Blog

Reading two quotes side by side: eight lines where policies differ

Two quotes can both say full coverage and differ by hundreds of dollars. A worked pair of sample declarations pages shows where the gap comes from.

Two quotes that both say "full coverage" usually differ because the label has no fixed meaning. Full coverage is a shorthand for liability plus collision plus comprehensive, and each of those has limits, deductibles, exclusions and add-ons that you can set differently. The price gap is the sum of those choices plus each insurer's own rating of you and your car.

The way to read the gap is to put the two declarations pages next to each other, compare eight lines in a fixed order, and price each difference. This article walks through a worked pair of sample declarations pages. The numbers are invented for illustration. The method is what you can reuse.

Why "full coverage" does not settle anything

The California Department of Insurance says that "auto policies can vary a lot" and that you should get several quotes, ask for each in writing and compare them. The New York Department of Financial Services puts it this way: prices for the same coverage vary significantly among companies, so when you compare prices, be sure you compare coverage of the same type. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) advises giving "the same information to each agent or company" and notes that misquotes often result from agent mistakes or inaccurate application information.

Those three statements point to the same discipline. A quote is useful only if the inputs match: same drivers, same vehicles, same coverages and limits. When they do not match, you are comparing two different products. See how to compare car insurance quotes apples to apples for the general approach and why two insurers quote the same driver very different prices for the rating side, which this article sets aside.

The two sample declarations pages

Assume a driver, Priya, is 38 and drives a 2020 sedan with an actual cash value of about $19,000. She gets two six-month quotes. The figures below are hypothetical numbers we defined for this article, not any company's prices.

Line Quote A Quote B
1. Liability limits 50/100/50 100/300/100
2. Uninsured and underinsured motorist 25/50 100/300
3. Deductibles Collision $1,000, comprehensive $1,000 Collision $500, comprehensive $250
4. Glass Comprehensive deductible applies Full glass, no deductible
5. Rental and towing None Rental $40 a day up to $1,200, towing added
6. Valuation wording and endorsements Standard actual cash value Actual cash value plus an original-parts endorsement
7. Drivers and vehicles One driver, one car, 7,500 miles a year One driver, one car, 7,500 miles a year
8. Fees and payment Paid in full, no fee Monthly, installment fee included in the six-month total
Six-month premium $1,020 $1,404

The gap is $384. Both agents call the policy "full coverage." The next sections work through each line.

Line 1: liability limits and splits

Liability limits are written as three numbers. 50/100/50 means $50,000 per person for bodily injury, $100,000 per accident for bodily injury, and $50,000 for property damage. Quote B's 100/300/100 doubles or triples each. The NAIC reminds shoppers that insurers pay up to the policy limit on a judgment or settlement, and that if the amount is larger "you will have to pay the difference." That is the cost of lower limits. The liability limits decoder translates the numbers, and how much liability coverage do you need? discusses how to choose.

In our example, Quote B's higher limits account for $90 of the six-month gap. Higher limits are not a defect in Quote A, and lower limits are not a bargain. They are different levels of protection.

What to check

Line 2: uninsured and underinsured motorist

Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage pays your injuries when the driver who hit you has no insurance or too little. The NAIC lists it alongside bodily injury and property damage liability. See uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage explained.

In the example, Quote A has UM at 25/50 and Quote B at 100/300. That difference adds $46 to Quote B. If the quotes show different UM limits, make that a line in your comparison. A quote that omits UM may also have been quoted with a signed rejection, and you would want to know that before you sign.

Line 3: deductibles by coverage

A deductible is the amount you pay before the insurer pays. The California Department of Insurance says only comprehensive and collision have deductibles, and that you usually pay a lower premium with a higher deductible. Its example: with a $500 comprehensive deductible and $1,500 of storm damage, you pay $500 and the coverage pays $1,000.

Compare deductibles for collision and comprehensive separately, because quotes often set them differently. In the example, Quote A uses $1,000 and $1,000 and Quote B uses $500 and $250. That is worth $108 of the six-month gap. Whether a lower deductible is worth the premium is a savings question, not a quality question. You can test it with the deductible break-even calculator and read how to choose a deductible: $500 vs $1,000 and beyond.

