Blog
Florida's 2023 tort reform (HB 837): what changed for car claims
HB 837 changed who can recover after a Florida crash, the time to sue, how medical bills are proved and how bad faith works. Here is the statute, dated.
Florida's 2023 law, CS/CS/HB 837, changed car-accident claims in five ways that matter to drivers: a person found more than 50 percent at fault for their own harm can no longer recover damages, the deadline to sue for negligence dropped from four years to two, a 90-day window now shields an insurer from bad faith claims if it pays limits quickly, medical bills are proved by new rules, and the old one-way attorney fee rule against insurers was repealed. It took effect on March 24, 2023, but not every piece applies to every crash. Rate effects are real but disputed, and the best evidence is dated and partial.
This article walks through each change from the enrolled bill and the current statutes, says which crashes each one reaches, and ends with what to compare at renewal. It is general information, not legal advice. A licensed Florida attorney or the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation is the place for questions about a specific claim.
The basics: what the law is and when it started
HB 837 was a broad civil-remedies bill, not an auto insurance bill. According to the Florida Senate's bill page (checked November 2026), it became Chapter 2023-15, Laws of Florida, with an effective date of March 24, 2023. Its text covers attorney fee calculation, negligence limitations periods, comparative fault, evidence of medical expenses, insurance bad faith and the end of one-way attorney fees in property insurance suits.
Three sections of the enrolled bill decide which cases the new rules reach:
- The change to the limitations statute applies "to causes of action accruing after the effective date."
- Unless the act says otherwise, it applies "to causes of action filed after the effective date."
- It does not impair rights under an insurance contract in effect on or before the effective date; where it affects a contract right, it applies to policies issued or renewed after that date.
That means a crash on March 1, 2023 kept the older four-year deadline, while a crash after March 24, 2023 has the two-year deadline. The comparative fault and evidence rules attach to cases filed after the effective date. Because the bill's drafters treated the limitations period and the other rules differently, a lawyer checks both the crash date and the filing date.
The 51 percent bar: modified comparative negligence
Before 2023, Florida used pure comparative negligence: a driver 90 percent at fault could still recover 10 percent of their damages from the other driver. Section 768.81(6), as amended by section 9 of chapter 2023-15, now says that in a negligence action a party found to be greater than 50 percent at fault for their own harm may not recover any damages. The statute exempts personal injury and wrongful death actions arising from medical negligence under chapter 766.
The practical meaning: fault is a threshold now, not only a discount. For the full mechanics, see modified comparative negligence: how the 50 and 51 percent bars work and the guide comparative vs contributory negligence.
A hypothetical to show the cliff
Suppose a jury finds that Driver A's damages are $100,000. These numbers are invented for illustration.
| Fault assigned to Driver A | Before the bar (pure comparative) | After the bar (greater than 50 percent) |
|---|---|---|
| 30 percent | $70,000 | $70,000 |
| 50 percent | $50,000 | $50,000 |
| 51 percent | $49,000 | $0 |
| 80 percent | $20,000 | $0 |
At exactly 50 percent a plaintiff still recovers, because the statute bars recovery only above 50 percent. Moving from 50 to 51 percent changes the result from $50,000 to nothing. That is why disputes about who ran the light, who braked late or who was speeding now carry more weight in rear-end, left-turn and merge cases.
What the bar does not do
- It does not change what you can collect under your own first-party coverages. Personal injury protection (PIP), collision and uninsured motorist benefits are contract benefits, and the bar addresses a negligence action against someone else. Whether a particular first-party claim is affected is a question for the policy language and a lawyer.
- It does not apply to medical malpractice cases under chapter 766.
- It does not change how fault is decided at the scene or by your insurer. Insurers have always assigned fault percentages when they pay claims. The difference is the stakes if the claim goes to trial.
The two-year deadline to sue
Under the old statute, negligence suits had four years. The enrolled bill's text shows "An action founded on negligence" moved from the "within four years" list to the "within two years" list. The current section 95.11 lists it under "within two years" at subsection (5)(a), and its history note cites chapter 2023-15 (the numbering has shifted since the bill because other subsections were added or moved).
The deadline is for lawsuits, not for reporting a claim. Report the crash to your own insurer promptly under your policy's notice terms. If you want the general framework across states, see statutes of limitations for car accident claims.
Three practical points:
- Count from the crash date, not the date you got the last bill. The statute applies to causes of action accruing after March 24, 2023; for a typical car crash, that is the crash date.
- Other deadlines can be shorter. Policies sometimes set a separate time to sue your own insurer. See suit limitation clauses: the short clock to sue your own insurer.
- A settlement offer does not stop the clock. Unless a written tolling agreement says otherwise, negotiating does not extend the filing deadline.
