Blog

Advertised savings claims: how to read an average-savings promise

What "drivers who switch save an average of $X" counts, who is left out, what the fine print says and the law covers, and how to test the number with a quote.

An advertised average saving is the average of a particular group, usually new customers who switched and reported that they saved. It is not a prediction of what your quote will be, and it is not a guarantee. The footnotes on the insurers' own pages say as much, in words such as "potential savings will vary," and they also tell you exactly who was counted. The only number that applies to you is the quote you get for your own drivers, cars and coverage.

This article reads the fine print from several insurers' pages as they stood in November 2026, explains who is in the sample and who is not, summarizes the laws that govern insurance advertising and what we could not find in them, and gives you a short test to run before you act on any such claim. It does not rank or criticize any company. Each figure below is what the company's page says, attributed to it.

What the claims say

Four pages we could open carry an average-savings headline. Each states its sample in a footnote. GEICO's site refused our automated requests, so we do not describe its claims.

Company Headline on the page What the footnote says it counted
State Farm Drivers who switch save an average of $740; customers save up to $900 on average by bundling auto and renters Average annual savings per household from a 2025 national survey by State Farm of new policyholders who reported savings by switching
Progressive Drivers who switch and save see an average savings of $975 National average 12-month savings by new customers surveyed who saved with Progressive between June 2025 and May 2026; "potential savings will vary"
Allstate Customers who switched saved $900 National average annual savings for new auto customers surveyed in 2025 who switched to Allstate and reported savings; "potential savings and availability varies by state"
Nationwide Save an average of $1,032 when you bundle home and car insurance Average annualized savings on home and auto premiums compared to the stand-alone price of each policy, from a national sample, March to May 2024; "actual savings will vary"

(Sources: State Farm: auto insurance, Progressive: Car Insurance, Allstate: auto insurance, Nationwide: auto insurance, all checked November 2026.)

A credit union program page follows the same pattern. TruStage's auto insurance page says its savings figure is based on a countrywide survey of new customers who reported savings when they switched to Liberty Mutual or Safeco between October 2024 and September 2025, that savings will vary, and that the comparison does not apply in Massachusetts (TruStage: auto insurance, checked November 2026).

Read the table twice. Every row is a different number, from a different company, over a different period, counting a slightly different thing. None of them contradicts another, and none can be added to another.

How these averages are built

You can work out the method from the footnotes. It has five steps.

  1. Start with new customers. The sample is people who bought a policy recently. It excludes people who got a quote and stayed where they were.
  2. Keep only those who switched. A switcher is someone whose new quote was attractive enough to act on.
  3. Keep only those who saved. Progressive's footnote says "customers surveyed who saved." State Farm's says "who reported savings." Allstate's says "reported savings." The people who switched and paid more, if any, are not described as part of the figure.
  4. Ask them how much. The word "surveyed" or "reported" tells you the figure comes from responses. The pages we opened do not publish the questionnaire, so we cannot say whether respondents compared like-for-like coverage.
  5. Average the answers across the country, over a stated window, per household or over 12 months.

The result can be an accurate summary of that group and still a poor guide to a particular shopper. The two things are not in conflict, because the group was assembled by selecting the people for whom the product worked.

Who is left out

  • People whose quote was higher. They did not switch and are not in the sample. Their experience is the reason a quote is worth running, and it is invisible in the average.
  • People who were declined or never finished a quote.
  • People who switched and saved little or nothing, if the figure counts only those who "saved."
  • People who compare differently. Someone who lowered coverage to cut the price may be counted as a saver.

The practical effect is selection. If the group is only people who saved, the average is the average of the winners.

A worked example with numbers we define

The following figures are hypothetical. They show how a selected average can sit beside a different average for everyone who quoted.

Suppose Company X gets quotes from 10,000 drivers in a month.

  • For 2,000 of them, the X quote is cheaper than what they pay now. They buy, and the average saving among them is $900 a year.
  • For the other 8,000, the X quote is higher than their current price, by $400 a year on average. They do not buy.