Be careful with the vocabulary. A quote that shows $500 for collision and "no deductible" for glass is a different product from one that shows $500 for everything.

Line 4: glass

The NAIC says comprehensive covers glass damage, so your comprehensive deductible may apply to a windshield claim unless the policy has a full glass endorsement. In the example, Quote B adds full glass, which accounts for $22.

Policy wording can also change how glass is repaired or replaced. The State Farm Car Policy Booklet for Oklahoma (form 9836A), for example, says that replacement glass need not have any insignia, logo, trademark or other marking from the replaced glass, and that windshield glass is repaired instead of replaced if you and the insurer agree. Another company's wording may differ. For modern cars with cameras behind the windshield, see windshield replacement on a modern car: cameras, calibration and glass and full glass coverage and zero-deductible windshield repair.

Line 5: rental and towing limits

Rental reimbursement and towing are small add-ons with limits that are easy to overlook. The NAIC notes that rental reimbursement coverage typically has a dollar limit that the policy spells out. In the State Farm Oklahoma booklet, car rental expense is limited by the "Each Day" and "Each Loss" limits shown on the declarations page, either as a dollar amount or as a percentage of the daily rental charge. The same booklet's emergency road service pays for up to one hour of labor at the place of breakdown and towing to the nearest repair facility where necessary repairs can be made.

When two quotes differ here, compare three things: the daily limit, the total limit, and the towing distance or dollar limit. In the example, Quote B's $40 a day up to $1,200 and added towing cost $31 more over six months. If you have another source for towing, such as an auto club, you may not need it twice. See rental reimbursement coverage and roadside assistance coverage vs auto club membership.

Line 6: valuation wording, endorsements and exclusions

This line is the hardest to compare because the differences are in the policy form rather than the declarations numbers. Three things are worth checking.

How the policy values a total loss. Actual cash value is the usual basis. The California Department of Insurance says that, unless the policy defines it otherwise, actual cash value in California means fair market value: what a knowledgeable buyer under no pressure would pay a knowledgeable seller. State total-loss rules, such as California's 10 CCR 2695.8, require that a cash settlement be based on the actual cost of a comparable automobile less any deductible and include applicable taxes and one-time transfer fees. A policy can offer more than actual cash value. Amica's website, for example, says its New Vehicle Replacement is included with all its auto policies when a never-titled new car is totaled within 365 days or before 12,000 miles, and that its Better Vehicle Replacement comes with its Signature policies. Another company's terms may be different. The point is not that one company is better; it is that the two quotes may promise different payouts for the same total loss. See new car replacement, better car and gap: endorsements compared and agreed value, stated value and actual cash value compared.

How the policy repairs your car. The State Farm Oklahoma booklet says repair estimates may include new, used, recycled and reconditioned parts, original or non-original. An endorsement that requires original parts changes the price of a repair and the price of the policy. In the example, Quote B's original-parts endorsement adds $29. See OEM parts endorsements: guaranteeing factory parts.

What is excluded or required. The Texas Department of Insurance comparison worksheet includes a line for "any additional requirements for coverage," such as all drivers being named on the policy or limits on miles, and a line for endorsements. Two policies can show the same limits and still attach different conditions: the Coast National Nevada form, for example, gives an additional car broad coverage only if no other policy insures it and the insurer insures all autos in your household. Ask for the policy form, and read how to read the auto policy contract, not just the declarations page.

Line 7: drivers and vehicles

The California Department of Insurance lists what an insurer needs: the names, ages, marital status and license numbers for all drivers in your household, their driving records, and details about your vehicles. If one quote lists a spouse or a teenager and the other does not, the quotes are not comparable, and the cheaper one may have a misquote problem. The NAIC says misquotes often come from agent mistakes or inaccurate application information.

