurer files its own.

Large insurers and proprietary data

Some large insurers rely less on shared products. A 10-K is a useful primary source because the company has to describe its own methods. The Progressive Corporation's annual report on Form 10-K for 2017 (an older filing, so confirm against the latest one) says the company seeks "to refine our personal auto segmentation, underwriting models, and pricing over time," and describes a product that "expands our use of prior claims information, adds billing and vehicle history segmentation, and expands our tiering mechanisms." That is a description of the company's own models, not a statement that it uses no shared data. We did not find a source stating which advisory products any particular insurer uses, and filings are where to look: an insurer's rate filing normally says what loss costs or manuals it relies on. How to read a car insurance rate filing on SERFF shows how to read one.

Even so, the same principle applies to everyone: an insurer pays for claims and a price must be filed in each state, so every price in the market can be traced to some combination of shared statistics and the insurer's own data.

Why quotes still differ widely

Shared data does not produce uniform prices, for several reasons you can check on your own quotes:

  • Different multipliers and expense loads, as in the hypothetical above.
  • Different tier structures and discount sizes. See reading a rate filing to see how big a discount really is.
  • Different appetite. One insurer may want young drivers or older cars and price accordingly; another may not.
  • Different use of factors outside the shared manual, such as claims history, driving data or credit-based scores where states allow them.
  • Different loss experience of their own book.

For the same driver and car, you can expect a spread. We do not state a typical dollar spread because we did not open a study measuring it; get your own quotes.

How to use this when you shop

  1. Get quotes from at least three insurers that price differently. One that leans on shared loss costs and one with heavily proprietary segmentation will weight your characteristics differently. Include a regional or specialty insurer if one sells in your state.
  2. Keep the coverage identical. Same limits, deductibles, add-ons, and term length. The car insurance quote comparison worksheet and how to compare car insurance quotes apples to apples show how.
  3. Look at your vehicle symbol effect. If you are choosing a car, the physical damage symbol is part of why two similarly priced models cost different amounts to insure. Ask for a quote on the specific VIN before you buy.
  4. Re-shop when something changes. A new car, address or driver changes which pieces of shared data apply.
  5. Ask the question directly. "Does your rate for this vehicle use a published rating symbol, and has it changed since my last renewal?" An agent may not know; the filing will.

Common questions

Is ISO a regulator?

No. It is a private company that serves as a licensed advisory organization and statistical agent. The NAIC and state departments regulate and examine it, as the multistate examination describes.

Do all insurers have to use ISO loss costs?

No. Verisk describes its symbols as advisory, and its examination report describes functions that help insurers set their "own independent" rates. Insurers can use, modify or ignore them. North Carolina's statutory rate bureau is a different arrangement.

Is sharing loss data price fixing?

Sharing historical data under state supervision is within the limited McCarran-Ferguson exemption; agreements to boycott, coerce or intimidate are not. A licensed attorney can address a specific legal question.

Why does my car's rating symbol matter?

According to Verisk, a higher symbol means a higher premium for physical damage when all other rating variables are equal, and symbols are set from price, loss experience and, for liability, a predictive model.

Key takeaways

  • ISO, a Verisk company, is a licensed advisory organization and statistical agent that publishes advisory loss costs, vehicle symbols and rating rules; insurers may use, modify or ignore them.
  • Loss costs cover claims only; each insurer adds its own expenses and profit, which is why prices differ even from the same starting point.
  • McCarran-Ferguson leaves insurance regulation to the states and gives a limited antitrust exemption; the ISO examination shows states supervising the process.
  • North Carolina uses a statutory rate bureau that proposes rates, unlike most states.
  • Compare at least one insurer built on its own data against one that leans on shared loss costs, with identical coverage.

Sources

Terms used in this guide

Related insurers

Related states

Related guides

Related tools

Latest on this topic