Blog

Per-person vs per-accident limits: worked crash examples

With 50/100/50 coverage, one badly hurt person is capped at $50,000, not $100,000. Seven numbered crash examples show where the money stops.

If you carry 50/100/50 and one person is badly hurt, your insurer pays at most $50,000 for that person, even though the policy shows $100,000 per accident. The second number only matters when two or more people are injured, and it is always subject to the first. Property damage to other people's cars and fences comes out of the third number, a separate pot, and any amount above a limit is what the at-fault driver can be asked to pay personally.

That is the whole mechanism. The rest of this article puts numbers through it in seven crash scenarios, so you can see where the money stops. The dollar amounts in the scenarios are hypothetical figures I chose to make the arithmetic visible; they are not averages or predictions. The policy language comes from two real contracts, and the scale of real injury costs comes from federal and industry studies, all cited below and checked in November 2026.

How to read 50/100/50

A split limit has three numbers. The liability limits decoder tool and the guide what 25/50/25 means: split liability limits explained explain the format; in short, 50/100/50 means $50,000 of bodily injury liability for each person, $100,000 for each accident, and $50,000 of property damage liability for each accident.

Two published policy contracts show how the insurers word it. Progressive's Nevada auto policy (form 9611D NV, edition 01/16, hosted by the Nevada Division of Insurance) says that when the declarations page shows a split limit, "the amount shown for 'each person' is the most we will pay for all damages due to bodily injury to one person resulting from any one accident"; "subject to the 'each person' limit, the amount shown for 'each accident' is the most we will pay for all damages due to bodily injury sustained by two or more persons in any one accident"; and the property damage amount is "the most we will pay for the total of all property damage resulting from any one accident" (Progressive Nevada Auto Policy 9611D NV (01/16), checked November 2026). An AAA Oklahoma sample policy form (AA01 OK PP A, posted by the Oklahoma Insurance Department) uses nearly identical words (AAA Oklahoma sample policy, checked November 2026).

Three phrases do the work:

  1. "Subject to the each person limit." The per-accident figure is a ceiling on the total, not a pool that any one person can draw from.
  2. "All damages." Medical bills, lost wages and pain and suffering all count against the same per-person cap.
  3. The limit holds regardless of the number of claims. The AAA form lists things that do not raise the limit: more claims, more covered vehicles, more insured people, more lawsuits or more vehicles involved. A second lawsuit does not buy a second $50,000.

Amica's liability page describes the common 100/300/100 shape the same way: $100,000 per person, $300,000 per accident for bodily injury, and $100,000 for property damage, which "can help cover multiple injured people up to $100,000 each for a maximum of $300,000 total" (Amica: What does auto liability insurance cover?, checked November 2026). Notice the same ceiling: $100,000 each, and no more than $300,000 combined.

Scenario 1: one catastrophic injury

A driver you hit has a spinal injury. Say a court or settlement puts the total damages at $400,000.

  • Your bodily injury limit for one person: $50,000.
  • The insurer's maximum payment: $50,000.
  • The per-accident limit of $100,000 is not available, because only one person was hurt. The other $50,000 goes unused.
  • Left over: $350,000 that the policy does not pay.

That leftover is the central risk of low limits. The Texas Department of Insurance states plainly that if you do not have enough liability coverage to pay for the damages and injuries you cause, you might have to pay the rest yourself, and the other driver could sue you (Texas Department of Insurance: Consumer guide to auto insurance, checked November 2026). The same page notes that Texas requires at least $30,000 per person, $60,000 per accident and $25,000 for property damage (30/60/25). For what happens after a judgment above limits, see what happens when damages exceed your liability limits.

Scenario 2: two injured people, one far worse

Two people are hurt. Person A's damages are $90,000. Person B's are $10,000.

  • Person A is capped at $50,000 by the per-person limit.
  • Person B receives $10,000, well under the cap.
  • Total paid: $60,000. The $100,000 accident limit is not reached, yet Person A is $40,000 short.

A common surprise is that the unused $40,000 of per-accident room cannot be moved to Person A. The cap follows each person, not the pot.

Scenario 3: four injured people, a total that exceeds the pot

Four passengers in the other car each have $40,000 in damages, $160,000 in all.

