Blog

What a crash hospital stay costs compared with common injury limits

Published hospital and crash-cost figures set beside 25/50, 100/300 and 250/500 limits, with a worked example and the quote comparison to run at each step.

A $25,000 per-person injury limit can be used up by a single serious injury. In the federal government's 2019 crash-cost study, the average medical care for one seriously injured survivor (a level the study calls MAIS3) was about $69,300, and for a severely injured one (MAIS4) about $188,600, before any lost wages or pain and suffering are counted. A $100,000 limit covers the first of those and not the second, and a $250,000 limit covers both. Which limit is "enough" depends on the injury and on what you could lose personally, and the published numbers below let you check for yourself.

What the published cost data actually measure

Three different public datasets get quoted in this debate, and they measure different things. Mixing them is the most common mistake.

NHTSA's economic cost study. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration publishes a periodic study of what crashes cost. The edition covering 2019 crashes, The Economic and Societal Impact of Motor Vehicle Crashes, 2019 (Revised), reports unit costs by injury severity on the Abbreviated Injury Scale, where MAIS1 is minor and MAIS5 is critical. These are lifetime economic costs in 2019 dollars, so they run well above any single hospital bill.

HCUP hospital costs. The federal Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project converts hospital charges into estimated costs using cost-to-charge ratios. Its numbers describe what a hospital spent treating a patient, not what the hospital billed and not what an insurer or claimant eventually paid. They also cover only the hospital, so physician fees, ambulance, rehabilitation, home care and equipment sit outside them.

Liability claims. What a liability insurer owes an injured person is a legal question: the injured person's reasonable medical expenses, lost earnings and other damages, reduced by any share of fault. It can be above or below the cost figures, depending on the state, the injury and the evidence.

So the cost data tell you how fast damages can grow. They do not tell you what any particular claim will be worth.

Hospital costs: what the HCUP briefs show

Two HCUP briefs give a sense of scale for the hospital portion alone.

The brief on emergency department costs, HCUP Statistical Brief 268, found that emergency department visits in 2017 totaled $76.3 billion across 144.8 million visits, an average of $530 per visit. That average is dominated by minor visits. The same brief reports that visits ending in a transfer to another facility averaged $1,100, which hints at how much a sicker patient costs even before admission.

For head injuries, HCUP Statistical Brief 255 covers 2017 stays with a principal diagnosis of traumatic brain injury (TBI). Those stays averaged 6.8 days and $21,000 per stay, compared with $12,100 for stays without a TBI diagnosis. Stays for TBIs caused by motor vehicle traffic and other transport incidents were longer and costlier than the average TBI stay: 8.6 days and $31,000 on average, with 8.4 percent of those stays ending in death in the hospital. Stays with loss of consciousness averaged $25,200.

Read those carefully. They are averages of hospital costs, in 2017 dollars, for the stay itself. A $31,000 hospital stay can sit inside a claim of several times that size once rehabilitation, specialists, lost income and long-term care are added, and the HCUP briefs do not follow patients after discharge. Costs have also risen since 2017, so treat the figures as a floor for scale rather than a current price list.

What NHTSA says a crash injury costs, by severity

The NHTSA study splits costs into components. The table pulls the figures that matter most to a liability limit from its summary of unit costs per injured person (2019 dollars). Medical care is the hospital, physician and rehabilitation spending for that injury; the study's totals also include lost earnings, household work, legal costs and more.

Injury level (MAIS) Medical care Total economic cost per person
MAIS1 (minor) $2,210 $19,344
MAIS2 (moderate) $13,269 $71,419
MAIS3 (serious) $69,345 $280,726
MAIS4 (severe) $188,626 $675,727
MAIS5 (critical) $363,229 $979,328
Fatality $17,289 $1,606,644

Source: Table 1-2 and Table 3-13 of NHTSA's report, which pairs medical costs with a total that includes lost productivity, legal costs, insurance administration, congestion and property damage. The report's own summary says each critically injured survivor cost an average of about $979,000.

Two cautions. First, the "total" column includes things a liability policy does not pay, such as congestion costs, the injured person's own insurance administration and property damage. It is society's cost, not a claim value. Second, the study counts 4.5 million injured people in 2019 across every severity, so no single row describes a typical crash. The point of the table is the shape of the curve: costs rise by multiples, not percentages, as severity climbs.

Look at the medical care column alone, because that is the part a bodily injury claim must at least cover:

  • A MAIS3 injury averages $69,345 in medical care. A $25,000 per-person limit pays about 36 percent of that figure, before wages or pain and suffering.
  • A MAIS4 injury averages $188,626. A $100,000 limit pays a little over half.
  • A MAIS5 injury averages $363,229. Even a $250,000 limit pays about 69 percent of the medical care alone.

Averages hide the spread, which is the real exposure. A broken leg, a spinal cord injury and a brain injury can all be coded in the same broad bands.

How common limits sit against those numbers

State minimums are set by law, and they vary, so check yours with the state car insurance requirements lookup tool or your state insurance department. Three examples show how different the floor can be:

  • California. The state DMV lists the current minimum liability limits as $30,000 per person, $60,000 per accident and $15,000 for property damage. See California.
  • Florida. The financial responsibility statute, Fla. Stat. 324.021, sets $10,000 for one person, $20,000 for two or more people and $10,000 for property in a crash. Florida's day-to-day insurance mandate is different, so see Florida for how bodily injury coverage works there.
  • Michigan. MCL 500.3009 sets default liability limits of $250,000 per person and $500,000 per accident for policies after July 1, 2020, but lets a buyer choose lower limits, down to $50,000 and $100,000, by completing a form. See Michigan.