Mileage, garaging address and vehicle trim also matter. In the example, both quotes use the same driver, vehicle and 7,500 miles a year, so this line adds $0. In real life, check that the vehicle identification number, annual mileage and use class match. See How insurers decode your VIN, and what a wrong trim costs you.

Line 8: fees and payment plans

The California Department of Insurance notes that most insurers let you pay in installments and tells shoppers to ask whether there is an extra fee. A quote shown as a six-month total may include or exclude fees, and a monthly price may not equal the six-month total divided by six. In the example, Quote A is paid in full with no fee, and Quote B is quoted monthly and includes a $4 fee in its six-month figure.

To compare, ask for the total cost over the policy period, including every fee, under the payment plan you would use. The pay in full vs monthly calculator helps if one quote assumes a discount for paying in full.

Where the $384 comes from

Here is the hypothetical gap decomposed.

Line Difference in six-month premium
1. Liability limits $90
2. UM/UIM $46
3. Deductibles $108
4. Glass $22
5. Rental and towing $31
6. Valuation and endorsements $29
7. Drivers and vehicles $0
8. Fees $4
Explained by coverage differences $330
Remaining difference in the insurers' own rating $54
Total gap $384

Notice the last row. Even after you match the coverages, two insurers will price you differently because each has its own rates, rating factors and discounts. That remainder is what a true price comparison measures. The $330 above is what you are buying.

What the decomposition tells Priya

  • If Priya wants Quote B's coverage, she should ask Quote A's company to price the same lines. The remaining $54 is the real gap.
  • If she prefers Quote A's lower limits and higher deductibles, she should ask whether a higher liability limit alone is affordable. Line 1 is the coverage that protects her assets.
  • If she is unsure, she can raise Quote A's liability limits first and the deductibles last, adding one line at a time and watching the price.

A printable list of lines to compare

Copy this list and fill it in for each quote. Use the car insurance quote comparison worksheet or the Texas Department of Insurance worksheet if you prefer a form.

  1. Company legal name, licensed in your state, and policy period.
  2. Drivers and vehicles listed; annual mileage; garaging address.
  3. Liability limits (per person, per accident, property damage).
  4. Uninsured and underinsured motorist limits, or a signed rejection.
  5. Collision and comprehensive deductibles, listed separately.
  6. Glass: full glass or subject to the comprehensive deductible.
  7. Rental reimbursement: daily limit and total limit.
  8. Towing and roadside: dollar limit or distance.
  9. Valuation wording and any replacement, original-parts or new-car endorsements.
  10. Exclusions and requirements (named drivers, mileage limits).
  11. Discounts applied, and the conditions to keep them.
  12. Fees, payment plan and total cost over the policy period.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Comparing monthly prices with six-month prices. Convert both to the same period.
  • Comparing different drivers. An omitted household driver turns a quote into a future dispute.
  • Letting the lowest quote set the coverage. The cheapest quote is often the one with the highest deductibles and lowest limits.
  • Ignoring the insurer. The California Department of Insurance advises confirming the complete name of the company that will issue each policy and that it is licensed in your state. The NAIC makes a similar point.

Common questions

Why are two full coverage quotes so different?

Full coverage is a label, not a standard. Limits, deductibles and endorsements differ, and each insurer then rates you with its own formula.

How many quotes should I get?

The regulators we cite say "several" and do not give a number. Three to five quotes with matching inputs is a reasonable starting point.

Should I compare my renewal against new quotes?

Yes. Use your current declarations page as the template so that you are quoting the same coverage; see how often should you shop for car insurance?.

Do online quotes match the final price?

Not always; see why your final price differs from the online quote.

Key takeaways

  • "Full coverage" is a shorthand. Compare the limits, deductibles and endorsements line by line.
  • Put each quote's inputs in the same order and get them in writing.
  • Price each difference, then isolate what is left: that is the insurers' own pricing of you.
  • Higher deductibles lower premiums but raise what you pay at claim time.
  • Check the company's name, licensing and complaint record before you buy.

Sources

Terms used in this guide

Related insurers

Related guides

Related tools

Latest on this topic