  • Each person's claim is under the $50,000 per-person cap, so none is cut by that limit.
  • The per-accident limit is $100,000, which is less than $160,000.
  • The insurer cannot pay more than $100,000 for bodily injury in total.

How that $100,000 is divided is a negotiation and a legal question, and the answer varies by state and circumstance. As one simple illustration only, a proportional split would pay each person $25,000, which is $100,000 divided by four, or 62.5 percent of each claim. Real settlements can differ. The article how insurers split limited coverage among several injured claimants covers the rules and the practical problems. The lesson for limit-shopping is that a per-accident limit of $100,000 is thin when four people are hurt.

Scenario 4: family members and "derivative" claims

A husband is injured and has $60,000 in medical bills and wage loss. His wife also claims $20,000 for loss of consortium, the loss of his companionship and services. Does she get her own $50,000 per-person limit?

Under the wording of both published contracts, no. The Progressive Nevada form says the per-person limit "applies to the total of all claims made for bodily injury to a person and all claims of others derived from such bodily injury," including emotional distress from witnessing the injury, loss of society, loss of companionship, loss of services, loss of consortium and wrongful death. The AAA Oklahoma sample says the same in nearly identical words. So the husband's $60,000 and the wife's $20,000 sit under one $50,000 cap: $80,000 of claims, $50,000 of coverage.

This rule can matter in a fatal crash, where the estate's and relatives' claims may all trace to one person's death. Other states and some policies may treat this differently (the wording is policy-specific), so read your own contract and ask the insurer. See fatal crashes and liability limits: wrongful death claims explained for more.

Scenario 5: property damage is a separate pot

You hit a parked SUV, a fence and a utility pole in one accident. The SUV needs $38,000 in repairs. The fence is $4,000 and the utility's bill for the pole is $18,000.

  • Property damage claims total $60,000.
  • Your property damage limit is $50,000 per accident, regardless of the number of vehicles or objects.
  • Left over: $10,000.

Property damage and bodily injury are separate limits. A $50,000 property damage limit does not borrow from the unused bodily injury room, and the bodily injury limits do not pay for the SUV. The same thing happens in reverse: an expensive repair does not reduce what an injured person can claim. For more on why this limit can run short, see why property damage limits fall short in today's crashes.

Scenario 6: a passenger in your own car

Your friend is a passenger in your car when you cause a crash and is injured. Does your own liability coverage pay your friend?

Whether your own liability coverage pays depends on the policy and your state. The AAA Oklahoma sample, for example, excludes bodily injury to "you or a relative" to the extent damages exceed the minimum limits required by Oklahoma law, which means a household member's claim would be limited to that minimum even if you bought higher limits. A friend who does not live with you is not described by that exclusion. Other policies may word it differently. The in-depth answer is in can passengers and family members claim on your liability coverage?. When you shop, ask: "Is there any household or family exclusion that lowers the limit for my own relatives?"

Your own medical bills and those of your passengers may also be addressed by other coverages such as medical payments or personal injury protection, and the Progressive Nevada form says it will not pay under liability any expenses paid under its medical payments coverage. That is another reason to read the whole contract, not just the limits.

Scenario 7: the cost of defending the lawsuit

The injured driver sues you. The insurer hires a defense lawyer, and the case takes two years.

Under both published contracts, defense costs do not reduce your limits. The Progressive form's "Additional Payments" section says that "in addition to our limit of liability" the insurer will pay for an insured person all expenses it incurs in the settlement of any claim or defense of any lawsuit; interest accruing after entry of judgment until the insurer has paid, offered to pay or deposited its limit; the premium on appeal or attachment bonds in a lawsuit it defends; up to $250 for a bail bond; and reasonable expenses incurred at its request, including loss of earnings up to $200 per day. The AAA sample contains the same list. These are examples from two specific forms; they are not a guarantee that every policy is written the same way.

So the $50,000 for one person is not eroded by attorney fees. But when the insurer has paid its limit, the other terms of the contract and state law control what happens next, including how long the defense lasts. See sued after a crash: how your insurer's duty to defend works. Note also that the Progressive form says it has "no duty to purchase a bond in an amount exceeding our limit of liability."

How big can injuries get?