Set against the NHTSA table, a 25/50 limit sits well below the average medical care for a MAIS3 injury. A 100/300 limit clears MAIS3 but not MAIS4 or MAIS5 medical care. A 250/500 limit clears the average medical cost of everything except a critical injury, and still leaves a gap for lost earnings in a severe case. Remember that the per-accident number is shared: a crash with three injured passengers in the other car divides the per-accident limit among them, as per-person vs per-accident limits: worked crash examples walks through.

A worked example with numbers we define

The following is hypothetical. Suppose you cause a crash that injures two people in another car. Rider A is seriously hurt, with total damages (medical bills, lost earnings and pain and suffering) of $150,000. Rider B has total damages of $60,000. We assume you are fully at fault and the claims are worth those amounts.

Your limits Paid to A Paid to B Unpaid, owed by you
25/50 $25,000 $25,000 $125,000 + $35,000 = $160,000
100/300 $100,000 $60,000 $50,000
250/500 $150,000 $60,000 $0

The table simply shows the arithmetic of a limit; liens from health insurers and other repayment claims can reduce what an injured person keeps, but they do not change what you owe. The unpaid column is the part a plaintiff can pursue against your assets, which is why what happens when damages exceed your liability limits and the question of what a judgment can reach matter more than the limit alone.

Limit versus household net worth

A useful way to choose is to compare the limit with what you could lose. The Federal Reserve's 2022 Survey of Consumer Finances, summarized in its October 2023 bulletin, reported median family net worth of $192,900 (in 2022 dollars; the Fed has since fielded a 2025 survey, so check its current page for newer figures). A household near the median could lose nearly all of its net worth to the unpaid $160,000 in the 25/50 row above, and a good deal of it even with 100/300.

Net worth is the wrong measure in one respect: future wages can also be pursued, and exemptions for homes, retirement accounts and wages differ sharply by state. The article what happens when damages exceed your liability limits covers that. The practical rule is that the more you have to protect, and the more you earn, the more a high limit buys. An umbrella policy adds liability above your auto limits and usually requires specified underlying limits, so check those before you buy one.

What each limit step costs, and the quote comparison to run

Limits are priced in steps, and the price of a step is usually small next to the protection it adds, because insurers price extra limits with factors that grow slowly. The mechanism is covered in the price of liability limits: how much each step up really costs. We do not state a dollar price here, because it depends on your state, vehicle, driving record and insurer.

Run this comparison with the car insurance quote comparison worksheet:

  1. Get one quote at your current limits, and note the exact coverages and deductibles.
  2. Ask for the same quote at 100/300/100, then at 250/500/100. Keep every other coverage identical.
  3. Write down the premium difference for each step, annualized, not just the monthly figure.
  4. Divide the extra annual cost by the extra protection. A move from 25/50 to 100/300 adds $75,000 of per-person protection; a move to 250/500 adds $225,000.
  5. Quote the same limits at two or three other insurers, since the cost of a step varies by company.
  6. Ask each agent whether underinsured motorist coverage can match your liability limits, because it uses the same amounts to protect you when the other driver is the one who is underinsured.

If the extra cost for a step is a few dollars a month, that is usually the cheapest protection on the policy. If it is large, ask the agent what is driving it: a recent claim, a young driver or a high-risk class can change the price of every step.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Buying the minimum because it is legal. A minimum is the least the law accepts, not a measure of what crashes cost.
  • Ignoring the per-accident cap. Three injured people share one number, so a $50,000 per-accident cap is thin however the per-person figure looks.
  • Counting medical payments or health insurance as liability cover. Your own medical payments coverage or health plan pays for your injuries, not the other person's.
  • Comparing quotes with different deductibles or coverages. The limits step has to be the only variable.
  • Assuming the average is your risk. The NHTSA and HCUP numbers are averages across many crashes; the claim you could face is a single draw from a skewed distribution.

Common questions

Are 25/50 limits enough for a serious injury?

On the published data, usually not. The average medical care alone for a MAIS3 injury in the NHTSA study was $69,345, which is nearly three times a $25,000 per-person limit.

Are the HCUP hospital costs what my insurer would pay?

No. HCUP estimates hospital costs from charges and cost-to-charge ratios. A claim is valued on the injured person's reasonable medical expenses and other damages under state law.

Do I need 250/500 limits?

It depends on your assets, income and risk tolerance. Compare the quote for each step, and consider an umbrella policy if you have significant assets.

Does the other driver's insurance reduce my exposure?

If the other driver also caused part of the crash, fault may be shared and your share of damages falls. That varies by state, and a licensed attorney or the state insurance department is the place for specifics.

Key takeaways

  • NHTSA's 2019 study puts average medical care at $69,345 for a serious (MAIS3) injury and $188,626 for a severe (MAIS4) one, so a 25/50 limit covers only part of one serious injury.
  • HCUP reports an average cost of $31,000 for a hospital stay with a traffic-related brain injury in 2017, hospital only, before rehabilitation and lost income.
  • Compare each limit step with identical coverages across several insurers; the price of a step is often small next to what it adds.
  • Weigh your limit against what you could lose, not against the legal minimum.

Sources

Terms used in this guide

Related states

Related guides

Related tools

Latest on this topic