Company X can say, truthfully and with the survey details in a footnote, that "drivers who switch save an average of $900." Across all 10,000 quotes, though, the picture is different. The 2,000 buyers save $900 each, a combined $1.8 million. The 8,000 non-buyers would have paid $400 more each, a combined $3.2 million. The average difference across all 10,000 quotes is a $140 increase.

The $900 and the $140 are both correct and they answer different questions. The first asks what happened to the people for whom the quote was cheaper. The second asks what the quote does for a randomly chosen driver. Real insurers' sample details are not published in the pages we opened, so no real company's numbers should be read into this example. The point is the structure.

Why competitors can all claim savings

Progressive's page also lists average savings for people who switched to it from other named insurers, for example from Allstate, GEICO and State Farm, with footnotes giving the same June 2025 to May 2026 survey window. Allstate's page lists average savings for people who switched to it from Progressive, State Farm and GEICO. State Farm's page gives its own average for people who switch to it (Progressive: Car Insurance; Allstate: auto insurance; State Farm: auto insurance, checked November 2026).

So the pages of several large insurers each say that people who moved to that insurer from the others saved money. This is not a contradiction, because each company counts people who found it cheaper. Drivers differ in age, record, location, vehicle and coverage, and each company prices those differently. A driver who is cheaper at Company A may be dearer at Company B. The claims describe who moved, and where a driver sits depends on rating factors, which are covered in why two insurers quote the same driver very different prices.

What the footnotes tell you to watch

Learn a short vocabulary for these claims. The sources behind the right-hand column are the pages in the table above.

Phrase What it usually signals Question to ask
"Average" A mean of a defined group, which a few large savings can pull up Mean or median? Over what group?
"Customers who switched" Only buyers What about those who got a quote and stayed?
"Reported savings" or "who saved" Only savers, based on responses Are non-savers counted anywhere?
"National" All states pooled Is my state's figure different?
"12-month" or "annual" A yearly figure Does the policy I am quoted run 6 or 12 months?
"Per household" A household total, which can include several cars Does my household look like that?
"Up to" A maximum What is the typical figure, if one is given?
"When you bundle" A saving that needs a second policy Do I want the second policy?

State Farm's page offers an example of two phrases side by side: "On average, customers save up to $900" when bundling auto and renters. An average of a maximum is not a plain average, and the footnote defines the figure, so read that sentence in light of the footnote. Progressive's page notes that its "5% on average" bundle figure is based on a six-month term and is not available in all states, which is a reminder to match the term when you compare.

What the law says about advertising

Insurance advertising sits in a mixed regulatory space.

State law is primary. Under the McCarran-Ferguson Act, the business of insurance is subject to the laws of the several states. The Federal Trade Commission Act applies to insurance only to the extent the business is not regulated by state law (15 U.S.C. 1012, Cornell Legal Information Institute, checked November 2026). The general federal rule is that unfair or deceptive acts or practices in or affecting commerce are unlawful (15 U.S.C. 45(a), Cornell Legal Information Institute, checked November 2026). For the split between state and federal roles, see Why insurance is regulated by states, not Washington.

An example of a state rule. Florida defines as an unfair or deceptive act making or circulating an advertisement, announcement or statement about the business of insurance that is untrue, deceptive or misleading. A separate provision covers any estimate, illustration, statement, sales presentation, omission or comparison that misrepresents the benefits, advantages, conditions or terms of an insurance policy (Florida Statutes 626.9541, 2025 edition, checked November 2026). Other states have their own unfair-trade-practice laws, and they differ in wording and enforcement.

Testimonials. The Federal Trade Commission's endorsement rules say that when an ad shows a consumer's experience as a key result, it is likely to be read as typical of what consumers will generally achieve. If the advertiser lacks substantiation that it is typical, the ad should clearly and conspicuously disclose the generally expected performance (16 CFR 255.2, Cornell Legal Information Institute, checked November 2026). That rule is written for endorsements. Whether it reaches an insurer's advertising in a given state depends on the McCarran-Ferguson boundary above, so it is background, not a rule we can say applies to a specific ad.

