Blog
The spread between the cheapest and priciest quote in one city
What sample-profile quote studies show about price gaps for the same driver, how to read the statistics, and how many quotes are enough before returns shrink.
In the published studies I could open, the gap between the lowest and highest quote for the same driver in the same city is large: more than five to one in North Dakota's 2026 survey of one Fargo profile, and often more than 100% in consumer-group studies. Those figures describe specific profiles, dates and companies, so they show that shopping can pay, not how much you will save. Getting about five matched quotes captures most of the available benefit in the one data set I analyzed below; three is the common minimum.
This article explains how these studies are built, what each one found, how to read the statistics so the average does not mislead you, where the evidence stops, and a quote-count rule of thumb with its caveats.
How sample-profile quote studies work
A sample-profile study picks a small number of imaginary drivers and asks insurers to price them. Everything except the company is held fixed: age, record, car, mileage, credit tier, coverage limits, deductibles, and location. Any difference in price is then a difference between companies. Regulators and consumer groups use two designs.
Insurer-supplied rates. The regulator asks companies to report what they would charge for each profile. The North Dakota Insurance and Securities Department's 2026 survey asked about 20 companies, which together cover over 80% of auto policies in the state, for six-month premiums for 12 profiles across five regions; it says rates are effective as of a specific date, and that being included does not mean the department recommends a company (North Dakota Insurance & Securities Department: 2026 Auto Insurance Cost Comparison Survey, checked November 2026). The Maryland Insurance Administration's interactive guide works the same way, showing total annual premiums for 22 scenarios from companies writing the most policies in the state, with the caveat that individuals may not qualify for every insurer (Maryland Insurance Administration: Auto insurance comparison guide, checked November 2026). Texas offers HelpInsure.com, run by its Department of Insurance and Office of Public Insurance Counsel, which says its results are informational and are not a substitute for a final quoted rate (HelpInsure.com, checked November 2026).
Researcher-collected online quotes. A consumer group or analyst enters the same profile on insurers' quote pages. The Consumer Federation of America (CFA) did this in 2012 and 2017. These designs reach more locations but depend on what the quote forms return on the day.
Neither design measures what you will actually pay. Real quotes depend on your own credit tier, record, prior insurance and discounts, and on whether the company will accept you at all. See how to read car insurance rate studies and average-cost claims for a general checklist.
What the studies found
North Dakota, 2026: one profile, one city, 23 companies
The first North Dakota profile is a single 23-year-old man in Fargo who drives a 2017 Ford F-150, commutes 4 miles each way, drives 15,000 miles a year, has a clean three-year record and excellent credit, and carries $250/$500 deductibles. The survey lists a six-month premium for each company. Using the 23 Fargo figures in the table, my calculations give:
| Statistic | Six-month premium |
|---|---|
| Lowest quote | $311 |
| 25th-percentile quote (6th lowest) | $496 |
| Median | $744 |
| Average | about $806 |
| 75th-percentile quote (18th lowest) | $969 |
| Highest quote | $1,643 |
| Highest divided by lowest | about 5.3 |
The percentiles here are the 6th and 18th of 23 sorted values, a simple approximation. Several rows carry survey footnotes, for example, that a carrier does not offer the requested deductible or that a figure is a lowest quote and subject to location; I included them as listed. The survey does not say why individual quotes differ.
CFA, 2012: moderate-income areas in 15 cities
CFA used the websites of State Farm, Allstate, Progressive and GEICO to price two typical moderate-income drivers with no accidents or violations in 15 cities, for each state's minimum liability coverage. It reported that 56% of the quotes were over $1,000 and 32% exceeded $1,500, and that in one city quotes to the same woman ranged from $762 to $3,390 (CFA: press release, June 18, 2012, checked November 2026). CFA is an advocacy group, the data are from 2012, and only four companies were sampled.
CFA, 2017: five insurers and 60 profiles, plus ZIP-code scale
In 2017 CFA reported two tests. In the first, online quotes from the five largest insurers for 60 customer profiles showed gaps over 100% in 41 profiles, over 150% in 20, over 200% in 12 and over 400% in five; a Minneapolis example ranged from $528 to $3,312. In the second, it collected 293,010 quotes from 64 preferred and standard affiliates of five insurer groups across 29,664 ZIP codes, and in the 50 largest metro areas reported an average within-ZIP range of $965, with the highest quote averaging 210% above the lowest (CFA: press release, October 19, 2017, checked November 2026). Non-standard insurers were excluded, which narrows the spread. Again, this is an advocacy-group study of one year.
Consumer survey evidence: what switchers saved
A different type of evidence asks real shoppers. Consumer Reports' 2024 survey of over 40,000 Americans found drivers who switched insurers saw a median annual savings of $461 (Consumer Reports: How to lower your car insurance rates, checked November 2026). AARP cites the same figure for car owners who switched in the past five years (AARP: 10 proven ways to pay less for car insurance, checked November 2026). Respondents who switched chose to do so, probably because they found a better price, so the median overstates what a random shopper would find.
Reading dispersion statistics
A spread has several shapes, and each statistic answers a different question.
- Range (highest minus lowest). Easy to compute and dominated by outliers. The highest quote may come from a company that does not want your profile, so it tells you little about what you should pay.
- Ratio (highest divided by lowest). Useful for headlines such as "5 to 1". Sensitive to a very low or very high company.
- Median versus average. In the North Dakota example the average ($806) sits above the median ($744) because a few expensive companies pull it up. Neither is your price.
- Percentiles. The gap between the 25th percentile ($496) and the 75th ($969) shows how wide the middle half of the market is. It is a better measure of typical disagreement than the extremes.
- Distance from the median to the lowest. If the median is $744 and the lowest is $311, the best quote beats the typical one by 58%. This is the number that estimates the benefit of shopping, not the range.