Bad faith: the 90-day safe harbor and the new duties
Florida's third-party bad faith law lets an insured whose insurer wrongly refused a reasonable chance to settle within limits seek the excess judgment from the insurer. HB 837 amended section 624.155 in four ways that matter to car claims (text checked November 2026):
- A 90-day safe harbor. No bad faith action lies for a liability claim if the insurer tenders the lesser of the policy limits or the amount demanded within 90 days after receiving actual notice of a claim accompanied by sufficient evidence to support the amount. If it does not tender in that window, the 90-day period and the safe-harbor rule cannot be used as evidence of bad faith, and the statute of limitations is extended another 90 days.
- Mere negligence is not bad faith. The statute says mere negligence alone is insufficient.
- Claimants have a duty too. The insured, claimant and their representatives must act in good faith in giving information, making demands, setting deadlines and trying to settle. A fact finder may reduce damages against the insurer if they did not.
- Competing claims. When several claimants may exceed the limits from one crash, an insurer avoids excess liability if, within 90 days of notice of the competing claims, it files an interpleader or uses binding arbitration, as the statute describes.
For drivers, the safe harbor changes the leverage in time-limited demands. A demand letter that gives the insurer 10 days to pay limits is judged against a statute that now gives the insurer 90 days after sufficient evidence. See time-limited policy limits demands and bad faith setups for how those letters work and bad faith or just a disagreement: what counts as insurer misconduct for the line between a dispute and misconduct.
If you are the insured on the receiving end of an excess-limits demand, the statute still expects your insurer to act fairly. The safe harbor protects the insurer who pays in time; it does not protect one who ignores an obviously valid claim. A Florida attorney can say how the 90 days apply to a given file.
Medical bills: what a jury can now see
The most technical change is new section 768.0427, created by the bill. In personal injury and wrongful death actions it controls evidence of medical expenses (summary of the statute as checked November 2026):
- Paid bills. For expenses already paid, evidence is limited to the amount actually paid, whoever paid it.
- Unpaid bills. For charges not yet paid, evidence can reflect what the claimant's health coverage would pay plus the claimant's share. For claimants without coverage or with Medicare or Medicaid, the statute uses benchmark rates of 120 percent of Medicare, or 170 percent of Medicaid where there is no Medicare rate. Reasonable billed amounts for necessary care also remain admissible.
- Letters of protection. A letter of protection is an arrangement where a provider treats a patient and waits for payment from a settlement. Before claiming those expenses, the claimant must disclose the letter, itemized billing with procedure codes, any factoring company that bought the receivable and its price, whether the claimant had health coverage, and whether the claimant was referred to the provider and by whom.
- Future care. Future medical expenses use similar coverage-based amounts or benchmarks, plus reasonable future billed amounts.
- A ceiling. Recoverable medical damages cannot exceed the evidence admitted at trial and are capped at paid amounts, amounts still owed at trial and reasonable future care.
Why this matters to a driver: if you treat on a letter of protection after a crash, expect your lawyer to gather the paperwork that the statute lists. If you have health insurance, using it may change what evidence of your bills is admissible. Ask your attorney before choosing, because the best path depends on the injury and the provider.
Attorney fees: what ended and what did not
Section 11 of the enrolled bill repealed section 627.428 and section 626.9373, the statutes that required insurers to pay a prevailing policyholder's attorney fees. Section 5 created section 624.1552, which, per the bill text, applies the offer-of-judgment statute (768.79) to civil actions involving an insurance contract. Section 1 amended section 57.104 so that a lodestar fee is presumed sufficient and reasonable, and the bill also bars a contingency risk multiplier in certain fee calculations.
Two things follow:
- The repeal of one-way fees mostly affects suits against your own insurer, such as disputes over collision, PIP or uninsured motorist benefits. The bill's section 29 says it applies to contracts issued or renewed after the effective date, so an older policy was treated differently from a renewal.
- This is a change to who pays lawyers, not a change to what the policy covers.
If your own claim is disputed, see first-party vs third-party claims and the guide insurance bad faith explained.
The seat belt rule: what HB 837 did not change
The plan for this article asked about a seat belt evidence rule. I searched the enrolled bill text for "seat" and "restraint" and found no provision on seat belts. The rule on seat belts in civil cases is older. Section 316.614(10) says a seat belt violation is not negligence per se, not prima facie evidence of negligence and not to be considered in mitigation of damages, but may be considered as evidence of comparative negligence in a civil action.
Combine that with the 51 percent bar and the stakes rise: any fault assigned for not wearing a belt adds to the plaintiff's share, which now matters more near the 50 percent line. A different state's approach is in the seat belt defense: when not buckling up cuts your claim.
