Blog
Do membership dues pay off? AAA, Farm Bureau and other clubs
How to decide whether AAA, Farm Bureau or similar club dues are worth it when the insurance is tied to membership, with a break-even method and examples.
Membership dues pay off only when what you use from the club, plus any insurance saving, is worth more than the fee, and the comparison has to include the dues in the price of the insurance. A club policy that looks $30 cheaper before dues can be $5 more expensive after them. The method below turns that into a few lines of arithmetic you can run on your own quotes.
Clubs and insurers are different organizations
The first source of confusion is that the club and the insurer share a brand. They are separate legal entities with separate bills.
AAA is a federation of regional auto clubs. Each club chooses which insurer writes its members' car insurance, so a AAA policy in one region comes from a different company than a AAA policy in another. Our guide to AAA car insurance: how the clubs and their insurers work covers the three large groups, including AAA and AAA. The membership you buy from the club is not insurance; it is a service plan, and the insurance is a second purchase.
Farm Bureau works the same way. Each state has a Farm Bureau federation, a voluntary membership organization that advocates for agriculture and rural families, and in many states an affiliated insurer sells auto, home and life coverage to members. In Tennessee, for instance, the Farm Bureau says that although you do not have to be a farmer, you must be a member of the Tennessee Farm Bureau to buy its auto or property insurance. Our profiles of Farm Bureau Insurance of Tennessee and North Carolina Farm Bureau Insurance show how the arrangement looks state by state, and Farm Bureau insurance: membership, eligibility and how it works lays out the general model.
Other clubs follow the same pattern: a membership organization, an affiliated or contracted insurer, and a rule that says whether you need to belong. The Hartford's AARP program is one example, covered in The AARP auto insurance program from The Hartford.
The practical point is that dues are a cost of the insurance relationship when membership is required, and a separate purchase when it is optional. You should treat the two cases differently.
What dues actually buy
AAA
AAA's roadside tiers are the clearest example of dues buying a measurable service. As of November 2026, AAA Mountain West Group's membership pricing page lists annual prices of $64.99 for Classic, $99.99 for Plus and $124.99 for Premier, with lower prices for additional household members in California, Nevada, Arizona and Utah. Each plan includes four roadside service calls a year. Towing runs to 5 miles on Classic and 100 miles on Plus, and Premier adds one tow of up to 200 miles a year. AAA's own explainer on the value of membership adds that lockout reimbursement is up to $50 on Classic, $100 on Plus and $150 on Premier, and that prices "vary depending on where you live." Other clubs charge different prices, so use your own club's page.
Memberships also carry retail, travel and repair discounts, and at some clubs other services. Those are real benefits only if you use them.
Farm Bureau
Farm Bureau dues are smaller and buy less that you can price. Tennessee Farm Bureau lists membership at $30 per family, including discounts on goods and services, health and safety programs, a magazine and a savings app. North Carolina Farm Bureau's member benefits page lists $25 a year, with savings of up to 20% on hotel stays and up to 30% off Avis base rates, and says membership provides access to its insurance with a personally assigned local agent. The dues also support the federation's advocacy, which some members value as a purpose in itself.
Roadside help is uneven. North Carolina Farm Bureau Insurance says on its common questions page that it has no roadside assistance program, and that towing and labor is an optional endorsement at extra cost, paid by reimbursement for one tow per disablement. Oklahoma Farm Bureau, by contrast, includes Roadside Rescue with membership: up to $75 per occurrence, up to three covered service calls a year, for current members and immediate family in the household, according to the federation. In other words, whether Farm Bureau dues buy roadside value depends on your state. The mechanics of roadside assistance and the choice between club and insurer add-on are in roadside assistance coverage vs auto club membership.
Required, discounted or optional: three kinds of club insurance
| Model | How it works | Dues treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Membership required to buy | The insurer sells only to members: the AAA insurance groups and most Farm Bureau insurers | Dues are a fixed add-on to every premium comparison |
| Membership earns a discount | The insurer gives a price reduction for belonging, such as AAA Mountain West Group's listed discount of up to 5% for an active membership | Subtract the discount, then add the dues |
| Membership optional or cosmetic | The insurer sells to anyone, but a club or group has an agreement that unlocks perks | Dues matter only if you want the club for its own sake |
Two cautions. First, a "required" rule can change. In September 2024 Country Financial told Illinois customers that it was dropping the Farm Bureau membership requirement for non-farm policyholders. As WGLT reported, the company said the requirement had frustrated non-farm customers for a decade, and the article notes that a customer who missed it could end up with a canceled policy. The American Farm Bureau Federation responded by expelling the Illinois federation, and the Illinois federation sued. The article put membership at about $20 a year, with $5 going to the national body. The episode shows that membership is a commercial arrangement between organizations that can be renegotiated, not a law of nature.
Second, requirements vary by company within the same system. COUNTRY Financial sells in 19 states under different arrangements; do not assume the rule that applies to your cousin's Farm Bureau policy applies to yours.
A break-even method you can run in ten minutes
Follow these steps for each club insurer you are considering.
- Get a quote for the exact coverage you want, using the same liability limits, uninsured motorist limits and deductibles you will use elsewhere. Fill in the car insurance quote comparison worksheet.
- Write down the premium with every discount applied, including any membership discount.
- Add the dues for everyone who needs a membership. If two adults want separate AAA memberships, count both. If a household membership covers all of you, count one.
- Subtract only the benefits you would otherwise pay for. If the club includes roadside help and you would otherwise add a roadside endorsement to a competitor's policy, subtract what that endorsement would cost. Do not subtract hotel discounts you will never use.