The point of the scenarios is that the amounts are plausible. Two studies give a scale.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration's 2019 study of crash costs reports average economic cost per injured person by severity on the Abbreviated Injury Scale (MAIS), in 2019 dollars: about $19,344 for a minor injury (MAIS1), $71,419 for a moderate injury (MAIS2), $280,726 for a serious injury (MAIS3), $675,727 for a severe injury (MAIS4) and $979,328 for a critical injury (MAIS5), and $1.6 million for each fatality (NHTSA, The Economic and Societal Impact of Motor Vehicle Crashes, 2019 (Revised), DOT HS 813 403, checked November 2026). Those averages cover costs to society, including lost workplace and household productivity, and are not what a liability insurer pays on a given claim. But they show that an average moderate injury already exceeds a $50,000 per-person limit.

The Insurance Research Council reported on July 30, 2026 that the average bodily injury claim payment rose from approximately $14,000 in 2017 to more than $20,000 in 2022, based on more than 7.4 million claims closed with payment (Insurance Research Council press release, July 30, 2026, checked November 2026). The IRC is supported by insurers, and its average is dominated by many small claims; it says little about the tail. Both facts can be true: most claims fit inside ordinary limits, and a minority of serious ones do not. You buy liability limits for the tail.

The article 100/300/100 vs 250/500/100: what the extra limits buy compares higher limit tiers, and how much liability coverage do you need? helps with the exposure side.

What the next limit step costs

I did not find a published, sourced price for each limit step, and prices vary by company, state, driver and vehicle, so any dollar amount for a real premium here would be invented. A hypothetical shows how to think about it.

Suppose three quotes for the same driver show $1,200 a year at 50/100/50, $1,320 at 100/300/100 and $1,480 at 250/500/100. These numbers are mine, for illustration. Moving from 50/100/50 to 100/300/100 adds $120 a year and doubles the per-person protection and triples the per-accident protection. Moving on to 250/500/100 adds $160 more and raises the per-person cap from $100,000 to $250,000. Whether that is worth it depends on your assets and income at risk. The article why doubling liability limits does not double the premium explains why doubling a limit does not double the premium. Ask each insurer for real quotes rather than relying on any estimate.

Above the highest auto limit you can buy, an umbrella policy adds liability on top of the underlying limits. Ask whether it requires minimum underlying limits such as 250/500/100.

Limit combinations to request on every quote

When you ask for quotes, ask for the same set from each company so you can compare them. Use the car insurance quote comparison worksheet to record them.

  1. Your current limits (for the baseline).
  2. 100/300/100. Amica's page notes that many insurance professionals recommend at least this level.
  3. 250/500/100. A step up for people with assets to protect.
  4. A combined single limit option if offered (for example, $300,000 for all damage from one accident). Under Progressive's wording, a combined single limit is the most it will pay for the total of all damages from one accident; see combined single limit vs split limits.
  5. Uninsured and underinsured motorist limits that match your liability limits, because they protect you and your passengers when the other driver has little or no coverage.
  6. The property damage limit on its own, since it is the one most likely to be exhausted by a modern car.
  7. A quote for an umbrella policy if your assets justify it.

Also ask three questions: whether defense costs are paid outside the limit, whether any household exclusion reduces coverage for your relatives, and how your state treats the per-person cap in a death claim.

Common questions

Can one person get the whole per-accident limit?

No. The per-accident limit is subject to the per-person limit. With 50/100/50, a single injured person is capped at $50,000.

If four people are hurt, does each get $50,000?

Not necessarily. Each is capped at $50,000, but the total for all of them cannot exceed $100,000. Four people with large claims share the $100,000.

Do medical bills, lost wages and pain and suffering share one cap?

Yes. The published contracts say the per-person limit is the most they will pay for "all damages" due to bodily injury to one person.

In the Progressive and AAA forms read for this article, the cost of defending a lawsuit is paid "in addition to" the limit. Check your own policy's "additional payments" section.

Key takeaways

  • The per-person limit binds even when the per-accident limit is larger: with 50/100/50, one injured person tops out at $50,000.
  • Family-member claims arising from one person's injury usually share that person's cap, under the wording of the two published forms read here.
  • Property damage is a separate bucket, and defense costs are paid outside the limits in those forms.
  • When you shop, request the same set of limit combinations from every company and compare the price of each step up.

Sources

Terms used in this guide

Related insurers

Related states

Related guides

Related tools

Latest on this topic