Guides
Why Florida car insurance is so expensive
Florida had the highest average car insurance spending in the U.S. in 2023. Why, what the 2023 tort reform changed, and why rates are now falling.
Florida car insurance became the most expensive in the country because claims there cost so much: heavy litigation over injury and repair claims, dense coastal metro areas, hurricane and flood losses, and a no-fault system with low required coverage that leaves many crashes to be fought over. In NAIC data, Florida drivers spent an average of $1,864.63 per insured vehicle in 2023, the highest of any state. Since a 2023 tort reform law, insurers' claim costs have fallen sharply and rates are coming down.
How expensive Florida is
According to the NAIC Auto Insurance Database Report, Florida's average expenditure rose from $1,389.08 in 2020 (sixth highest) to $1,567.88 in 2022 and $1,864.63 in 2023, first in the nation, against a U.S. average of $1,281.92. Its combined average premium for liability, collision and comprehensive was $1,993.81. The liability portion stands out: Florida's average liability premium was $1,294.57 in 2023, compared with $736.65 nationally. The Insurance Research Council ranked Florida the second least affordable state for auto insurance relative to income in 2022 (IRC, March 2025).
What Florida requires
To register a car with at least four wheels, Florida requires only $10,000 of personal injury protection (PIP) and $10,000 of property damage liability from an insurer licensed in Florida, according to the Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles. PIP pays 80% of necessary and reasonable medical expenses up to $10,000 regardless of who caused the crash. bodily injury liability is not required to register, though drivers can be required to carry it after certain crashes or convictions, and drivers convicted of DUI must file an FR-44 with much higher limits.
Low required limits keep the legal minimum cheap, but they leave injured people looking beyond PIP to the at-fault driver, whose coverage may be small or nonexistent. That pushes costs into uninsured motorist coverage and into lawsuits.
Why claims cost so much
- Litigation: before 2023, Florida's one-way attorney fee rules let policyholders who won suits against their insurers recover legal fees, and claimants had four years to sue for negligence. Insurers and the state's regulator point to that environment as a main cost driver. Florida's no-fault rules mean your own PIP pays first for your injuries, but the $10,000 limit is quickly exhausted in a serious crash, which sends larger claims into the liability and court system.
- Urban density: the NAIC reports that 91.5% of Floridians live in urban areas, among the highest shares in the country.
- Weather: hurricanes and flooding can total thousands of vehicles at once, which falls on comprehensive coverage.
- Loss ratios: in 2022 Florida's personal auto physical damage loss ratio was 112.0%, meaning insurers paid more in repair and replacement claims than they collected for that coverage, according to the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation (OIR).
What the 2023 reform changed
HB 837, signed and effective March 24, 2023 (Florida Senate), made several changes that affect auto claims:
- Modified comparative negligence: a person found more than 50% at fault for their own harm cannot recover damages (s. 768.81(6), Florida Statutes). Before, they could recover a reduced amount. See comparative negligence.
- Shorter deadline: general negligence suits must be filed within two years instead of four (s. 95.11).
- Attorney fees: limits on the one-way attorney fee provisions in suits against insurers.
- Medical damages evidence: new standards for proving medical expenses, including disclosures for treatment under letters of protection.
- Bad faith: new standards for bad faith claims against insurers.
The broader debate over these changes is covered in tort reform and car insurance.
Rates since the reform
The OIR reports a clear turn (July 2025 and March 2026). Florida's top five auto groups, Progressive, Berkshire Hathaway (GEICO), State Farm, Allstate and USAA, write about 78% of the market.
| Year | Average rate change, top five groups |
|---|---|
| 2023 | +31.7% |
| 2024 | +4.3% |
| 2025 | -7.4% (total requested) |
| 2026 | -8.0% indicated, as of February 2026 |
Florida's personal auto liability loss ratio fell to 52.5% in 2025, the lowest in the state in 15 years and the lowest of any state, and the physical damage loss ratio fell to 49.5%. Under Florida's excess-profits law (s. 627.066), insurers whose profits exceed a threshold must return money to policyholders; Progressive recorded a $950 million policyholder credit in September 2025. Separately, the OIR says State Farm announced a policyholder dividend of about $533 million in Florida, averaging $173 per vehicle.
Not every indicator points the same way. Marathon Strategies found that Florida was back among the top five states for corporate nuclear verdicts in 2025, after a dip in 2024 (August 2026). Hurricanes can also reverse progress in a single season.
What Florida drivers can do
- Do not stop at the minimum. With no bodily injury liability required, a serious crash you cause can put your savings at risk. Consider liability limits sized to your assets; the How much car insurance do I need? helps.
- Keep uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage. It protects you when the at-fault driver has little or no liability coverage.
- Check comprehensive before hurricane season. Flood damage to a car is covered under comprehensive, not homeowners insurance.
- Re-shop now. With insurers cutting rates and some issuing refunds, quotes can differ widely for the same coverage.
- New to Florida? You must get insurance from a Florida-licensed insurer to title and register your car within 10 days of establishing residency; see moving to a new state: how to switch your car insurance.
Key takeaways
- Florida had the highest average auto insurance expenditure in the U.S. in 2023, $1,864.63 per vehicle in NAIC data.
- Litigation, urban density, weather and a low-minimum PIP system drove costs up.
- The 2023 reform barred recovery for claimants more than 50% at fault and cut the negligence filing deadline to two years.
- The top five insurers moved from +31.7% rate changes in 2023 to an indicated -8.0% for 2026, and some are paying refunds.
- Florida requires only PIP and property damage liability, so buying bodily injury and uninsured motorist coverage is a key decision.