- Compare the adjusted total against the best non-club quote, plus the cost of replacing any benefit you would lose.
- Run it a second way. Ask whether you would join the club anyway. If yes, the dues are already spent and the comparison is the premium alone. If no, the dues belong in the price.
Written as a formula: club total = premium + dues − value of benefits you would actually buy; other total = premium + cost of replacing those benefits.
Worked example: AAA
These numbers are hypothetical, except that the Plus price echoes the AAA Mountain West list. A driver gets a quote from a AAA insurer at $1,480 for the year, with a membership discount already applied, and a quote from another insurer at $1,510 for identical coverage.
- Buying AAA Plus at $99.99, the club total is $1,579.99.
- The other insurer's roadside endorsement would cost, say, $30, so its total is $1,540.
On the first lens the non-club insurer is $39.99 cheaper. Now ask whether the driver would buy AAA Plus anyway, for the 100-mile towing and the lockout reimbursement. If so, the other insurer's total is $1,510 + $99.99 = $1,609.99, and the AAA insurer is $129.99 cheaper. The answer flips depending on whether the membership was going to be bought regardless, which is why step 6 matters.
Worked example: Farm Bureau
Also hypothetical. A Farm Bureau insurer quotes $1,395 and a national insurer quotes $1,430 for the same coverage. Membership is $30.
- Farm Bureau total: $1,425.
- National insurer: $1,430.
The gap is $5, which is less than the difference one change in your garaging address or one ticket could create. If you will also bundle a home policy, compare bundled totals, because the multi-policy discount may be larger on one side. If you value the hotel and car-rental discounts and would use them, the benefits might tilt the balance, but price that at the amount you actually spend, not the headline percentage. A Farm Bureau policy that is about a third of a percent cheaper after dues is a tie, and the tie-breakers are service, claims reputation and financial strength.
The cheaper club is not always the cheaper insurance
Dues can distort a comparison in both directions.
- Dues hide in a separate bill. A premium quote online may not include the membership fee, which arrives from a different organization on a different schedule. Ask the agent to give you both numbers in writing.
- A club can be the better service even at a slightly higher price. Local agents and adjusters are the draw of many Farm Bureau insurers. That is hard to put a dollar figure on, but it counts.
- Rate comparisons need the whole household. A membership that covers "family members in your household" may be a better deal if several adults will use it than one that charges per person.
- Dues often rise. Check the renewal price of the membership as well as the premium, since both can change annually.
If you are trying to understand why prices differ between insurers at all, our post on who really underwrites an affinity or group auto program explains who carries the risk behind a group's name, and the guide to affinity, employer and occupation discounts covers programs you may qualify for without paying dues.
What happens to your policy if the membership lapses
This is the question most people discover too late.
When membership is required, the insurer can treat a lapse as a reason to non-renew. Because the club is a separate organization with its own renewal notice, a missed dues payment can interrupt eligibility even when the insurance premium is current. The Illinois episode above shows the concern: WGLT reported that a customer who missed the membership requirement could end up with a canceled policy. How the insurer must notify you depends on your state's rules for nonrenewal and cancellation, and your state insurance department can tell you what applies.
Clubs often allow a catch-up window. AAA East Central's member guide, for example, says renewal payments are accepted up to 90 days after a membership's expiration date, and that renewing in that window keeps the original membership number and join date; if you do not renew, you buy a new membership that may carry non-refundable fees. That is one club's rule. Your club's terms and your insurer's policy may differ, and the sources do not describe what any AAA insurer does with an auto policy during that window, so ask directly.
Questions to ask before you sign:
- Is membership a condition of the policy, and what happens at renewal if it lapses?
- Who bills the dues, and can they be paid with the premium?
- Is there a grace period, and what notice will I receive?
- If I leave the club, can I stay with the insurer at a different price?
- Does the premium I was quoted include the dues, or are they extra?
When the answer is clearly no, and clearly yes
Dues are hard to justify when you would never use the club's services, the insurance saving is under the dues, and the insurer has no service edge that matters to you. They are easy to justify when you would buy the membership anyway, when the insurer's quote beats the field by more than the dues, or when you place real value on a local agent and the insurer also performs well on claims. For the middle ground, the six-step method is the tool.
Common questions
Do I have to be a farmer to join Farm Bureau?
No. Tennessee Farm Bureau says farmers and non-farmers alike can buy insurance if they are members, and several state federations say the same. Membership still has to be paid for each year.
Does AAA insurance require AAA membership?
For the three large AAA insurance groups described in our guide, yes. Membership is a separate purchase from your club, and some groups give a discount for it. Other insurers may sell policies at AAA offices, so check the name of the company on your quote.
Is the club's roadside service a replacement for the roadside coverage on my car insurance?
They overlap, so you rarely need both. Club service follows you, while an insurer endorsement follows the car; see roadside assistance coverage vs auto club membership. A related post, Out of charge on the road: EV towing, roadside help and coverage, looks at what an electric vehicle changes about towing.
Can I avoid dues by choosing a non-club insurer?
Yes, most insurers sell without membership. The right comparison is still the all-in cost. A cheaper club policy can exist; the dues just have to be part of the math.
Key takeaways
- Clubs and their insurers are separate organizations with separate bills; dues are an extra cost whenever the insurer requires membership.
- Compare the premium plus dues, minus the value of benefits you would otherwise pay for, against the best non-club quote.
- Ask whether you would join the club anyway; if so, the comparison is premium against premium.
- AAA dues buy roadside tiers priced by region; Farm Bureau dues buy smaller perks, and roadside value depends on the state.
- Ask what happens if the membership lapses before you sign, because a missed dues payment can cost you the policy.