Averages hide tails in two ways. First, state or national average premium figures, such as the NAIC's average expenditure, are averages across policies with different coverages and drivers; they say nothing about dispersion for one profile. average expenditure vs average premium vs quoted rate explains the difference. Second, one low quote may only be available to a narrow group of drivers. Only a quote built from your own details tells you whether you are in that group.
Limits of the evidence
- Date. Rates are as of a specific date; North Dakota's survey is effective January 1, 2026, and CFA's studies are from 2012 and 2017. Prices and company strategies move; see why insurers disagree on your price: appetite and rate adequacy.
- Profiles. A profile with a clean record and excellent credit is the easiest to price. Drivers with a recent accident, a lapse or poor credit see different spreads and different eligibility; see shopping for car insurance after an accident or violation.
- Company mix. Studies sample a fixed list of companies. Smaller or regional companies, and ones that sell only through independent agents, may be missing. The North Dakota survey itself says not to restrict shopping to the companies it lists.
- Affiliates counted separately. Rows that share a brand can appear separately, which can make a market look broader than the number of distinct choices.
- Coverage and deductible choices. A study fixes them; you may not.
- No service dimension. Price spread says nothing about claim handling.
- Advocacy and government sources. CFA presents these studies to argue for regulatory reform, and a state department publishes its survey to encourage shopping. Each has an interest in showing large gaps.
How many quotes are enough?
I tested the question on the one data set above. Take the 23 Fargo quotes and ask: if you got k quotes drawn at random, what would the expected lowest of them be? The arithmetic is exact for this sample (no simulation), and it assumes every quote is equally likely to be drawn, which real life does not guarantee.
| Quotes drawn | Expected lowest six-month premium | Share of the average price saved |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | $806 | 0% |
| 2 | $599 | 26% |
| 3 | $519 | 36% |
| 4 | $474 | 41% |
| 5 | $445 | 45% |
| 6 | $424 | 47% |
| 8 | $395 | 51% |
| 10 | $376 | 53% |
The first extra quote helps most, and returns shrink: moving from three to five quotes improves the expected result by about nine percentage points, and from five to ten by about eight points. These percentages compare the expected lowest quote with the average of all 23. They are not savings relative to what you pay now. Your own current price might already be low, or high.
A rule of thumb with caveats. Get at least three matched quotes, which matches the Insurance Information Institute's advice to get at least three price quotes (Triple-I: Nine ways to lower your auto insurance costs, checked November 2026). Add more if your first three are far apart, if you have a recent accident or ticket, or if you have not shopped for years. Include different channels (a captive-agent company, a direct company, an independent agent), because they can reach different companies; see captive agents vs independent agents vs buying direct. Stop adding quotes when the lowest matched price stops moving. The caveats: a larger number of unmatched quotes is worse than three matched ones, and each quote costs time. The New York Department of Financial Services says consumers who shop get better value for their insurance dollar than those who do not, and also lists claim practices, service and reliability as reasons not to shop by price alone (NY DFS: Shopping for auto insurance, checked November 2026).
Build the quotes on one reference policy; building a fair comparison of car insurance quotes: a worksheet shows how, and state-run auto insurance price comparison tools and shopper's guides lists government tools that give a first look. Re-shopping timing is covered in Does timing matter? Rate cycles, renewals and when to shop.
Using a spread study yourself
- Find your state's survey or tool on the insurance department site, if it has one, and note its effective date.
- Choose the profile closest to yours, and look at the median and the lowest quotes, not the highest.
- Treat the lowest-priced companies as ones to quote, not ones to buy from. Whether they accept you depends on your details.
- Quote at least those companies plus your current one, matching coverage.
- Record the results in the car insurance quote comparison worksheet tool, and note the date.
Common questions
Is the spread bigger in expensive cities?
I could not confirm a pattern from the sources I opened. The data above are for particular places and profiles; check your own state's survey.
Why would the same driver be quoted five times higher?
Each company applies its own rating factors, tiers and appetite. The company side is explained in why two insurers quote the same driver very different prices.
Do online quotes match what I will pay?
Not always. The final price can change after records are checked; see why your final price differs from the online quote.
Does the lowest quote mean the best coverage?
No. A low quote may have different limits, deductibles or omissions. Compare matched policies.
Key takeaways
- Published same-driver spreads can be large: about 5.3 to 1 in one Fargo profile (North Dakota, 2026) and over 100% in 41 of 60 profiles in CFA's 2017 test.
- Use the median-to-lowest gap, not the range, to estimate what shopping could save.
- On one real data set, the expected lowest quote improves quickly through about five quotes, then slowly.
- Get at least three matched quotes; add more when the first three disagree or your situation is unusual.
- Every study is a dated snapshot of particular profiles and companies, not a forecast of your price.
Sources
- North Dakota Insurance & Securities Department: 2026 Auto Insurance Cost Comparison Survey, 23 Fargo quotes, methodology, checked November 2026
- Maryland Insurance Administration: Auto insurance comparison guide, 22 scenarios and caveats, checked November 2026
- HelpInsure.com, Texas shopper site and its disclaimer, checked November 2026
- CFA: press release, June 18, 2012, 15-city minimum-coverage quote study, checked November 2026
- CFA: press release, October 19, 2017, 60-profile and ZIP-code quote studies, checked November 2026
- Consumer Reports: How to lower your car insurance rates, 2024 survey median savings for switchers, checked November 2026
- AARP: 10 proven ways to pay less for car insurance, same median savings figure and shopping advice, checked November 2026
- Triple-I: Nine ways to lower your auto insurance costs, at least three price quotes, checked November 2026
- NY DFS: Shopping for auto insurance, shoppers get better value; do not shop by price alone, checked November 2026