What we could not find. In the sources we opened, we did not find a state or federal rule that prescribes how an "average savings" figure must be computed, which survey method it must use, or what share of customers must have saved. Disclosure, in the footnote, is where the method appears. If you believe an advertisement or an agent misled you, your state insurance department takes complaints, and how to file a complaint against a car insurance company explains how. Illinois's insurance department makes the consumer-side point in its shopping guide: do not be rushed into buying a policy because of high-pressure sales tactics or be misled by advertising (Illinois Department of Insurance: Auto Insurance Shopping Guide, checked November 2026). A licensed attorney or the state insurance department is the place for a specific dispute.

Test the claim with a quote

An average tells you whether a quote is worth requesting. It cannot replace the quote. Here is a method.

  1. Write down what you pay now, per month and per term, and the coverage on your declarations page. how to read your car insurance declarations page helps if you are unsure which lines matter.
  2. Get quotes for the same coverage. Use identical limits, deductibles and extras on every form. online quote defaults: pre-selected extras and recommended coverage explains why pre-filled forms can mislead.
  3. Match the term. Convert a six-month quote to a yearly figure, or compare six-month to six-month.
  4. Include everything. Add installment fees and subtract any discount that needs your action, such as paying in full or enrolling in a driving-data program. Then ask what the price is without any program you do not want.
  5. Check the renewal, not only the first term. Ask whether the quoted price is a new-customer price and how renewals are priced. reading a car insurance renewal notice: rate-change notice rules covers what you will see later.
  6. Look beyond price. how to compare car insurance quotes apples to apples and how to choose a car insurance company cover ratings, complaints and claims service.
  7. Use a worksheet. The car insurance quote comparison worksheet keeps the lines aligned for three or more quotes.
  8. Set a rule in advance. For example, decide that you will switch only if the saving on equal coverage exceeds a number you pick, and re-shop on a schedule from how often should you shop for car insurance?.

Once you have three comparable quotes, the advertised average no longer matters. You will have your own.

Reading a "you could save" ad in the wild

The same logic applies outside the insurers' pages. A comparison site, a social post or a TV ad may quote an average. Ask four things. Who was counted? Over what period? Does it include only people who saved? What does the small print say? how car insurance comparison sites and lead generators work explains how comparison sites make money, and why big insurers spend billions on advertising and what you pay for it explains why the claims exist. A third useful distinction is the difference between an average premium and a quoted rate, covered in average expenditure vs average premium vs quoted rate. And car insurance price myths: red cars, quote shopping and others addresses a common myth, that quote shopping itself costs you.

Common questions

Does "drivers save an average of $X" mean I will save $X?

No. The footnotes describe a group of new customers who switched and reported savings, and say potential savings will vary. Your saving depends on your own quote.

Why does every big insurer say people who switch save money?

Each is counting the people who found it cheaper and moved. Because insurers rate the same driver differently, a driver can be cheaper at one company and dearer at another. The figures are not measured on the same people.

Is an average-savings ad illegal if it only counts people who saved?

We cannot say. State insurance laws prohibit untrue, deceptive or misleading advertising, and what counts as misleading depends on the full ad, its disclosures and the state. The state insurance department can answer for your state, and a licensed attorney can advise on a specific ad.

What should I do with an average I see in an ad?

Treat it as a reason to get a quote, not as a number to plan on. Run the quote for the same coverage as your current policy and compare the totals over the same term.

Key takeaways

  • An advertised average is typically the average saving of new customers who switched and reported saving, over a stated window. It says how the product worked for that group, not for you.
  • Several insurers can each say that people who switched to them saved, because each counts only those who found it cheaper.
  • The footnote carries the method: who was surveyed, when, over what term, and the words "savings will vary."
  • Insurance advertising is mainly regulated by the states. We found no rule setting how an average-savings figure must be computed.
  • Run quotes with identical coverage and the same term. That number is the only one that applies to you.

Sources

Terms used in this guide

Related insurers

Related states

Related guides

Related tools

Latest on this topic