Claimed and measured effects on premiums
Supporters said the law would reduce litigation costs and, through them, premiums. The evidence so far is dated and partly advocacy.
- Regulator data. The Florida Office of Insurance Regulation said on March 5, 2026 that the five largest personal auto groups, about 78 percent of the market, were indicating an average rate change of -8.0 percent for 2026 as of February. Its release reports a personal auto liability loss ratio of 52.5 percent in 2025, the lowest in 15 years, and physical damage loss ratios of 112.0 percent in 2022, 70.3 percent in 2023, 66.7 percent in 2024 and 49.5 percent in 2025. A loss ratio is claims paid divided by premium earned. The release credits "historic legislative reforms" and does not name HB 837.
- Modeled estimate. A February 2026 report by The Perryman Group, covered by Insurance Journal, estimated that Florida's property-casualty insurance costs are about 14.5 percent lower than they would have been without the 2022 and 2023 reforms. That is a computer-modeled counterfactual, it covers all property-casualty lines rather than car insurance alone, and a trade association (APCIA) praised it.
- What neither proves. Loss ratios and rates also move with repair costs, used-car prices, weather, claim frequency and insurer decisions. An easing could reflect several causes. Neither source isolates HB 837.
Treat any claim that "the law cut your premium by X" skeptically. Your own rate depends on your insurer's filing, your record, your car, your ZIP code and your limits.
What to compare and do at renewal
- Pull your renewal and compare it with last year's. The renewal rate increase checker helps size the change.
- Ask whether the insurer filed a Florida decrease. Rate filings are public through the Office of Insurance Regulation; ask the agent whether your rate reflects a recent change and when.
- Reconsider bodily injury and uninsured motorist limits. If you are more than 50 percent at fault you cannot recover from the other driver, but your own uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage and medical payments or PIP are separate benefits. Check the limits with the state car insurance requirements lookup and your declarations page.
- Get at least three quotes. Use the car insurance quote comparison worksheet so the same limits and deductibles are compared. Then search for quotes before your renewal date.
- Keep records of any crash. Photos, the police report, the other driver's insurer, and the dates, because both the limitations period and the 90-day bad faith window count from dates you can prove.
Common questions
Does HB 837 apply to my crash?
If the crash happened after March 24, 2023, the two-year deadline applies to it. The other changes apply to cases filed after that date. A crash before that date may follow different rules. A Florida attorney can confirm.
Can I still recover if I was partly at fault?
Yes, as long as a jury or the settlement process does not assign you more than 50 percent. If you are assigned 50 percent or less, your damages are reduced by your share. Above 50 percent, the statute bars recovery from the other party.
Did the law raise or lower my premium?
It did not set rates. The regulator reported average indicated decreases for the largest groups in 2026 and credits legislative reforms, but it did not attribute the change to HB 837 by name, and other factors moved at the same time.
Does my own insurer still have to pay my collision or PIP claim?
Your policy decides that. The comparative fault bar addresses negligence suits against other parties. The fee repeal changed who pays lawyers in disputes with your insurer. See your policy and a licensed attorney for a specific dispute.
Key takeaways
- HB 837 took effect March 24, 2023; the two-year negligence deadline applies to causes of action accruing after that date.
- A party found more than 50 percent at fault for their own harm recovers nothing in a negligence action under section 768.81(6).
- Section 624.155 now gives insurers a 90-day safe harbor to tender limits, and claimants must also act in good faith.
- Section 768.0427 changes how medical bills are proved, including disclosure requirements for letters of protection.
- Rate evidence so far is regulator data and a modeled estimate; neither proves HB 837 alone moved your premium.
Sources
- Florida Senate: CS/CS/HB 837 (2023) bill page, effective date March 24, 2023 and Chapter 2023-15, checked November 2026.
- Florida House: enrolled CS/CS/HB 837 text, applicability sections, limitations shift, bad faith, fee repeal, checked November 2026.
- Florida Statutes section 768.81, greater percentage of fault bar, checked November 2026.
- Florida Statutes section 95.11, two-year negligence period, checked November 2026.
- Florida Statutes section 768.0427, medical expense evidence and letters of protection, checked November 2026.
- Florida Statutes section 624.155, bad faith safe harbor and claimant duties, checked November 2026.
- Florida Statutes section 316.614, seat belt evidence in civil actions, checked November 2026.
- Florida OIR: auto rate decreases for top 5 groups, March 5, 2026, indicated rate change and loss ratios, checked November 2026.
- Insurance Journal: Florida insurance costs 14.5% lower than without reforms, report finds, Perryman modeled estimate and caveats, checked November 2026 (trade press; no primary report opened).